I think TPM was one of the first places to note that what most of the media was playing as McCain calling for an Afghanistan Surge (TM) today was actually his abandoning his position and adopting the position Obama’s been pushing for a year. Even Mark Halperin eventually caught on. But it’s hard to keep your record of being ahead of curve.
Now I see this post from my old pal Juliet Eilperin who reports at the Post’s Trail blog that just after giving his speech adopting Obama’s Afghanistan policy, McCain hopped on the Straight Talk Express (TM) and changed his position again. After telling the crowd in Albuquerque that he would send three additional combat brigades to Afghanistan, that he might get NATO to supply the additional troops instead. “We need to work that out, we need to have greater participation from our NATO allies, and we need a lot more help from our NATO allies,” said McCain.
Now, as we noted, he may have switched his position because the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs recently said that while we need additional troops in Afghanistan we can’t send any because they’d have to come from Iraq.
A short time after that McCain spokeswoman Nicolle Wallace said that some of the additional brigades would be NATO troops and some American.
I’d almost forgotten that top McCain economics advisor Phil Gramm’s only real experience in the non-influence-peddling part of the private sector was as an investor in a 70s soft-core porn movie.
Not that there’s anything wrong that …
From the AP …
In a break with past Bush administration policy, a top U.S. diplomat will for the first time join colleagues from other world powers at a meeting with Iran’s chief nuclear negotiator, The Associated Press has learned.
William Burns, America’s third highest-ranking diplomat, will attend talks with the Iranian envoy, Saeed Jalili, in Switzerland on Saturday aimed at persuading Iran to halt activities that could lead to the development of atomic weapons, a senior U.S. official told the AP on Tuesday.
Official contacts between Iran and the United States are extremely rare and although Washington is part of a six-nation effort to get Iran to stop enriching and reprocessing uranium, the administration has shunned contacts with Tehran on the matter.
Stephen Payne, GOP lobbyist and Bush pal who only a few days ago could have arranged your visit with Vice President Cheney, gets canned by the Department of Homeland Security.
Can we fight al Qaeda, which is in Pakistan, better by fighting in Iraq or Afghanistan? (Scratch chin.)
Two speeches, two very different visions for the futures of America and Iraq. Barack Obama and John McCain delivered dueling speeches today on foreign policy and America’s future course in the Middle East. We bring you the highlights back-to-back in today’s episode of TPMtv …
High-res version at Veracifier.com.
Here I think is an example of news judgment within the DC bell jar.
As I noted below, the ‘news’ today, as in things that have happened today and are newsworthy, is the fact that John McCain has dropped his position on Afghanistan and embraced the one Obama has been pushing for the last year. (As a secondary matter, we can note that McCain doesn’t have the troops for his new position because they’re tied down in Iraq. But let’s not expect too much.)
And look at the headline at Mark Halperin’s The Page: “Obama Acknowledges “Shift in Emphasis” on Issues.”
And here’s Halperin’s gloss on McCain’s new Afghanistan strategy: McCain “highlights the success of the surge (and Obama’s opposition to it), says the troop increase strategies used in Iraq should also be applied to Afghanistan.”
It’s almost comical. It doesn’t fit the script so it didn’t happen.
Late Update: Okay, it’s 7:27 PM. And Halperin now has a headline noting that McCain is “supposedly adopting Obama’s position on troops in Afghanistan.” The key though is that the headline is prompted by an email the Obama campaign sent out to reporters at 6:41 PM (yeah, we got it too.) Did I mention it’s only “supposedly”?
This isn’t getting much notice but it deserves your attention. The senate is currently debating the reauthorization of PEPFAR, the omnibus AIDS prevention and treatment legislation. This reauthorization also includes a repeal of a travel ban on people with HIV. Basically, people with HIV can’t visit the United States and they can’t become citizens if they’re here. Since the US doesn’t require HIV tests for foreign travelers, obviously, a lot of people can slip through unnoticed. But it’s a ban that affects a lot of people and one which we share with a handful of the world’s dictatorships and authoritarian regimes like Sudan, Russia, Libya and Saudi Arabia.
The law was the product of ignorance and prejudice when it was first enacted in 1993. And there’s no reason to keep it on the books now.
But apparently two senators — Sessions of Alabama and Vitter of Louisiana (who of course we know is a serial user of prostitutes, so maybe he should get tested himself) — have put holds on the legislation. So they need 60 votes to override their objection. The vote may come as soon as today. If you’re from those states it’s worth making your voices heard on this one. And if you’re not from Alabama or Louisiana, see whether your senators are willing to vote to override the hold and let us know what you hear.
Video released by the attorney for a then-16-year-old Canadian detainee at Gitmo, of a portion of his 2003 interrogation there by the U.S. Canadian government:
Chilling in its ordinariness.
Is everybody missing this? That McCain is now trying to catch up to Obama on Afghanistan? In fact, he’s now adopting Obama’s position.
Obama has been saying for almost a year that more troops are needed in Afghanistan. McCain has said that wasn’t the case, that Iraq was the central battleground in the war on terror. Moreover, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs says that we need more troops in Afghanistan but we none are available unless we pull substantial numbers out of Iraq — which McCain is ruling out.
So let’s all say it out loud: McCain is now copying Obama’s position on Afghanistan.
And with troops that he doesn’t have since he’s against pulling any out of Iraq.