A number of you have written in (mainly research scientists of one sort or another) to say that in the case of Sarah Palin’s $3.2 million earmark request to study seal DNA we should not jump to the conclusion that such spending is wasteful just because it may sound funny. So let me be clear. I don’t assume that at all. In fact, I’m a big supporter of federal spending on pure research — much of which McCain routinely derides as pork to guffaws all around. My father was a marine biologist whose commitment to investment in the sciences was so great that he’d surely send a thunderbolt down from heaven to smite me if I didn’t. Of course, being such a hard core scientist he didn’t believe in heaven, which is a complication. But I digress. I raise these earmarks because it is another example that John McCain and Sarah Palin are monumental hypocrites and liars on the whole issue of reform, earmarks, the Bridge to Nowhere and virtually everything else. So it would be irresponsible not to make that clear.
Late Update: TPM Reader LS makes a good additional point …
One more point of view from a scientist:
good science is funded through peer review, not via earmarks and lobbying.
we don’t want science funded this way, it leads to croneyism and misuse. give the money to NIH and NSF and don’t do by congressman trading favors.
earmarks are lousy way to fund science, bad, bad, bad.
TPM Reader CM makes much the same point …
I’m a social scientist, rather than a hard scientist, but, for better or for worse, I swim in the sea of research dollars. While I agree with your post that funding research is a good use of tax money and is essential to keeping our society and economy vital, I’m not sure
that earmarking research dollars through legislative action is the best way to ensure that the best research is funded. The federal government has organizations like the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities that distribute research dollars after review by area experts and professional scientists. While I certainly do think congressional oversight of the NSF and the NEH is necessary, allocation of research funds is best left to the professionals. However valid, direct research funding through spending bills is a pork-related program activity.
As a related matter, most of Palin’s ‘science’ earmarks requested for last year are actually sops to the fishing industry in her state to which she is closely tied.
Joe Klein on McCain’s (too little talked about) health care insurance tax increase.
The latest on Trooper-Gate is that Gov. Palin is moving to have her ally, the state’s Attorney General move to quash subpoenas of her aides in the investigation.
Can anyone else think of a major political figure who’s done only Barbara Walters-style prime time celebrity interviews rather than appearing on actual news shows? I can’t. And really a political campaign will do whatever it can get away with. But what news organization has ever done that? What an embarrassment.
James Carville still mourns the McCain he once knew — and is struggling to move past the denial phase:
From an Obama supporter who’s gunning for a fight …
3.2 million for Seal DNA?
People love this. One thing that captures the imagination. It’s the new Bridge to Nowhere. That should be the talking point. 3.2 Million for Seal DNA? Is that the kind of change we need? “Do I hear lipstick on a seal?”
Former AZ Sen. Dennis DeConcini (D-AZ) on why the press’s judgment problem about McCain ….
[McCain] has a problem of judgment. I think that has been clear, as the campaign goes on, that his judgment is flawed. He paints it as a “maverick” position, but in fact he has a problem finding good judgment and staying with it.
He likes to paint himself as a man of convictions that stays with it. But if you served with him, as I did, and if you have followed him since I have left, and I have done that, you see his positions changed [with] whatever is needed. Whether it’s on taxes, income tax cuts; whether it’s on drilling in Alaska, or offshore, or you name it — and John McCain has been all over the map.
And he will continue to do that, and that’s why he has been able to be successful because, in my judgment, mostly. not all of the media, but much of the media kind of lets him get away with it.
New Quinnipiac polls give Obama leads in Ohio and Pennsylvania but show McCain ahead in Florida. That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.
WSJ: In confidential letter, one-time Palin ethics advisor warned her that Trooper-gate scandal was “grave” and recommended she and her husband publicly apologize for their actions.
WaPo editorial: “John McCain is a serious man who promised to wage a serious campaign. Win or lose, will he be able to look back on this one with pride? Right now, it’s hard to see how.”