Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
03.19.09 | 6:04 am
Tone Deaf?

Yesterday, Rahm Emanuel called the AIG bonuses a “big distraction.” Today, David Axelrod says: “People are not sitting around their kitchen tables thinking about AIG,” Axelrod said. “They are thinking about their own jobs.”

I honestly don’t get what up-side they see politically in taking this tack. Thoughts?

Late Update: Some of the responses, starting with TPM Reader MM:

Well, how about with the people that don’t follow all of this as closely as you guys do? I talk with my co-workers in the lunch room and THEY aren’t babbling about AIG or What-ever. We are talking about Sally’s husband that was laid off and Jane’s forclosed house and Pete’s daughter that needs a kidney and the insurance might not be adequate to even attempt a transplant if a donor is found. And then EVERYONE is worriedly talking about our hours cut to 31 hours a week from the usual 40 and how are we going to pay our bills.

You have to step away from the rarified air of the news bubble you are in, David, to see the big picture, here. I am glad Rahm and Barack are KEEPING THEIR EYES ON THE BIGGER PICTURE!

TPM Reader RM:

David Axelrod’s political radar is on the fritz and he better get it fixed in a hurry or Obama is going to lose the credibility he needs to continue leading us out of this abyss. There is no political up-side to this tack. Not one. Period.

TPM Reader AB:

Yeah, I read that Axelrod quote and thought he’d got it exactly wrong. People are sitting around their kitchen tables talking about AIG. It’s not an either/or situation where they discuss AIG or their jobs. The two are related. And the reason people are so mad about AIG is because their jobs and savings are insecure while AIG screw-ups are getting bonuses with taxpayer money.

Same thing goes for all the people who say we should be worrying about the counterparty payments. Yes we should, but the bonuses and counterparty payments are also related. Both are examples of AIG doing pretty much what it wants with government money while the people who should be in charge throw up their hands and say, “We didn’t know” or there’s nothing “We could do.”

The screwed-up oversight processes that allowed the bonuses is the same screwed-up process that allowed the counterparty payments. Either someone’s asleep at the wheel or their priorities are very, very wrong when it comes to addressing both these issues. In fact, the bonus issue is serving to focus attention on the bigger issues not draw it away. It’s the proverbial straw that broke the camel’s back.

Tons more reader responses here.

03.19.09 | 5:55 am
No Ideas, No Plan, No Nothing

Larry O’Donnell went to town this morning on Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA). The ostensible issue was whether Cantor was going to support Rep. Charlie Rangel’s bill to tax the heck out the AIG bonuses when it comes up for a vote later today. He couldn’t get an answer out of Cantor, though to my ears it sounded like a no. But the larger issue this exchange exposes is just how bereft of solutions the Republicans are right now. The only thing they have managed to muster is a faux populism over the AIG bonuses — a passing fancy they hope will score some short-term political points:

See more at MSNBC.com.

03.19.09 | 5:11 am
TPMDC Morning Roundup

The House is expected to pass legislation later today to stiffly tax those AIG bonuses. That and the other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.

03.19.09 | 3:00 am
What Happened Yesterday?

03.18.09 | 7:50 pm
Sweetheart Deals

Over at DealBook, Steven Davidoff has a run-down of just what those newly-released AIGFP bonus contracts tell us.

Here’s the key take away …

This was not a boilerplate contract. Rather, it was highly negotiated. And it was highly negotiated to pay retention fees at high levels without regard to performance. This is obviously shocking. But it makes me wonder: perhaps one area of direction here should be actually looking at who negotiated this and why?

It strikes me that the A.I.G. financial products division received an unbelievably sweet deal. Did its managers slip it under the radar? Did the managers act in good faith? And who at A.I.G. signed off on this and did they focus on the risks and rewards? Yet more avenues for possible litigation.

Meanwhile, Daniel Gross points to the big question …

Congress should also hear from the many AIG counterparties who together have received billions of dollars of taxpayer funds so far through AIG. These folks bought insurance from or did business with a company that was unable, as it turned out, to make good on its financial commitments. And yet because the government didn’t let AIG file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, these counterparties have been made whole. I’d like to hear Goldman Sachs CEO Lloyd Blankfein tell Congress why it was appropriate for taxpayers to make a payment to Goldman of $5.6 billion in credit-default swaps, and why Goldman shouldn’t eat at least a portion of the losses it would have suffered had the taxpayers let AIG fail. It would be nice to hear from the half-dozen German banks, including the state-owned Landesbank Baden-Wuerttemberg, who have benefited from one of the biggest transfers of taxpayer wealth to Europe since the Marshall Plan. Or from executives at Citadel, the beleaguered hedge fund that received $200 million in payments from AIG’s securities-lending business. They should be duly sworn in and forced to explain why taxpayers should pay these claims just because their firms bought insurance without determining whether the insurer could pay the claims.

