Behind the scenes on Obama’s trip to the Summit of the Americas.
A bit of follow-up on right-wing paranoia about the Obama/Chavez meeting. I’m just watching Andrea Mitchell interview Michael O’Hanlon about whether President Obama showed some sort of dangerous weakness in happily shaking hands with Hugo Chavez. Mitchell played a clip of the always cartoonish Newt Gingrich and then noted that conservatives are drawing the analogy to John Kennedy’s famous meeting with Nikita Krushchev in which the latter sized Kennedy up as a lightweight and — so the argument goes — thus believed he could push Kennedy around during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
Now, Kruschev? Really? I’m not sure I can imagine a better illustration of the sort of parodic paranoia I’m talking about. We do realize that the US has the most powerful military in the world and Venezuela has little ability to project military power beyond its own borders. It’s a non-entity militarily, even compared to Iran and North Korea. Will he be emboldened into calling Obama el Diablo? Maybe provocatively give away more books?
Late update: Here’s the video:
To trim (the budget) or not to trim (the budget)? Robert Reich answers the question.
First line from a promo for the new issue of Newsmax magazine: “In these deeply troubled times, the question rises to the fore: Is Jesus Christ about to come back?”
That and a profile of Glenn Beck.
Maybe the two stories overlap?
We keep the chat shows running through the day at TPM HQ. And I’ve been listening to a constant stream — mainly but not only on Fox — of talk through the day about whether we should feel weak or ashamed or tarnished or any other number of things because President Obama had a friendly handshake with Huge Chavez of Venezuela.
The whole idea seems so deeply silly to me that it’s hard to know how exactly to even comment on it. But I’m struck once again by the sort of psychologically arrested mentality and extreme emotional insecurity that seems at work in the minds of many foreign policy conservatives — or more specifically, so as not to paint with too broad a brush, those of the neo-conish flavor.
Sure, a lot of this is just political posturing — trying to sound the story out for possible political vulnerabilities on Obama’s part. Throw a bunch of mud up against the wall and see what sticks. What’s striking to me though is that a lot of it seems like a very genuine, gut-level emotional response. (A related example is what Matt Yglesias pointed out a few days ago — how many right-wingers seem to have convinced themselves that North Korea, a borderline failed state on the possible brink of economic collapse somehow has the US over a barrel.)
In the course of our normal lives, few of us have much difficulty identifying habits of defensiveness or a penchant for histrionic or petulant interactions as signs of weakness, not strength. Really powerful people don’t need stunts and usually signal their power by a certain graciousness and indifference in such interactions. They have nothing to prove. But American power, respect, command of public opinion — however you want to define it — must be in these people’s minds an extremely brittle thing. They really do seem like extremely insecure people.
Not our normal fare. But this comes from John Pomfret at the Post …
Jackie Chan believes that the Chinese people need to be controlled! He’s beffudled about democracy. He doesn’t know about freedom.
Speaking at the Boao Forum in southern China, Chan said this: “I’m not sure if it is good to have freedom or not. I’m really confused now. If you are too free, you are like the way Hong Kong is now. It’s very chaotic. Taiwan is also chaotic.”
And this: “I’m gradually beginning to feel that we Chinese need to be controlled. If we are not being controlled, we’ll just do what we want.”
The Chinese audience loved it.
Pomfret follows with an interesting interpretation of what it means.
Let me follow up on my earlier post which asked just who that “suspected Israeli agent” was who Rep. Jane Harman (D-CA) was talking to. Some quick TPM staff research shows that the original Time article on this story from 2006 identified Harman’s interlocutor as Haim Saban.
(See my correction at the bottom of this post. It’s less clear than I originally thought that we know Saban was the person on the other end of the phone call. Time notes that Saban did lobby Pelosi on Harman’s behalf and seems to suggest this as a possible part of the quid pro quo. But a closer look leaves the identity of Harman’s interlocutor an open question.)
Saban is a major entertainment industry mogul, who’s a big contributor to the Democratic party and a major supporter of Israel. If you’re interested in some fun trivia, I think a big chunk of his fortune comes from creating the Mighty Morphin’ Power Rangers. In any case, Saban was born in Alexandria, Egypt, was I believe raised in Israel and then became a naturalized US citizen.
The key here is that the premise of the investigation into AIPAC was precisely whether people around AIPAC were not just big boosters of Israel but in some sense acting as agents of a foreign power — obviously, an extremely explosive question. So the intel sources appear to be referring to him as a “suspected Israeli agent.”
There are obviously a lot of facts we don’t know here. But if Saban is the interlocutor, it seems to me that any legal case against Harman would likely be very shaky since the claim that Saban was an agent of a foreign power would quite likely be legally unsustainable.
Late Update: Ron Kampeas has more on this at the JTA blog.
Important Late Update: A closer look at the original Time article says that Saban was the one who lobbied Pelosi, but not necessarily that Saban was the “agent” in the conversation with Harman. However, Ron Kampeas’s update at JTA says that Saban was in fact the person on the call. So I think this idea is more than likely correct. But let’s make the identification more tentative than I originally suggested. What’s not clear to me is whether Kampeas was doing more than drawing an inference from the Time reporting. So for the moment, let’s say that the identity of Harman’s interlocutor is an open question.
In my comments on the Harman story, you’ll see I’m giving probably as much focus to the hows and whys of the government’s role surveilling Harman as I am to what she’s accused of. So let me early on make this point clear — one issue does not override or trump the significance of the other. I think both are critical. And I think it’s deeply important to keep that fact in mind.
There’ve been a number of hints and examples over recent months and years of the national security apparatus wiretapping or otherwise surveilling members of Congress. In each case, there’s some explanation. In some cases, we’re told it was inadvertent. But what jumps out at me in the Stein’s Harman story is the suggestion that Alberto Gonzales protected Harman because the administration needed her out there spinning the warrantless wiretap story on their behalf.
Now, Jeff’s reporting seems to suggest that this was something Harman was going to do anyway. And Gonzales didn’t want to let this controversy get in her way. But it does not take too big a leap to see this going down rather differently — seeing Harman, fairly or unfairly, compromised by these wiretaps and thus beholden to the administration.
Whether or not there’s anything to that hypothetical about Harman, this issue of wiretapping members of Congress gets into extremely dangerous territory. And I think we’re at the point where we need some clearer explanation of how many times this happened under the tenure of the previous (and for that matter the present) administration.
Obama heads to Langley to address CIA employees this afternoon. That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.
A crucial break from the past or a move that makes America less safe? We take to the Sunday shows for a heated debate about the Obama administration’s recent decision to reveal Bush administration memos regarding the interrogation of terror suspects …
Full-size video at TPMtv.com.