After initially concluding that the AIG bonus tax was constitutional, Harvard law prof Larry Tribe has taken a closer look and is now not so sure.
The White House is cool to this legislation to begin with. Tribe’s changing course may help give the necessary political/legal cover to slow roll it in the Senate or eventually veto it — if it gets that far.
From TPM Reader XX …
I live in a wealthy NJ suburb which is home to a lot of Wall Streeters . I received an impassioned email plea from a neighbor who wants everyone to take action against the 90% taxation of bonuses. He works for JP Morgan Chase. He claims that his company was “forced” to take TARP funds and he should not penalized by the tax. Since his income is mostly in the form of a bonus, he thinks that the confiscation of the bonuses amount to a constitutional taking. As one who is not employed by one of the Tarp banks and whose own bonus is in jeopardy because of a collapsing economy (due to some of those banks misdeeds), I am less than sympathetic. In fact, I am a little miffed. However, my real question is:
Was JP Morgan really “forced” to take the funds, or was it just pressured by Paulson to take the funds or else jeopardize some future aid by the government? I can’t seem to find an answer.
Let me again stipulate, to start, that I think the current bill moving through Congress is probably a bad idea. Was JPMChase forced to take the money? I’m pretty sure no one was ‘forced’ to take the money, in a strictly legal sense. But I do recall that Paulson made clear he really wanted all the big exposed banks to take a big chunk. And a number of the banks made a big show about doing the Feds a favor by taking it. Whether that was just grandstanding or denial I’m not completely sure, possibly a mix of both. Because it quickly became clear that not only did many of them desperately need it, at least two (Citi and BofA) came back and pretty short order begging for substantially larger sums. My sense is that of the handful of big banks, JPMChase is in relatively good shape — though it’s hard to say how much that means since the others seem to be effectively insolvent and only remaining afloat via an implicit guarantee from the federal government. So I don’t know the best answer to whether JPMChase was ‘forced’. But if they were, perhaps they can suggest a schedule for paying the money back to the Treasury?
Watching Rep. Connie Mack (R-FL) on CNN calling for Tim Geithner to resign. After just nine weeks on the job? We all know the real culprit here is Obama. He’s had an entire 10 weeks to wreck the country. Things were fine before.
Vice President Biden’s chief economic advisor Jared Bernstein says the House’s bonus taxing bill “may be a dangerous way to go,” Sen. Judd Gregg (R-NH) says the Obama budget will bankrupt America, but WH Council of Economic Advisers Chair Dr. Christina Romer is confident the economy will bottom out and be growing again by year’s end. All that and more in today’s Sunday Show Roundup …
Full-size video at TPMtv.com.
Obama: “I think that Vice President Cheney has been at the head of a movement whose notion is somehow that we can’t reconcile our core values, our Constitution, our belief that we don’t torture, with our national security interests.” That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.
The Treasury Secretary will announce more details on the bank bailout plan in the next few minutes. Treasury has released a new fact sheet on the plan, and in a WSJ op-ed today, Geithner looks to rebrand “toxic assets” as “legacy securities” (bad mortgages are dubbed “legacy loans”).
As part of their efforts to make the scale and scope of Bernie Madoff’s crimes clear to Judge Denny Chin in deciding the terms of his plea, confinement and eventual sentencing, the folks at the US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York submitted emails from Madoff’s victims describing the injury they had suffered and the punishment they believed Madoff deserved.
When you read through the emails, though, you do sort of wonder what level of vetting was applied to these emails or who some of those people even are. And when you get to the email on page 36 you get the sense that the quality control on which emails they threw on the pile maybe wasn’t all that high.
Here’s the text of that email …
From: [redacted]
Sent: Saturday, March 07, 2009 6:38 PM
Subject: REPLY MEMy Name is Mr. [redacted] but my origin is from Republic of Congo. I have an inherited fund I want to invest in a business in your country with a help of a local. I don’t know about what business but I found it wise to invest the funds in your country with your collaboration with me.
Ever since I move to Dubai due to the problem in my country, I have not been able to invest the funds in Dubai due to security reasons. Now I am seeking foreign assistance to transfer the funds in your country based on the news of their development.
