Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
02.16.09 | 6:18 am
Study Harder

I’m not sure what other ways he’s going to follow in Newt Gingrich’s steps. But GOP House whip Eric Cantor seems to have the megalomania and ego front down pat. He’s been putting out word over the last few days that he’s modeling himself off Newt and now apparently Winston Churchill too. And now there’s this from the Post …

But Rep. Eric Cantor (Va.), the House minority whip who led the fight to deny Obama every GOP vote for the plan, is studying Winston Churchill’s role leading the Tories in the late 1930s, a principled minority that was eventually catapulted into power over the Labor Party. He calls the stimulus bill “a stinker.”

Now, I guess it’s possible this is the Post’s error and not Cantor’s. And even if it’s not you’d think they might have corrected this point. But Cantor’s handle on his new hero seems pretty thin.

In the late 1930s, of course, Great Britain didn’t have a Labour government with a principled Tory minority. It had conservative Tory government with a Labour minority. And Churchill was on the outs with both, although on some fronts he was beginning to make common cause with some Labourites on his key issue, which was foreign policy. When Churchill eventually came to power it was in a national coalition government for the purposes of fighting the war. And when he eventually went to the voters as head of the Tory party toward the end of the war they got crushed by Labour in a landslide.

I say all this as a big Churchill fan. But, I mean, not only is Eric Cantor no Winston Churchill, I’m not even sure he’s read a book about Winston Churchill.

02.16.09 | 4:49 am
U.S. Bankers Need Stiff Upper Lips

Think U.S. bankers have it tough with the new executive compensation limits? Check out what Conservatives in Britain are proposing for bankers there.

02.16.09 | 4:40 am
TPMtv: Sunday Show Roundup: Stimulus Post-Mortem

The economic stimulus package has been passed by both houses of Congress and is set to be signed by the President on Tuesday. But while the voting is complete the debate rages on. And what about the next item on the president’s early agenda – the banking crisis and the question of nationalization? All that and more in today’s Sunday Show Roundup …

Full-size video at TPMtv.com.

02.16.09 | 4:17 am
TPMDC Morning Roundup

BREAKING: Ken Starr anticipates partisan rancor in any Supreme Court picks Obama gets to make. That and the day’s other (less predictable) political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.

02.15.09 | 9:43 pm
Please Do

Israel is reportedly on the brink of releasing Marwan Barghouti from prison, in an effort to bolster Fatah and Abu Mazen ahead of a possible prisoner swap with Hamas.

It’s the right and the smart thing to do. And with Netanyahu probably on the brink of a second premiereship, right and smart are both going to be in seriously short supply.

02.15.09 | 6:53 pm
A Bit of Wiggle Room

There’s been an alternative theory afoot in recent days which holds that Tim Geithner’s ill-received bank rescue plan wasn’t so much a plan as a holding pattern; and that the ‘stress test’ for banks may be the back door through which we move toward some sort of nationalization of at

obama-blog.jpg

least some of the big banks. Nouriel Roubini suggested something like this just after Geithner’s speech. And now it seems that Obama too is leaving himself a decent amount of semantic and policy wiggle room to pursue such an approach.

Last week Ron Brownstein published an article based on an interview he and four other columnists were granted with President Obama. And now E.J.Dionne has published a detailed transcript of just what Obama said on the issue of nationalization.

The upshot is that Obama would not rule out Swedish model nationalization, though he clearly wants to avoid it. And the opposition to nationalization which Obama made clear early last week seems, in this interview, to be at least in part a matter of semantics, or subject to enough subsequent revision and experimentation as to bring us to the same end result. But this is a case where reading the precise words he used is key.

02.15.09 | 6:24 pm
Maverick

Shorter John McCain: Obama needs to do a better job of letting us jerk him around.

02.15.09 | 10:37 am
Shocking Development

CNN’s Current Headline Story

cnn-front21509-blog.jpg

Sometimes I wonder what it would be like if McCain had lost.

Late Update: Seems like now CNN rules Mark Halperin’s world. Or is it vice versa?

page-front21509-blog.jpg
02.15.09 | 8:40 am
Wheels Turning

There was a very odd moment on This Week this morning when Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA) and Sen. Schumer (D-NY) both said they opposed bank nationalization only to be followed by Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) who said that, painful as it is to contemplate, we need to seriously consider doing so.

Now, I’ve said before that I think the term ‘nationalization’ mainly confuses and obscures the issue. And since Geithner’s speech last week there does seem to be a slow but steady movement in the direction of letting the big insolvent banks fail. But this contrast points to something I’ve been wondering about for a while, which is whether the idea might not end up getting some paradoxical support from more doctrinaire free market types.

The idea has never been to nationalize the banking sector as a matter of on-going national policy. It’s more like a highly structured and customized form of moving these institutions through Chapter 11 bankruptcy. In fact, we have a whole system in place for how this is done by the FDIC.

But as long as you have this unworkable hybrid of keeping notionally solvent banks on taxpayer life support with the pretense that they’re still viable private corporations you end up with government-mandated salary caps and lots of other government intrusions into the running of these business. We’re still working on this story. But recently we we were told that just after receiving its TARP money, one of the mega-banks turned around and sent a whole bunch of stateside jobs to India to cut costs. If and when that comes out I’m sure you going to have a lot of calls to prevent TARP funded banks from doing that too. And why not? Notwithstanding a marginal company’s need to cut costs, why should taxpayers from state X directly underwrite bank Y to put tens of thousands of state X’s residents out of work?

Organized bankruptcy for failed companies is not a radical or left-wing idea. It’s the junction where capitalism and the rule of law meet. Very establishment stuff.

Needless to say, this is hardly the most compelling reason to stop subsidizing failed banks and the failed bankers who run them. The current approach isn’t working. It’s amounting to a massive giveaway of taxpayer dollars. But I suspect this may end up pushing some of these people over the edge too.

Late Update: The whole “retention fee” issue seems very similar to what I was referring to above. In theory at least, there’s a logic to these companies needing to make sure their best employees aren’t poached by competitors. In practice, I’m skeptical there’s such a great market out there for financial services wizards. I know a lot of them. And most are really glad not to have lost their jobs yet. But the whole problem is an artifact of the illogic of propping up the failed banks in the first place. Citi wants to protect the value of its shareholders’ big asset, the company, the institution itself as a value proposition going forward. But that’s something they should have thought of before they let the board and executives drive the company into bankruptcy. It’s not clear to me why taxpayers care if Citi’s best brokers go to Morgan Stanley or some new bank that gets set up from the ruins of one of the failed ones. I’ll admit I’m not sure I have as clear an answer to the idea that foreign banks could poach the best people, etc. So I’ll defer to others who have a better handle on that issue. But you still end up in these unworkable situations. And I suspect it’s a messiness that will lead many free marketeers to decide that biting the bullet is the way to go.

02.15.09 | 8:25 am
TPMDC Sunday Roundup

President Obama declares that he’s an eternal optimist — but not a sap. That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Sunday Roundup.