From TPM Reader BR …
FDR like Obama came to office with two jobs in front of him – straightening out the banking system and stimulating the economy. He punted for a year and a half on fiscal stimulus. (Very likely he didn’t realize what he needed to do, but even if he did he would have been unable to do much.) He was politically dependent on conservative Democrats like Al Smith, John Raskov, Daniel Roper and Lewis Douglas and the interests they represented (e.g., the chemical industry). These people were committed to the balanced budget. After he dealt with the banks, he abandoned the balanced budget and lost political support from the conservative Democrats.
Obama is in a mirror-image political situation. He was elected with lots of support from big financial interests, and he needs to maintain that support to get his stimulus package through. He isn’t strong enough right now to win a two-front war against the Republicans and the big banks.
I read this context into this morning’s leak to the Times. The only people who know what was said between Axelrod and Obama are the two of them, and I don’t think Axelrod would leak without Obama’s OK. Obama feels he can’t say no to Geithner right now without losing his stimulus package. But he’s going to make the bank bailout stand or fall on its own. If it gets shot down, then – with the stimulus passed – he will be in a position to turn to a different strategy.
Watching the Dow is always a questionable metric for evaluating the merits of policy decisions the government announces. But it’s worth looking particularly closely at the reactions of financial stocks, particularly bank stocks — and how the swings in their value are perceived. A real solution to the present crisis probably involves wiping out the shareholders in the bank. So as investors see that on the horizon, if we ever get there, it will only be logical for people to try to unload those stocks.
NYT’s DealBook is reporting that analysts at RBC Capital Markets are proposing what looks a lot like a quasi-nationalization proposal.
‘Nationalization’ is a loaded word. But the key is making insolvent banks face their insolvency, from which a number of steps inevitably follow …
The analysts, including Jon Arfstrom, Jason Arnold, Gerard Cassidy and Joe Morford, suggest that the solution to the bank meltdown is a tough love approach: The government should seize insolvent banks — “of any size,” they write — and pool the worst assets in an investment vehicle akin to the Resolution Trust Corporation, which was formed to mop up the flotsam from the savings and loan debacle.
Why such a harsh prescription?
These analysts think that American banks are still carrying far too many assets at inflated prices, and marking them down to more-realistic values would “overwhelm the capital of the U.S. banking system,” they say.
Yep, that was a punt.
Perhaps they realized that the situation is too fluid and uncertain to come out with a definitive plan that brings us to the post-Economic Crisis promised land. And they may be right in that regard. But I can’t help thinking that this is in some level a punt. Maybe they couldn’t actually come to an agreement on what to do. So they came forward with this.
I’ll be curious what others make of it.
Late Update: In some ways, I think the stalemate interpretation is the most optimistic one, since it suggests that coming up with a sensible plan is still a future option.
Buried down at the bottom of the Times article on the Obama bailout plan is this short passage …
Under the category of sticks, private investment managers are closely watching how the Treasury rolls out its “uniform stress test” for grading the health of banks. If the government takes a tougher line with more banks, it could force them to sell off more of their loans and take their lumps sooner rather than later.
Remember, the heart of the problem in the banking sector is not simply that a lot of the banks are probably insolvent, it’s that they’re not willing to admit it and government regulators are not forcing the point. Specifically, the banks are refusing to recognize steep losses on a lot of bad assets. If this stress test were to force valuing these assets at something like market values that could force the sorts of financial reorganization (i.e., bankruptcy and a period of government ownership) that is probably the only way out of this mess. That’s a big ‘if’. I doubt that’s the plan at the moment. But it’s a detail in the plan that might later be built on.
Bank bailout 3.0 rolls out at 11 a.m. ET, and the Senate votes on the stimulus package later today. That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.
Well, maybe CNBC was wrong. The Times is saying that it’s a bit more of the ‘bad bank’ after all. And the big story seems to be that Geithner won out against what the Times refers to as “some of the president’s top political hands” who wanted tougher controls over the banks and less giveaways for the banks’ shareholders.