On Monday the McCain campaign is going to put out a paper promising to balance the federal budget deficit by the end of McCain’s first term. Much will be written tomorrow about just how preposterous the budgeting claims are, especially since McCain is also promising a big new round of tax cuts.
But there’s one gem I want to zero in on — this line, as quoted from Mike Allen’s piece just out in The Politico …
The McCain administration would reserve all savings from victory in the Iraq and Afghanistan operations in the fight against Islamic extremists for reducing the deficit. Since all their costs were financed with deficit spending, all their savings must go to deficit reduction.
How much does he expect those savings are going to come to? Is this a line item in the savings tally?
This has to be one of the better examples of McCain’s penchant for policy by slogan seeping out from the campaign trail into actual policy proposals.
McCain’s people do realize that there is no budget mark down for ‘victory’. Whatever victory’s other merits, it is only reductions in expenditures directed (in the broadest sense) toward the war zones that get you actual budget savings.
Is McCain saying that both wars will be over by the end of his first term? And if so, is that victory with all or most of the troops staying on post-victory, as he’s implied? Or will they all have left by then? Remember, Adm. Mullen says we need more troops in Afghanistan to deal with spiraling situation developing there. But we don’t have any more because of our commitments in Iraq.
And if his four-year balanced budget promise is premised on rapid victory in both theaters, isn’t that sort of arbitrary timelines on steroids?
I believe we’re at one of those moments when it is a help to step back from the rhetorical flurry and see where each side stands — call it clearing away the Fog of Spin.
The Iraq War is very unpopular. The majority of the country believes it was a mistake to have invaded in the first place. And the great majority want to get all of our troops out of Iraq in the near future. These are facts amply supported by what is now years of public opinion data. While it is true that the reduction in violence over the last 8-9 months has led to some shift in how people think ‘things are going’ in Iraq, it has had no measurable effect on the key questions: should we be there in the first place (no) and should we leave now (yes.)
This is the only backdrop against which to understand the current jousting over the semantics of the Iraq debate.
We have two candidates with starkly different positions. Barack Obama is for an orderly and considered withdrawal of all US combat forces in Iraq, a process he says he will begin immediately upon taking office. John McCain supports a permanent garrisoning of US troops on military bases in Iraq — a long-term ‘presence’ which he hopes will require a constantly-diminishing amount of actual combat and thus an ever-diminishing toll in American lives.
This is, I believe, a fair and even generous description of each candidate’s essential position. And the recital makes the key point clear: McCain’s position is squarely on the wrong side of public opinion — in fact, to an overwhelming degree.
This is why the McCain campaign spends what seems almost literally to be all its time (with tractable reporters in tow) scrutinizing the rhetorical entrails of Obama’s every statement trying to find some movement or contradiction or frankly anything that can be talked about to keep everybody’s attention (press, commentators, citizens, precocious teenagers) off the fact that McCain’s position on Iraq is wildly unpopular and even more what McCain’s position actually is.
Because of this, on Iraq, McCain’s entire campaign is based on a strategy of constant obfuscation — a strategy that has become much more aggressive in the wake of what the McCain campaign is calling last week’s “relaunch” with a new staff based around Rove proteges from President Bush’s 2004 reelection campaign.
Now, before concluding, let me say a few words more about the nature of this dodge. As noted yesterday, despite the AP’s sloppy reporting, Obama has been quite consistent on proposing a 16 month timetable for withdrawal from Iraq. But let’s back up and come at the question another way. If 16 months is no good, is there anyone out there ideologically committed to 12 or 20 months. Or for that matter, since few of us in the general population have a good understanding of the operational details of how you withdraw well over 100,000 military personnel from a country like Iraq, why is it not enough for a presidential candidate simply to say, I’ll change the policy on the day I get into office. And that means I’m going to begin an orderly and considered withdrawal of our troops and have it done as soon as possible.
Now, I can already hear a lot of people rising to the bait and saying, ‘No, we need specifics, a timetable, a date certain, because we’ve been hearing this for years — that we’ll be out as soon as we can, as soon as this that or the other happens.’
And I’d agree.
But this makes the point. Most people who are so keyed into specifics and hard deadlines are that way because we’ve had five years of a policy of deliberate deception in which vague promises of bringing the troops home in the pretty near future are hung out in front of the public’s collective nose as a means of obscuring the real policy of keeping American troops in Iraq permanently as a way of securing oil reserves and projecting US power and in the region.
And that brings us squarely to our other point. What McCain’s offering is exactly the same thing — vague suggestions about troops coming home to toss dust in people’s eyes about his real policy (which he’s occasionally candid about) which is keeping US troops in Iraq permanently. So for instance, last week, when McCain’s campaign pushed the nonsensical claim that Obama had embraced McCain’s position, their release stated that Obama had…
now adopted John McCain’s position that we cannot risk the progress we have made in Iraq by beginning to withdraw our troops immediately without concern for conditions on the ground.
Again, a few clauses floating in the air to try to game people into thinking that McCain’s actually for withdrawing American troops from Iraq too, just a bit more responsibly, with a little more “concern for conditions on the ground” and so forth, when in fact he’s for keeping American troops there permanently.
