Give the McCain camp credit. They’re pretty upfront with what McCain’s new mortgage-buy-up plan is really all about.
From the McCain campaign website (emphasis mine):
John McCain will direct his Treasury Secretary to implement an American Homeownership Resurgence Plan (McCain Resurgence Plan) to keep families in their homes, avoid foreclosures, save failing neighborhoods, stabilize the housing market and attack the roots of our financial crisis.
Incidentally, as a reader points out, isn’t this the third different mortgage relief “plan” McCain has announced this year?
A new McCain TV ad is out, with the announcer soberly intoning, “Mr. Obama, we all know the truth.” That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.
As I said in my initial reaction, I thought this was a victory, though not a big one, on points for Obama. But in the context of the campaign, I think that’s a substantial win for Obama. And like the first debate, I suspect this will continue the solidifying, reassuring effect that — in retrospect — was the key result of Debate #1.
One thing that occurs to me after taking some time to mull the exchange is this: where were McCain’s new fisticuffs? Bill Ayers, Obama as a liar, terrorist, all the sludge we’ve seen over the last 72 hours? Yes, he was aggressive on policy. But that’s what debates are about. But McCain didn’t take any of the shenanigans from the campaign trail into this debate. Almost like he was unwilling to say any of it to Obama’s face. Or at least that he knew he couldn’t get away with it in front of a non-party-line audience.
On that note, let’s review the McCain-Palin sludge-a-thon in today’s episode of TPMtv …
Late Update: TPM Reader ES sends in these thoughts, a different, but overlapping take …
My intuition is that McCain conceded tonight. Sure, he shot a few across the bow (the ‘that one’ moment in particular) but he did not go nuclear. He did not engage Obama in the way Palin does on the stump with her references to Ayers, Rezko and Wright. It’s as if McCain couldn’t bring himself to do so. All his attacks were kind of half-hearted. He’s given it his best shot, but when the time came to go for the killer punch, or at the very least, attempt one on prime-time national TV, he blinked. While he clearly despises Obama, he also clearly thinks too highly of himself to get down and dirty with his opponent. He’ll do some on the stump, but not in a debate. Hence the show of disdain (and even the naked lies) – that’s how McCain negotiates the contradiction between his anger, his frustration at losing to “that one,” and his very elevated view of himself. It’s like his nonstop talk of honor and victory in Iraq – everybody knows it is not about actual victory (whatever that may mean in Iraq) but about the perception and the narrative of a victorious and honorable exit. So from now on he’s gonna let Palin take on the role of the bad cop and make a complete fool of herself (err, as if she had not already done that). He will play the whiny, droopy-eyed good cop. Since he can’t have the presidency – quite the narcissistic wound – he will settle for the love of the Washington press corps.
Later Update: A few more responses from around the web …
“John McCain had a very strong debate tonight. It’s too bad for him that it came on a night when Barack Obama was nearly flawless.” — Stephen Hayes, The Weekly Standard.
“Foreign policy didn’t come up much in tonight’s presidential debate; but when it did, Sen. John McCain–whose strengths lie in this realm–seemed surprisingly unsteady while Sen. Barack Obama came off as more sure-footed than he did in the first contest.” — Fred Kaplan, Slate.
Noam Scheiber has a good summary of what happened at TNR. Obama dominated in what was supposed to be McCain’s format. His answers were just much more clear and coherent than McCain’s. And he unpacks an exchange that I referenced briefly in my live blog — the key point in the debate when McCain repeatedly tried to point himself forward as the ‘cool hand’ at the tiller, appearing either oblivious or indifferent to the fact that the last three weeks have made ‘steady’ one of the last words a lot of people associates with John McCain. As I wrote in the live blog, “Is McCain suddenly running against himself?”. (See the video here.) Let’s pick it up from Noam …
More importantly, I thought the Pakistan exchange was the moment when son overtook father in the Oedipal drama that’s been a subtext of this campaign. After Obama gave his initial response, McCain pressed the absurd line that his opponent didn’t understand talking softly while carrying a big stick–that he was, in other words, erratic.
Coming from a candidate whose name has been synonymous with “erratic” these last several weeks, it left McCain dangerously exposed, and Obama didn’t miss with his counterpunch. “This is the guy who sang, ‘Bomb, bomb, bomb Iran,’ who called for the annihilation of North Korea. That I don’t think is an example of ‘speaking softly,'” he said. “This is the person who, after we had–we hadn’t even finished Afghanistan, where he said, ‘Next up, Baghdad.'” As if to add insult to injury, Obama nearly straight-armed McCain when he tried to interrupt, underscoring not only his intellectual advantages but also his physical ones.
