Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
04.16.08 | 8:36 pm
Live Debate Bloggin’

8:36 PM … So I’m coming in a bit late here. I was on the Polk panel this evening at Long Island University, which ended at 8 PM. And rushed home to get here. So what’d I miss?

8:44 PM … Hillary: The Republicans are so bad that I have to become one to save the Democratic party.

8:48 PM … Can Hillary just come out and embrace a culture-war, swift-boating campaign against Obama? Please? Instead of this gonzo Lee Atwater by proxy stuff? Sigh…

9:01 PM … She certainly seems more self-assured on the Iran question than Obama did. The question of extending an American security umbrella to Israel is very dicey. And he could clearly see he was on delicate territory. Are we really extending to Israel and Saudi Arabia the nuclear guarantee we made to Europe under NATO? Is it only for nuclear attacks? Conventional attacks?

9:09 PM … Obama’s making a good point on the capital gains tax. But he’s making it in a very bedraggled, painful, drawn out way. This is not good at all. All the right points are there but just not put well … Charlie Gibson’s ‘history’ of the capital gains tax? Please. There’s a good answer to that. But he didn’t seem to have it.

9:16 PM … Did someone tell Charlie Gibson that he knows something about economics? There are a heck of a lot of people people who make over $97,000 a year? Really? I think like 12% of the population makes more than $100,000 a year. And his capital gains point is a canard.

9:24 PM … I was disappointed that Charlie Gibson seems to spout off right-wing bromides as established facts. I was even more disappointed that Obama didn’t seem able to knock them down.

9:29 PM … I don’t watch a lot of nightly news. Is Charlie Gibson usually this bad?

9:31 PM … This is awful.

9:35 PM … Are there any questions in this debate that aren’t based on Republican attacks? Is affirmative action a major issue in this campaign? Did I miss that?

9:40 PM … I like Stephanopoulos. But using former presidents? Is this a major issue?

9:44 PM … TPM Reader KB checks in: “Josh, ABC’s News’ posture tonight makes perfect sense. Don’t you get it? In GOP primary debates the media inquisitors take on the role of the true conservative pressing candidates to clearly and unequivocally state their answers on hot button social issues and economic talismans like the capital gains tax. In Democratic primary debates, by contrast, the media inquisitors take on the role of the true conservative pressing candidates to clearly and unequivocally state their answers on hot button social issues and economic talismans like the capital gains tax.” Now MB gets in the mix: “When gas hits $4 a gallon will the average American making $250,000 a year be able to afford to drive to work?”

9:46 PM … No Charlie. It hasn’t been a “fascinating debate.” It’s been genuinely awful.

9:50 PM … What happened to the League of Women Voters? Can we give the debates back to them? This sort of episode really sickens me. KB’s point above is sadly accurate. It’s stuff like this that really makes me think that whole big chunks of the established press needs to be swept away.

9:56 PM … As I noted above, I missed roughly the first half hour of this debate. But from what I heard about those thirty minutes and what I saw of the subsequent ninety minutes was basically debate by gotcha line with basically no discussion of any of the big questions the election is turning on.

04.16.08 | 7:49 pm
Keystone Debate Blogging

Is this really the 26th Democratic presidential debate of this cycle?

No wonder we all groan at the mention of another debate. But it’s been about six weeks since the last one (if you don’t count the faith forum whatchamacallit the other night), so we’re good to go.

Standing by for 8 ET start . . .

7:59 PM … Can we expect the candidates to bring any blue collar props on stage? A bowling ball? Maybe a shot glass?

Josh will be joining us later. He has other professional obligations at the moment.

8:00 PM … No Wolf? No Tim Russert? Peace.

8:02 PM … No blue collar props. Maybe they’re packing heat.

8:05 PM … Amy Poehler’s Hillary is so dead-on that I can’t watch Hillary speak without conflating the two in my mind.

8:06 PM … Blessedly short opening statements. Someone must have reminded the candidates that this is the 26th time they’ve done this.

8:07 PM … Commercial break. A good time to point out that ABC is imposing a blackout on its debate footage until tomorrow morning — or trying to.

8:08 PM … Charlie Gibson stumps them right off the bat with Mario Cuomo’s suggestion that the winner pledge to make the loser his or her running mate.

8:11 PM … By “stumps,” I mean moment of awkward silence. They both manage to avoid answering the question directly.

8:12 PM … Straight to the bitter clingers question . . .

8:14 PM … Obama addressed the question and admitted he “mangled” his words but seemed defensive — and didn’t really address the subtext to the question.

8:15 PM … For a moment, I thought Hillary was going to throw back a shot of whiskey before answering the question.

8:18 PM … Here he goes. Obama circles back to elitism and condescending subtext.

8:22 PM … He got in a few shots about Hillary learning the “wrong lessons” and adopting GOP campaign tactics. She only mildly engaged, also sidestepping the subtext of the charge.

8:26 PM … The Wright question to Obama almost seems like a blast from the past. But oddly enough, I think the Wright controversy erupted between the last debate and this one, so first time Obama had a chance to be quizzed on this in a debate.

8:28 PM … Ding, ding, ding, ding. Hillary just invoked 9/11 in explaining how Wright would have been “intolerable” to her as her pastor.

8:32 PM … Speaking of mangled, I doubt Obama meant to say he “disowned” Wright.

8:33 PM … Another blast from the past: Tuzla.

8:36 PM … Both candidates seemed unprepared in a sense for a reprise of these earlier gaffes. Getting bogged down in the minutiae.

04.16.08 | 6:28 pm
TPMtv: Stupidest Guy on Earth Speaks Out

The President bears the greatest responsibility for the catastrophe of the Iraq war. He was the key decision maker at every point. And he’s fundamentally accountable. But if you look into the innards of the process that led to war there is probably no one who was either responsible for or involved with more of the bad decisions, more of the conscious decisions or horrible ideas than Doug Feith.

You’d think someone like that would be keeping a low profile. But in fact he’s got a new book out explaining how Iraq was a great idea, how nothing was his fault and sticking it to his enemies. Trainwreck is an overused term, but in today’s episode of TPMtv we look at some choice moments from Feith’s book release media tour where he explains how you’ve got the whole thing all wrong …

High-res version at Veracifier.com.

04.16.08 | 6:02 pm
Doomed to Repeat the Past?

John Judis, on the historical currents Obama is swimming against.

04.16.08 | 4:03 pm
Debate!

In case you hadn’t heard there’s a Democratic debate tonight, starting at 8 PM on ABC. And we’ll be blogging it live here at TPM. This could be the final debate, though of course, that’s been the case with the last three or four. So no promises.

04.16.08 | 3:44 pm
So Proud, So Proud …

Netanyahu: Israel benefiting from 9/11 and Iraq War.

04.16.08 | 3:15 pm
Tips

As I mentioned last week, we’re refocusing our attention on the congressional races. And for the kind of coverage we’re trying to provide we really want and need your tips — the kind of leads and insights that only you can have because you’re watching the media in your area. For more on the kind of tips we’re looking for, please see this earlier post. And accept our thanks in advance.

04.16.08 | 3:04 pm
An insightful analysis on

An insightful analysis on what the polls show and the “bitter” controversy from one of our reader-bloggers at TPMCafe.

04.16.08 | 2:07 pm
Wonder What That’s About

With the new campaign money numbers out we’re awash in stats showing Democratic candidates with lots more money raised and money on hand. That’s why this stands out a little. In the rematch between Jeanne Shaheen and Sen. John Sununu, he actually has more than twice the money on hand that she does, $4.3 to $ 2 million.

04.16.08 | 12:40 pm
Bitter Sweet For Hillary

Just to give you an idea of how much of an opening the Hillary camp sees Obama’s bitter gaffe giving her in Pennsylvania, her “small town” ad is the only spot she has running in most of the TV markets in the state, TPM Election Central reports.