Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
04.08.09 | 10:04 am
Counterpoint

TPM Reader EK:

There’s a lot of discussion about how the Republicans are framing the ‘defense cut’ meme, but I’m also concerned about your response. It seems like your reaction is, “don’t say Obama is cutting Defense when he isn’t and shouldn’t.” My reaction is, “don’t give Obama credit for cutting the Defense budget when he isn’t and should.”

Late Update: TPM Reader JC responds:

EK’s comment — that Obama’s not cutting the Pentagon budget, and he should — is helpful, but it goes beyond that. There’s a curious silence in the left/center blogosphere about the merits of the policy that’s driving this latest budget.

The shift from top dollar, fancy-pants weapons systems to a COIN-centric Defense budget contains a host of issues worth considering. We’re betting heavily on a defense policy that that requires a) lots of troops on the ground, b) boatloads of money, & c) a willingness to insert ourselves in failed states & global hotspots where there are insurgencies to counter in the first place. In addition, it takes years (if not decades) for counterinsurgency to succeed — with, of course, absolutely no guarantee that it will. They don’t call this the Long War for nothing. Have Afghanistan & Iraq been so much fun that we were prepared to commit to this?

Clearly, none of this is an argument for continuing to spend on massively over budget Cold War-era programs. My point is that it would be useful to consider the implications of the policy behind the budget. Regrettably, not enough folks seem to be doing this. …

04.08.09 | 9:18 am
Reader Alert

We want your help in finding examples of the emerging meme that Obama’s proposed defense budget amounts to an old-style, lefty, dovish, weak-on-defense capitulation. Keep an eye especially on local media in your area. Oftentimes, comments made back home by senators and representatives fly under the national media radar.

Bonus points for finding examples of (1) Democrats (like Rep. Dan Boren of Oklahoma) saying it; (2) the media repeating and perpetuating it uncritically; and (3) Republicans who blame the phantom defense “cuts” on Obama’s out-of-control, budget-busting domestic spending, to use their terminology.

Email your examples, with links so we can confirm them, to the “Send Comments & News Tips” address at the top of the page. And, as always, thanks.

04.08.09 | 8:52 am
What’s the Matter with Minnesota?

Michele Bachmann (R-MN): I, too, know more about MIT scientist’s study on costs of emissions caps than he does.

Late Update: TPM Reader AV responds and tries to explain:

As a Minnesotan who lives in the 5th District but has worked in the 6th, I will say that perhaps the best question is “What is wrong with the 6th District in Minnesota that they would re-elect this beastly hellspawn who appears to represent that state?”

Minnesota does churn out some nutty characters, this is true: Jesse Ventura, Michele Bachmann, Prince and Norm Coleman come to mind (for various but not always common reasons). But you must also keep in mind that we unleashed unto the world the likes of Paul Wellstone, Eugene McCarthy and the Coen Brothers. We’re not terribly lame.

Oh, and we’re real nice, too.

04.08.09 | 7:53 am
Prepare to be Stalked

Roger Ebert takes on Bill O’Reilly.

04.08.09 | 7:31 am
Patriot Games

We started tracking yesterday the emerging meme that Obama’s restructuring of the defense budget amounts to being weak on defense. It’s an important early framing of the debate, driven by Republicans, and all too often adopted by media who should know better.

The meme is in full bloom this morning, with a chorus of Republicans equating the elimination of wasteful and obsolete weapons programs with being dovish — even as the money is reallocated to other defense priorities and the total defense budget increases.

But I don’t think anyone has gone quite as far as Rep. Tom Cole (R-OK):

While President Obama’s short changing of America’s Armed Forces is deeply disappointing, it is – unfortunately – not a surprise. Throughout his campaign and during his short tenure as President, he has made it clear that he believes his charm and eloquence are adequate substitutes for a strong military. That will not work. Whether President Obama knows it or not, President Bush’s foreign enemies were also America’s enemies. He cannot charm them out of their opposition to our country. The cuts announced today, however, take that naivete to a dangerous new level. I intend to do everything I can to make sure they do not actually occur.

Cole perfectly captures the strident, reactionary, and ultimately stale and unoriginal talking points coming from the GOP. We’ve been hearing this for so long, it’s almost a caricature of the right wing, still reading Tom Clancy and fighting the Soviets.

04.08.09 | 7:02 am
Extra!

If you’re not in the business, the steady drip of newspaper deaths and near-deaths over the last few months may not register as the sweeping upheaval that it is. We’ve put together a slideshow of some of the most significant recent developments. It’s pretty staggering, so take a look.

04.08.09 | 5:16 am
TPMDC Morning Roundup

Biden: Cheney is “dead wrong.” That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.

04.08.09 | 5:13 am
How Does Colbert Do It?

In the latest installment of his “Better Know a District” series, Colbert manages to get freshman Rep. Dan Maffei (D-NY) to don a fake goatee and mustache and declare his love of cocaine, among other absurdities:

04.08.09 | 3:00 am
What Happened Yesterday?

04.07.09 | 7:31 pm
Wall Street v. Main Street

Don Van Natta, Jr., on the risky bond deals that small municipalities got suckered into making before the bottom fell out — and the carnage it’s leaving behind.