As you know, like many others, we were hitting like crazy on this point long before the story became all bonus all the time. Who are the counter-parties? To a great degree, we now know who they were — at least the major ones. Deutsche Bank, Goldman Sachs, a bunch of other banks in Europe. But in many respects these big institutions were just pass throughs. Hedge fund X goes to Goldman to place a bet against the US housing market. Goldman outsources a big chunk of the risk to AIG. Hedge fund X wins the bet, collects from Goldman, which in turn collects from AIG. The transactions are obviously much more complicated; but that’s the rough trajectory.

The best article I saw on this today was Serena Ng’s in the Journal. Many discussions of these credit default swaps have conditioned us to think of them as de facto insurance policies. So I buy a bunch of mortgage debt. But I also buy some CDS insurance to cover myself against the risk of my investments going under. But that’s not what was happening in a lot of these cases. A lot of this was smart hedge fund managers who could see the housing meltdown coming three or four years ago and placed bets against it.

Not that there’s anything wrong with that, so long as you place your bets with institutions that can cover your winning hand.

But why are we paying off these debts? Like Dan Gross said above, do we really need to cover all of Goldman’s exposure dollar for dollar? Maybe we split it fifty-fifty? Remember, Goldman says their balance sheet is strong and it’s share price is holding up relatively well. Maybe they can help the taxpayer managed a bit of this heavy lift?

And not just Goldman. I’m picking on them because their exposure to AIG’s arrested collapse was especially great. And there were a lot of Goldman alums at least fortuitously involved in saving AIG. But the same logic applies to all the other counterparties.

It’s a complex business. And even a lot of right-thinking economists are worried that these hedges and sellings of risk back and forth are so tied up and knotted together that cutting the cord could trigger a chain reaction toward the kind of meltdown we only barely avoided last fall.

Maybe so. But when you look at these payouts up close, that rationale for making these people whole is very questionable. At a minimum it’s worth bringing a few of those CEOs up to Capitol Hill and asking them just why they got our money and why we can’t have some of it back.

03.18.09 | 7:09 pm
Take Two

Robert Reich on what Obama has to do next after the AIG bonus fiasco.

03.18.09 | 1:22 pm
The Big Bucks

Let’s go

joseph-cassano-blog.jpg

back to Joe Cassano, former chieftain of AIG Financial Products.

As noted earlier, there is a good deal of evidence that Cassano was trying to keep his division’s book off-limits to AIG’s in-house and outside accountants and auditors going back at least several years. Here is our first draft run-down of evidence that points to a systematic effort to keep AIGFP’s books under seal and provide misleading or false information about the Financial Products’ division’s health.

He was forcibly retired in March of 2008, but kept on a $1 million per month retainer and allowed to keep living in the AIG-paid for apartment in London. It was only in September 2008 that Rep. Henry Waxman flipped out when he heard that the guy who blew up AIG and put taxpayers on the line for tens or hundreds of billions of dollars was still getting a $1 million a month retainer. That’s when they killed the retainer too.

But take a look at the ‘retirement’ agreement Cassano signed with AIG back in March of last year.

03.18.09 | 12:28 pm
Big Fat Red Herring

AIG CEO Edward Liddy has made quite the show of fearing for his employees safety at today’s hearing, and congressmen have played right along, tut-tutting over how horrible hate mail is. The exception is Barney Frank, who sees it for the red herring it is:

Let’s be clear: AIG is not the victim here. Any suggestion that Congress or the media have incited the usual whackos who send hate mail is offensive, but more to the point, is intended to distract from the real issue here: AIG’s own reckless and probably criminal conduct.

Late Update: Another example of how “protecting” the employees of AIG really means not cooperating with investigators:

03.18.09 | 10:39 am
Obama: The Buck Stops With Me on AIG

Before heading to California for some “town hall” meetings, President Obama addressed the AIG mess: