Normie Saviors and the Long Hand of Donald Trump

**FILE** A March 5. 2008 file photo shows former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert visiting the Illinois House of Representatives floor at the state Capitol in Springfield, Ill. The former Illinois lawmaker, whose ei... **FILE** A March 5. 2008 file photo shows former U.S. House Speaker Dennis Hastert visiting the Illinois House of Representatives floor at the state Capitol in Springfield, Ill. The former Illinois lawmaker, whose eight-year tenure as Speaker of the House was the longest of any Republican, is on a new career path less than a year after retiring from Congress, where he lost his leadership title when Democrats won control. The 66-year-old has taken the position of "senior adviser" to the law and lobbying firm of Dickstein Shapiro LP, where he has worked for the past month as a member of its public policy and law practice unit. Federal law barred Hastert from lobbying for a year after his retirement last November. (AP Photo/Seth Perlman, File) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

I mentioned in this week’s podcast that the current state of the House GOP Speaker debacle-ship reminds me of the day Denny Hastert became Speaker. Hard on the heels of a disappointing (Clinton-Lewinsky) scandal mid-term, in rapid succession one Speaker and one Speaker designate were blown out of the water by extra-marital affairs. In a rush to safety, as the financial journalists have it, Rep. Denny Hastert was elected Speaker essentially by affirmation. The one thing Republicans wanted more than anything was a return to calm and Hastert’s biography and demeanor offered it. Certainly someone as frumpy and avuncular as normie embodiment Hastert wouldn’t be off cheating on his wife or bringing the caucus into disrepute. So Hastert it was.

Obviously, it didn’t turn out quite as expected. But that’s how it looked at the time.

Of the nine Republicans now vying to be Speaker, the man who comes closest to fitting that model is Rep. Tom Emmer of Minnesota. First of all he’s a current member of the leadership, actually the last one standing after the successive falls of McCarthy, Scalise and Jordan. And it’s difficult to emphasize how much of a norm it is that new congressional leaders come from the leadership line of succession. Whip becomes Majority Leader, Majority Leader become Speaker. The 1998 trauma response to make Hastert Leader was a slight departure. But he was Chief Deputy Whip, so a junior or second tier member of the leadership.

Emmer is also a non-bomb thrower and checks a lot of other calmness boxes. He voted to certify the 2020 election. He voted for the various deals averting debt defaults and government shutdowns. If you want to end the drama, he’s your guy. The only other contenders who are even adjacent to leadership are Kevin Hern, head of the Republican Study Committee and Mike Johnson, the Vice Chair of the Conference.

But Donald Trump is lobbying against him. As Kate Riga notes here, Trump’s influence is easy to overstate. He pushed for Jim Jordan and look how he ended up. Even Trump’s election endorsements tend to be timed to get a clear sense of a probable winner and swoop in to get the credit. But he’s certainly not without influence.

One detail to note is that a plurality winner can’t win the caucus leadership election. You have to win a majority. Especially in this context that’s critical. With nine candidates, someone could become the caucus choice with 30 votes. With nine candidates, that almost certainly means multiple votes with the lowest vote getter eliminated in each round. Absent Trump’s role I would figure Emmer would win and maybe quickly. That’s not because he’s so popular or able necessarily. He’s just the most obvious port in the storm. A number of the other candidates have only been in Congress a handful of terms. But Trump’s role at least complicates it.

While the eight who dethroned McCarthy were never going to agree to recant their actions and take him back, I have to imagine there is galactic pressure on them now to let this end. But at least in my limited understanding of the internal dynamics of the House GOP caucus, Emmer is at least arguably more of a squish than McCarthy. So they go through all this only to end up back where they started or even with a more deal-friendly Speaker. To be clear, Emmer isn’t some paragon of pre-Trump or pre-Freedom Caucus Republicanism. We’re talking here about very thin shades of difference. And it’s quite possible it’s a shade so fine that I’m not catching a lot of the nuance. But it would certainly seem like a big disappointment to the Trump lovers after a Jordan Speakership seemed within reach.

Here I’m talking about whether Emmer can get to a majority of the caucus. But the obvious and still unresolved question at the heart of this whole story is whether he could get 217 votes on the floor.

We’ll see soon enough!

Latest Editors' Blog
  • |
    May 29, 2024 1:09 p.m.

    Before we get a verdict, it’s important to recognize that this is justice, regardless of whatever the verdict is. It…

  • |
    May 29, 2024 11:04 a.m.

    Follow along with our Trump trial live blog right here.

  • |
    May 29, 2024 10:59 a.m.

    Alas, our beloved co-host Kate is sick, so there will be no podcast this week. See you all next week…

  • |
    May 28, 2024 11:28 p.m.

    I wanted to give you a brief update on the server outage we had off and on for much of…

Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: