Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
10.11.08 | 9:57 am
Question of the Moment

When did Rove’s hatchet men do greater damage to John McCain? In 2000 or 2008?

To me it seems like a very easy question to answer. But what do you think?

10.10.08 | 11:28 pm
Weird. Sad. Surreal

This afternoon on the campaign trail, John McCain began dialing back (or began trying to appear to be dialing back) the rising tide of hatred and verbal violence he and his running mate have been whipping up over recent weeks. After all we’ve seen over recent months, I think it would naive to conclude that McCain did this for any other reason but that the attacks appeared to be backfiring. Perhaps that’s ungenerous. But to think so requires a leap of faith, a judgment not grounded in any evidence from the last year of the man’s behavior. The aim of such a bludgeoning assault is to force the subject of Obama’s relationship to Ayers back to the center of the campaign dialogue. But that’s not what happened. By week’s end that campaign narrative was all about the ferocity and recklessness of McCain’s attacks.

There’s something else to note too. Over the last 48 hours several name brand Republicans have come out and either chided or denounced McCain’s borderline incitement. And given how taboo it is to level such criticism of your own nominee at this stage of the election you have to assume these criticisms were only the tip of the iceberg, with a far more intense and angry barrage of criticism voiced privately.

Here are a few clips put together by CNN that are worth watching.

The first passage to watch starts at 25 seconds in. A participant tells McCain he’s “scared” of any Obama presidency and McCain responds that he “is a decent person and a person you do not have to be scared [of] as President of the United States.”

Those are the words. But look at the facial expressions. McCain looks down as he says it and has the countenance of someone who been forced to tell someone else they’re sorry. There’s some mix of gritting your teeth and saying something you don’t want to say mixed with some sort of shamefacedness. Look at the video. Because while I feel like I intuitively ‘get’ the gestures I find it hard to quite capture them in words. Perhaps you’ll do better and you can share your thoughts with me.

In the next clip McCain is speaking up close with a woman in the audience who says she can’t trust Obama and then blurts out that it’s because he’s “Arab”. Some reports have it that she said ‘Arab terrorist’. But at least on this tape only ‘Arab’ is audible.

McCain shakes his head, as though losing his patience and snatches the mic back out of woman’s hands. “No, Ma’am. No, Ma’am. He’s a decent family man, citizen, that I just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues.” Again, there’s a lot there when you actually see the video. And I encourage you to watch.

I get from his expression a sense of a man that is, in addition to all the other things he’s angry about, is frustrated or angry at the situation he’s gotten himself into. But he has sown the wind and now he’s reaping the whirlwind. “Even,” says TPM Reader RB, “as he says ‘You don’t have to be scared of an Obama presidency’ to a handful of followers (and, more importantly, of national reporters), he is spending millions to bombard as many people as he can with the ad named “Dangerous”. The small hand giveth, and the large hand taketh away.”

And yet this conveys too much suggestion of planning and intent. I have more the sense of someone desperately casting about and losing control of the situation itself. Even hypocrites can get in over their heads. Indeed, in a more nuts-and-bolts strategic sense McCain has really gotten himself into a hole because the campaign he’s been running has almost entirely been premised on the claim that you should be scared of an Obama presidency. Not that McCain, if he’d run a very different campaign, couldn’t have run on issue disagreements with Obama. But right now if you take away fear of Obama becoming president, there’s almost no reason not to vote for him since McCain has basically conceded the issue agenda to Obama. If you look at every poll for months, voters are dying for change. Fear of Obama is the only thing keeping him from leaving McCain in the dust. Take that away and McCain’s done.

I’m not sure what else to say about this episode. But it is something to behold.

10.10.08 | 10:07 pm
Red Herring

You can already see, in the McCain camp’s first statement on the Trooper-Gate report, that the McCain campaign will spin it as actually letting Gov. Palin off the hook for firing Monegan because it finds that she had the power to fire him.

That’s ridiculous. Monegan’s firing was just the tip of the iceberg.

The report details the extraordinary lengths that Gov. Palin, largely through her husband Todd, went to get her ex-brother-in-law, a state trooper, fired because of personal family reasons (namely, his nasty divorce from Palin’s sister). It was this effort, which led to pressure being improperly brought to bear on numerous state employees, that constituted an abuse of power by Palin. As it should be. State employees should not be subject to personal vendettas from elected officials.

While the report also finds that the governor in Alaska has the inherent power to fire her department heads for any reason or for no reason, it concludes that Monegan’s refusal to fire one of his state troopers at the insistence of the governor and her family was a contributing factor in his own firing.

So rather than the firing of Monegan itself being the abuse of power, the wide-ranging effort to retaliate against her sister’s ex-husband, of which Monegan’s firing was merely a part, was the real abuse. Monegan’s firing is evidence of the broader scheme, not the scheme itself. Cold comfort if you’re a McCain-Palin supporter.

10.10.08 | 9:16 pm
Background Reality Check

How’s McCain’s veep-vetting process looking right about now?

10.10.08 | 8:21 pm
Trooper-Gate: Palin Abused Power

The Republican-dominated panel overseeing the Trooper-Gate probe just voted unanimously to release the report by its independent investigator.

