TPM Reader BA finds himself befuddled:
Continues to boggle my mind what a difference 4 years can make to the conservatives.
1996: Bob Dole is a war hero! Clinton is a draft dodger! WORSHIP THE WAR HERO!
2000: Forget the war! Ignore the potential Vietnam-era AWOL-ness of our candidate, and his complete lack of foreign policy knowledge! He’s got integrity!
2004: So what your candidate actually fought and was injured in the same war during which our candidate was so very much NOT AWOL! We mock his service and question the legitimacy of his injuries! Have a purple band-aid to wear at our convention!
2008: Only a certified war hero can lead this country! WORSHIP THE WAR HERO!
A number of readers have either suggested or explained that what the Obama camp is trying to do is have its cake and eat it too, make sounds of disapproval, such as President Bush did in 2004 with respect to the Swift Boaters, while still gaining advantage from them.
Perhaps. But that’s not what I’m seeing.
I’ve also seen suggestions that Obama must either reject Clark’s comments or vehemently restate them. But that’s nonsense. There’s nothing to be gained for the candidate to be critical of McCain in this regard. He can keep repeating his praise for McCain’s service and time as a POW, which he should do and is not in conflict in any way with anything that Clark said.
What his campaign should not be doing is lending its imprimatur to the proposition that because McCain saw combat in Vietnam and suffered as a POW that he has the judgment to be an effective president.
Late Update: As an example, TPM Reader SS writes …
Am I the only one who thinks that the Obama campaign is winning big here and that the media is being played badly? The conversation has begun – “it’s out there” as they say – does McCain’s record as a (not-very-good) fighter jock and POW more than thirty years ago in some way qualify him to be Commander-in-Chief? At the same time, Obama “rejects the statement” and “honors and respects Senator McCain’s service.” How is Obama hurt by this? How is McCain? And now we can let the bloviators compare this honest question to what was done to John Kerry. Remember how Kerry’s record was fair game because he brought it up and Bush and Rove pretended like they had nothing to do with the SBVT? Obama seems to have learned the new rules. As a friend of mine likes to say, if I were having any more fun, I’d have to be twins.
As I say above, if they’re on this, great. Experience has taught me not to take it for granted.
CNN’s Rick Sanchez: Clark, “dissing, some might say swift-boating, John McCain’s military record” …
Among the targets in Obama’s patriotism speech today: MoveOn and elements of the ’60s counterculture.
To make his case today about why Gen. Clark’s comments were out of bounds, the McCain campaign chose an actual member of the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth bamboozlement squad. Speaking for the McCain campaign, Col. Bud Day actually defended the SBVT’s campaign as “the truth.”
We were just chatting here at the office about what’s behind the Obama campaign’s rapid rejection of Wes Clark’s statements. The read from those in touch with the Obama campaign seemed to be that they don’t want to get into a conversation that focuses attention on McCain’s war record and/or experience.
If that’s the case, it’s more troubling than it appears on the surface. I can think of a lot of other reasons why they might not want to get into this. Maybe they think it conflicts with the ‘new politics’ message they’re trying to push. Or perhaps they think the wind’s at their back or they don’t want the subject to be changed.
But if it really is a fear of getting things focused on McCain’s war record or experience it really is the kind of mistake Democrats habitually make. Take a look. McCain’s entire campaign is about his time as a POW and the claim that his war service makes him uniquely qualified to be the country’s commander-in-chief. They’re pushing the fact that he’s been on the national stage for four decades, whereas Obama’s only been there for four years. That is almost the entirety of his campaign. So it’s out there. It’s already a key focus of this campaign.
John McCain’s claim to experience, based in large part on his military service, is a key issue in this campaign. Ignoring it doesn’t make it go away.
Did Wes Clark call into question John McCain’s war record? Did he say any element of it wasn’t true, honorable, anything? Here’s ABC News political director Rick Klein guest blogging at Jake Tapper’s ABC blog …
Retired Gen. Wesley Clark went where no Democrat really truly wants to go on Sunday — calling into question, in surprisingly sharp language, Sen. John McCain’s military record.
Obama campaign on Clark …
“As he’s said many times before, Senator Obama honors and respects Senator McCain’s service, and of course he rejects yesterday’s statement by General Clark,” said Obama campaign spokesman Bill Burton.
Late Update: McCain just made his comments on this, sort of implicitly buying into the lie that Clark was attacking his military service.
It’s not surprising. But it is an example of the fatuous McCain worship that is the bread and butter of the Washington press corps that Wes Clark’s comments this weekend on Face the Nation are being called ‘swift-boating’. It’s almost comical, but not much less than Bob Schieffer’s incredulous responses to the fact that Clark had the temerity to argue that McCain’s experience as a Navy pilot and a POW don’t necessarily mean he’d be a good president.
We have this in today’s Sunday Show round up. But I want to show you the Clark interview at length to show what he actually said.
The McCain campaign is now launching an attack with its ‘truth squad’ about the Clark ‘controversy’ and pushing Obama to “denounce” Clark, etc. It’ll be interesting to watch what happens here. The McCain campaign’s angle here is to not to prevent attacks on the integrity of McCain’s war record (which Clark explicitly did not do) but to make it off limits for anyone to question that his war-time experience means he has the temperament and experience which make him the better qualified candidate to be president.
The McCain campaign’s claim that there’s any attack here on McCain’s war record is simply a lie — a simple attempt to fool people. This is an essential point to this entire campaign — does McCain’s military record mean that even the Democrats have to concede the point that he’s more qualified to be commander-in-chief of the US armed forces, that his foreign and national security policy judgment is superior to Obama’s? It’s simply a fact that McCain has a record of really poor judgment on a whole list of key foreign policy and national security questions.
This is one of those moments in the campaign where the nonsense from the chief DC press sachems is so palpable and overwhelming that everyone who cares about this contest needs to jump into the breach and demand that they answer why no one can question whether McCain’s war record makes him more qualified to be president and whether he has good foreign policy and national security judgment.
Here’s the video …
Can someone find the outrage?
(ed.note: Please be on the lookout for reporters who refer to this as ‘swift-boating’ and let us know who and when.)