Obama on McCain the hothead …
Obama: You’re Right, I Don’t Understand Your Failed Foreign Policy …
I wasn’t quite sure what to make of this when it happened. It sounded demeaning, but it happened as I was writing one of my posts. So I didn’t get a chance to listen closely enough on the first round. But you be the judge …
Late Update: Amazing how quickly they can get up new URLs these days.
You can see our initial comments on this below. And here’s the video — make your own judgments …
Late Update: A few readers say the two shook hands right after the conclusion of the debate, at that moment where Brokaw told them they were in the way of his teleprompter. Here’s what TPM Reader KP said …
Hey, i watched the video of the debate. The moment right before Tom Brokaw told them they were in his way, they clearly shook hands vigorously. Then they took a moment to stand side by side for the audience and Brokaw was like, hey move it.
The moment you showed on video was when McCain was obviously presenting his wife to shake Obama’s hand.
On the other hand, in the video above, Blitzer seemed to think they had no yet shaken hands.
Special Late Night D’oh Update: It turns out KP’s right. They did shake hands right at the end of the debate, at the point where they got in the way of Brokaw’s teleprompter. It wasn’t on CNN or NBC but we just found it on ABC. No question. They shook hands before McCain later snubbed him and then ran off in a huff.
This debate struck me as a marginal victory for Obama on points, but because of the state of the race a substantial victory in terms of the overall race. Obama more than held his own. I think Obama’s answers were more coherent. And there were several exchanges where I think Obama had very strong answers, which I noted in the live blogging. That said, McCain did fine. I think his supporters will think he put in a solid performance. But the bottom line is that right now McCain is losing. He has to shake things up. But he didn’t.
Did McCain just refuse to shake Obama’s hand?
Late Update: We just looked at the video. There’s some room for interpretation. But it certainly looks like McCain left Obama hanging when Obama put his hand out to shake. But before you make up your mind, you should see the video. We’ll have it for you shortly.
Later Update: We’re getting conflicting reports on this handshake story. We’re getting flooded by emails. So a lot of people definitely think they saw it. But like I said, we’re going to be pulling the video shortly. So you can see for yourselves. One reader says that it was actually that moment where they were blocking the teleprompter that they were shaking their hands. The truth is, I think, that on TV it was hard to be sure quite what happened. So let’s wait to see the video. And then we’ll try to find out more about what happened.
Video shortly …
10:20 PM … I think McCain was just about to say, a tiny country in a tiny part of the world.
10:24 PM … I think Tom Brokaw just won the contest for most positively stupid question of the evening.
10:32 PM … Very strong conclusion by Obama. I think he served himself very well with that. Through the debate his answers have been more coherent; he’s connected them better to ordinary concerns.
10:34 PM … Really don’t know if this ‘steady hand at the tiller’ line is a winner for McCain.
10:34 PM … Okay, I’ll give Brokaw that one. He ended on a funny line.
9:55 PM … That’s some of the best hair transplant debate humor I’ve heard in a while.
9:56 PM … Lucky Obama jumped in there before Brokaw said time was up.
9:59 PM … I think when you’re the only one laughing at your jokes, there’s a problem. … (ed.note: 10:06 PM … a number of readers say they heard one people laugh at this joke: Brokaw.)
10:00 PM … I didn’t realize that Brokaw would be so in the tank for McCain. I guess he’s still the emissary?
10:02 PM … Very solid turn of the question from Obama on Iraq/foreign policy. (I’m surprised Brokaw isn’t cutting him off in the middle.) On the other hand TPM Reader JG, who says he’s an Obama supporter, says I’m being too hard on Brokaw, he’s just had a hard time controlling the time, but not unfair.
10:07 PM … Is McCain suddenly running against himself? Saying we need a “cool hand at the tiller”? Someone who understands our limits?
10:09 PM … Curious what people think. But even trying to judge this from the vantage point of an undecided voter, I don’t get the sense that McCain is scoring many points in this foreign policy phase of the debate.
10:13 PM … Has Brokaw ever interrupted McCain?
10:14 PM … Green behind the ears? Guess that’s a new metaphor. (10:23 PM … Hmmm, learn something new every day. Readers are sending me links to this phrase. I thought it was ‘wet behind the ears’ and that you can be ‘green’. Didn’t know they combined.) On the other hand, saying how McCain’s a loose cannon freak is pretty good.