If you can assist, I am willing to give you 10% of the funds that is US$3.5Million. You will understand that my entire life and future depend on this money and I shall be very grateful if you can assist me. The major thing I demand from you is the absolute assurance that the funds will be safe and you will not sit on it when it is transferred into your account.
I will be willing to coming to your country once everything has been done and the funds are in your bank to discuss on lucrative investment in your country.
I hope to hear from you so that we might get to talk better on this issue. Please do give me your contact information in order for me to call you ASAP.
If this email offends your moral value, do accept my apology.
Hope to hear from you soon.
Best Regards,
[redacted]
See the original here (scroll to page 36).
I have to confess I couldn’t stop laughing for maybe 10 or 15 minutes after I read this. Really a bang on this one, guys. How many of the rest of these ‘victim’ emails are just crank emails?
(ed.note: Hats off to TPM Reader DW for looking a little closer than the US Attorney’s office staff.)
Following up on the reviews of Tim Geithner’s latest plan, why do we keep coming back to this idea? The modalities are different. But fundamentally it’s a different twist on the original TARP idea — use government muscle (either in dollars or guarantees) to buy the ‘toxic assets’ from the banks at prices pretty close to the high prices the banks want to believe they’re worth rather than the much lower prices that a lot of economists (and let’s remember, the market) say they’re worth. So, if it’s such a bad idea, why do we keep coming back to it.
I posed this question to Joe Stiglitz back in early February. And this is what he said …
You can see the rest of our Stiglitz interview here.
Late Update: Some of the responses to this post assumed the title was a rhetorical question. Actually, it’s a real question. If it’s such a bad idea, why is the idea so persistent. Real question.
I wanted to flag for everyone that Brad DeLong is not nearly so down on the new Geithner plan as some others are.
We’re trying to make sense of what we think of Tim Geithner’s latest go at resolving the toxic assets issue. As we’ve discussed in various places going back months now, it seems like another twist on the basic concept of getting taxpayers to pay or underwrite purchasing these bad debts from the banks at inflated, perhaps wildly inflated, prices. Here’s a roundup of harsh critiques of the plan.
But I’d like to take a moment to pursue another point Thoma made a few days ago which, though specifically applied to AIG, applies to the large bank bailout issue as well.
Thoma was reviewing Lucian Bebchuk’s argument that AIG is not to big to fail and that rather than continue to pump taxpayer dollars into that black hole we should usher the company through some process of managed bankruptcy/restructuring. Thoma seems to broadly agree that this is the best approach but points to the unlikely but not impossible catastrophic outcome.
Think of it like this — both to understand the best way forward and as a way to understand the possible thinking of people at Treasury.
For the sake of discussion let’s assume that ‘biting the bullet’ with AIG or the banks (broadly speaking putting them through some form of managed restructuring as opposed to keeping them on life support) has a 5/6 chance of a good outcome, much better and much cheaper for the taxpayer than the current situation. But there’s a 1/6 chance of a catastrophic outcome. Are those good odds?
Now, let’s think about it from Geithner’s point of view. You have a 1/6 chance of literally destroying the economy, with all the real and reputational consequences of that fact. And what are the upsides of the 5/6 chance? Here’s where the gaming out gets interesting, for lack of a better word. It’s not as though if you try the Swedish model, or some spin on it that everything gets great all of a sudden and people get their 401k money back and everyone who got laid off gets their jobs back.
You’d probably get a good nod in the history books. And you’d likely have saved the taxpayers a ton of money in the longterm and you’d avoid going down in history as the standout driver of moral hazard of all times. But a lot of these benefits and the perception of the benefits would accrue over months and years, even decades.
Now, you might say, tough luck. This is what real leadership should look like — you take stock of the situation and do what’s right, even if the political upside isn’t that great. And I haven’t taken into account here that the ‘safe’ approach may not work at all. And if it doesn’t then the Stimulus will be stillborn and so forth and we’ll remain in a terrible spot. But I do think risk aversion in the sense I’ve described helps illuminate why we seem to be in the paralyzed position that many of us (I think rightly) decry.