Even the fine scrutiny of Obama’s language threads back to the last five years of policy by deliberate lying, which McCain is now carrying on.
Andrew flagged this post for me at TheNextRight, which claims that our series of posts last week on BMW Direct and their oddly inefficient direct mail fundraising is actually an attempt to ‘delegitimize direct mail fundraising’, which would be a bad thing in the author’s eyes since this is one mode of mass-fundraising where, he says (and correctly), that conservatives have a “tactical advantage.”
In any case, the author, Soren Dayton, makes a number of claims to argue that our reporting makes no sense. And I’ll try to follow up with a post explaining why his arguments don’t hold water. But what I really wanted to flag for you is that he links approvingly to a site called Election Journal, which appears to be a sort of one-stop shopping for all bogus GOP claims of election fraud designed to aid voter suppression efforts.
Some of it almost reads like parody — here’s a post about the Alabama AG calling out the Bush Justice Department for its blase attitude toward vote fraud.
I’ll definitely be bookmarking it. Sort of ground-zero for the ‘vote fraud’ bamboozlement, or at least the clearing house.
A new ad from a pro-Iraq War group declares that gains from the surge are “change we can believe in.” That and other political news in today’s Election Central Sunday Roundup.
Yesterday we flagged the AP’s Jennifer Loven’s ‘analysis’ piece flogging the McCain/RNC spin on Obama’s run to the center. Well, as every crack communication operation knows, message repetition is the key to success. And so today we have another ‘analysis’ piece, this time by the AP’s Steven Hurst. And it’s practically the same piece. Hurst and Loven actually both use the identical quote from RNC spinmeister Alex Conant.
Says Conant: “”There appears to be no issue that Barack Obama is not willing to reverse himself on for the sake of political expedience.”
The identical quote appears in both pieces. If the pieces weren’t bylined I think I might have assumed one was a rewrite of the other. But they actually appear to be two completely original articles, just mouthing the identical McCain/RNC line.
It seems like we might have a case of persistent Solomonism at the AP, even though the master himself is now two jobs on. This is really going to bear watching.
Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton are set to do a round of big-money fundraisers this coming week for Obama’s campaign and the DNC. That and other political news in today’s Election Central Saturday Roundup.
For a few new projects we’re going to be working on, we’re looking for some good freelance researchers/writers. So if you’re a freelancer or have a job that allows you to do some freelancing, and you’ve ever been interested in working with TPM, send us an email with the subject headline “TPM Research,” with an introduction and resume.
To be clear, this not for a full-time job (though it could lead to one) and at the moment it’s not for a specific project. But we’d like to have people’s names on file to reach out to to help on particular stories.
The late Sen. William Proxmire saved his Golden Fleece Award for federal government boondoggles but he might have made an exception for GOP direct mail firm BMW Direct — which takes obscure Republican candidates and turns them into money-making machines for itself …
High-res version at Veracifier.com.
When I read Jennifer Loven’s AP piece on Obama, which I flagged in the post below, it made my eyes bleed so bad I hardly knew where to start in cataloguing the awfulness. But TPM Reader CO points out a good place to start.
We’ve seen many examples over the last couple days of reporters egregiously lapping up the McCain camp’s nonsensical spin about Obama flip-flopping on Iraq. But some reporters can get spun so thoroughly that they actually retrospectively rearrange the facts of the campaign to accommodate the McCain camp’s spin. Change the facts to suit the spin, as it were.
So here you have Jennifer Loven, a veteran journalist with one of the plum spots in the profession writing this sentence (emphasis added) …
His problem is that his change in emphasis to flexibility from a hard-nosed end-the-war stance — including his recent position that withdrawing combat troops could take as long as 16 months — will now be heard loud and clear by an anti-war camp that may have ignored it before.
Sort of depends on the meaning of ‘recent’ because I think I’ve heard the 16 months line for some time. And, sure enough, from October 2007 …
There is no military solution in Iraq, and there never was. I will begin to remove our troops from Iraq immediately. I will remove one or two brigades a month, and get all of our combat troops out of Iraq within 16 months.
If I’m not mistaken he has said this numerous times since.
Please. There’s always, repositioning by both sides gearing up for the general. So let’s note those. And I guess there’s no stopping gullible reporters from getting jonesed up by each sides’ spinners to find subtle shifts where there aren’t any. But let’s not get so bamboozled that we actually start making stuff up. Okay?
Associated Press officially endorses McCain.
(ed.note: Well, pretty much.)
Late Update: Some recent fun AP-McCain moments (during the courtship phase) …
McCain’s moderators, the AP’s Ron Fournier and Liz Sidoti, greeted McCain with a box of Dunkin’ Donuts. “We spend quite a bit of time with you on the back of the Straight Talk Express asking you questions, and what we’ve decided to do today was invite everyone else along on the ride,” Sidoti explained. “We even brought you your favorite treat.”
McCain opened the offering. “Oh, yes, with sprinkles!” he said.
Sidoti passed him a cup. “A little coffee with a little cream and a little sugar,” she said.