Who can tell me the names of some good, up-and-coming political comics in New York City?
You’ve probably seen some version of this data in numerical form. But it’s still eye-popping in a graph …
The graph on the left charts party identification over the last six years. Democrats held steady, then surged in the 2008 campaign and finally came down off those highs after the election. Republicans have been steadily down — from just under 1/3 or the electorate in 2004 to just under a quarter now.
The graph to the right shows just this year. The lines look fairly similar — but much less so when you see them in the context of the larger trend. That is, the Dems were coming off an extremely high 39% party affiliation and a build up into the election. For Republicans it’s just a continuation of the same 5 year trend.
Just as noticeable — independent affiliation is the biggest ‘winner’. But for the moment at least, actual elections are zero sum games between the two major political parties. The Democratic ‘brand’ (we’ve got to understanding the world in something beside marketing terms) is holding up nicely. The GOP brand remains in steep decline.
More connections emerge in the broadening array of pay-to-play state pension fund scams. As Andrew Cuomo, who’s investigating the case, puts it: “This is sort of like when you pull a thread on the sweater and that one thread starts to unravel the entire fabric. We’re pulling threads and it turns out the other end of the thread is in New Mexico or Connecticut or Illinois or in California.”
We pull some of the threads here.
Which Republican had the most whacked reaction to Arlen Specter’s party switch? Let’s review the contenders …
On my previous post, TPM Reader MO says the following …
Perhaps I’m only fairly sane as well, but I do think the GOP has a point. If you take Goldwater and Reagan as the baseline for conservatism, and perhaps H.W Bush as a reformed conservative, it’s pretty easy to see why people like Sullivan, etc. don’t consider the Bush years as conservative ones.
My earlier post was more assertion than argument, so let me expand on the point. There are many flavors of conservatism. And among them are many people who can look at President Bush’s eight years in office and point to policies they didn’t like. But that’s not the standard. Or in any case it’s a foolish one. The question is just how President Bush’s actual tenure in office differs from previous Republican leaders who remain firmly in the pantheon.
I would start by casting off Goldwater because you really cannot compare candidacies, which are inherently aspirational and since they have no power can combine all sorts of totally contradictory impulses and be all things to all people. Along the same lines, political philosophies aren’t based in pundits or really good books. They’re a matter of political movements — parties, records in office, political institutions, all of which exist in the fallen world of constrained options in the real world. So let’s focus on the obvious counter-example, Ronald Reagan.
My sense is that for the vast majority of Republicans, their current and alleged beef with President Bush is that he espoused some sort of ‘big government conservatism’. He was profligate with the nation’s finances and left the country settled with huge structural deficits.
How is this different from Reagan’s time in office exactly? They’re actually surprisingly similar.
Both presidents pushed through big tax cuts, squeezed domestic discretionary spending, though never as much as opponents feared or supporters professed to hope for, and spent lavishly on defense. Having two big wars gave President Bush more to spend on. But the broad pattern is very similar. And both ended up leaving the country with really big deficits, though Reagan did a bit in the latter years of his administration to even the balance. Again, very, very similar. So either Bush is well within the conservative tradition or Reagan is another phony.
Perhaps you could argue that President Bush was too big government on the civil liberties and state power front. But it’s the rump GOP which has staked its reputation on a principled embrace of torture, warrantless wiretapping and various other kinds of extra- and unconstitutional actions. So that doesn’t strike me as credible. How else did President Bush’s Republican party get away from its conservative roots.
Late Update: TPM Reader MS adds some snark …
It’s even more amazing that there were precious few voices on the right pointing out Bush’s conservative heresy.
If only the right-wing had some sort of mass media outlets at their disposal – you know, a book publisher or wonkish magazines or a cable TV news channel, just to pull three totally hypothetical examples out of thin air – to get the word out during Bush’s time in office – when something could have been done about this heresy, in real time – that he was betraying conservatism.
It’s truly amazing how much it has become an accepted truism, even among fairly sane people, that under George W. Bush the Republican party got away from its conservative roots.
Debt collectors take cyber-stalking to boffo new lengths. In this case the debt collectors set up a website with a url version of the debtors name advertising the fact that she was behind on her car payments. JaneSmithIsn’tPayingHerBills.com, etc.