Here’s the report (.pdf).

The report finds that Gov. Sarah Palin “abused her power” in violation of Alaska law. That’s the key finding. It also finds that while the refusal to fire Palin’s former brother in law was not the sole reason Palin terminated her public safety commissioner, Walt Monegan, it was a “contributing factor.”

10.10.08 | 6:18 pm
Trying to Snuff Out the Flame

At a rally late today in Minnesota, John McCain addressed the heated comments, including calls to violence, coming from some supporters at his rallies this week:

“I am enthusiastic and encouraged by the enthusiasm and I think it’s really good,” McCain said. “We have to fight and i will fight but we will be respectful. I admire Sen. Obama and his accomplishments and I want to be respectful.

Here’s the (updated longer version) video of a portion of McCain’s remarks:

Late Update: Ana Marie Cox is on the ground at the rally and reports:

Indeed, [McCain] just snatched the microphone out the hands of a woman who began her question with, “I’m scared of Barack Obama… he’s an Arab terrorist…”

“No, no ma’am,” he interrupted. “He’s a decent family man with whom I happen to have some disagreements.”

Later Update: In the expanded version of the video above, I don’t hear any reference to terrorist when the woman calls Obama an Arab.

10.10.08 | 5:05 pm
McCain Camp: Obama Is Going Negative

Obama’s critique of the people yelling “Kill him!” and “Terrorist!” at McCain-Palin rallies is an attack on the good, god-fearing people of America, according to McCain campaign spokesman Brian Rogers:

“Barack Obama’s attacks on Americans who support John McCain reveal far more about him than they do about John McCain. It is clear that Barack Obama just doesn’t understand regular people and the issues they care about. He dismisses hardworking middle class Americans as clinging to guns and religion, while at the same time attacking average Americans at McCain rallies who are angry at Washington, Wall Street and the status quo.

“Even worse, he attacks anyone who dares to question his readiness to serve as their commander in chief in chief. Raising legitimate questions about record, character and judgment are a vital part of the Democratic process, and Barack Obama’s effort to silence and shame those who seek answers should make everyone wonder exactly what he is hiding.”

Here’s Tucker Bounds, another campaign flack, picking up the same talking points a short time ago on MSNBC:

Note at the very end where Bounds claims that the McCain camp’s latest TV ad about Ayers is really an ad about the economy. Really.

10.10.08 | 5:00 pm
McCain Goes After Michelle …

From TPM Election Central …

The McCain campaign is now broadening their attack on Obama’s past association with William Ayers to include Michelle Obama — even though McCain has repeatedly said spouses should be off limits during the campaign.

The attack? Bernardine Dohrn, Ayers’ wife and fellow former Weatherman, went to work in 1984 for the major Chicago-based national law firm of Sidley & Austin, and three years later, Michelle joined the mega-firm as well.

That’s the entire attack. We wish we were joking. But we aren’t.

Read the rest of the story here.

10.10.08 | 4:26 pm
Secret Service Steps In …

From the Tampa Tribune …

The U.S. Secret Service is looking into reports that a crowd member yelled,”Kill him!” while Gov. Sarah Palin was talking about Sen. Barack Obama during her Clearwater rally Monday.

The incident reportedly occurred after Palin questioned Obama’s patriotism because of his acquaintance with William Ayers, a Chicago university professor who was an anti-Vietnam War radical in the 1970s.

Apparently the only public evidence of the “kill him” shout is a Washington Post news story Tuesday by reporter Dana Milbank, who covered the rally.

Milbank later was quoted in an interview with the Politico Web site as saying he thought the shout may have been a reference to Ayers, not Obama.

A few points are worth noting here. Milbank appears to be the only direct source for this. We’ve had numerous angry audience members, cries of ‘terrorist’ and ‘treason’ and so forth. But this was definitely one of the most inflammatory. Perhaps Milbank misheard. Let’s hope so. Regardless, it makes sense to look into it and find out just what happened.

(ed.note: Thanks to TPM Reader MH for the tip.)

10.10.08 | 3:45 pm
George Wallace McCain

Earlier this afternoon I wrote about the ACORN story and the right’s effort to lie to people and fool them into thinking this has anything to do with voter fraud. This email just came in from TPM Reader DW …

McCain’s team has been pushing it on reporters today and just put out one of the most obvious web videos yet.

I say “obvious” because the implication of the 24/7 Fox coverage is made blatant. It’s transference. It’s saying to white voters, “we know you’re angry about the economy. Don’t blame Wall Street. Blame the n—–s.”

McCain’s going to lose, and he knows it. This is a 90-second ad aimed at the base who are watching Fox News. But he’s setting up a large proportion (maybe the majority) of the GOP base to believe that scary blacks stole the election for Barack Obama. He’s stoking race hatred. He is scum, and if in 10 years his name isn’t synonymous with Lester Maddox and George Wallace than historians won’t have done their job.

It’s really true. The essence of McCain’s campaign now appears to amount to prepping McCain’s base to believe they didn’t really lose the election. The election was stolen from them by Barack, his army of gangsters and black street hustlers, and possibly Osama bin Laden too.