Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
05.24.09 | 10:32 am
More on Safe Havens

We’ve gotten various responses to the question I posed below. Here’s TPM Reader RW’s response …

I think you oversimplify the issue of safe havens. In counter-terrorist operations, every second and dollar a terrorist organization must use to physically protect the organization is a dollar and a second it does not have to work on initiating a terrorist operation. In Afghanistan under the Taliban, al Qaeda had a government willing to provide an entire country for a safe haven. In other words, the Taliban used its state sovereignty as a shield to protect al Qaeda from the reach of law enforcement. It turns the problem of terrorism from a law enforcement to one of warfare.

From that perspective, terrorist groups who are protected by state sponsors are especially deadly to the nation-state. It is especially critical to the passive helper, the friend that agrees to leave his keys in his car on a specific night, or who hides a wounded fighter in his basement for a night. It is these passive supporters who, knowing terrorists have a far-off and powerful patron, are willing to invest, in their own small way, in the promised terrorist victory. Those passive supporters are the real lifeblood of Islamic terrorism.

This is why Bush’s policy of not pressing Pakistan to get rid of terrorist havens made no sense. The only thing that has allowed the Taliban to survive for so long is the connections it maintains with the outside world via Pakistan’s ISI. Those connections have been its only source of support and its only vehicle for launching attacks for its entire existence. Cut those connections, as Obama is trying to do, and you eliminate al Qaeda as the very real threat it is. In essence, Obama is forcing the Taliban and its al Qaeda allies to fight a two-front war for the first time ever. This is a winning strategy. The stateless terrorist is far less appealing to the passive supporter.

I don’t think this settles the larger question by any means. But I think there are a few key errors in RW’s logic.

First, not all states are created equal. They can be powerful in either military, financial, diplomatic or scientific terms. And one’s that have one or more of those qualities can be very dangerous as state sponsors of terrorism. But Afghanistan under the Taliban’s first reign had none of those. And given the poverty of the country itself, it’s quite difficult to imagine it ever will. You’re not going to have funds funneled through the intricate Afghan financial services sector or really do anything else. The key thing the Taliban offered al Qaida in the first round was non-interference, which isn’t nothing. As a state, the central fact about Taliban-controlled Afghanistan was that it was barely a state at all, which in many ways was what made it so attractive to al Qaida. And to wrap up on this point, the idea that al Qaida operatives are going to get passive assistance from Muslims in Albany or Riyadh or Bali because they have the tacit backing of Afghanistan strikes me as ludicrous.

Second, it’s true that a key element of counter-terrorism strategy is that you want to put pressure on a terrorist adversary on all fronts. And time and money that doesn’t have to go toward self-protection can be routed toward forward operations. Earlier in this decade this got sort of distorted and warped into ‘fighting them over there so we don’t have to fight them here.’ But again, there are two key problems with this argument in this case. First, if you’re going to fight them ‘over there’ it’s key to know where they are. And most of al Qaida wasn’t in Afghanistan. Many had come through. But most were in other Muslim countries or in the West. Rooting the command and control from Afghanistan was key. But much of the disruption operations were a matter of cracking down in other ways on operatives in other countries. Related to this, I’m not saying that the ideal isn’t to deny al Qaida safe havens anywhere. It’s a relative thing. Is it the best use of our resources? Most of these guys have been laying low in Pakistan for the last seven or eight years. And might we be creating more terrorists in a 20 year counter-insurgency than we kill or deny safe havens too?

It comes back to the same question: how critical is it whether terrorist capos can hide out, with the passive approval of the government, in caves in Afghanistan? And should this be the center-piece of our counter-terrorism effort or even our whole foreign policy?

05.24.09 | 9:27 am
TPMDC Sunday Roundup

Newt Gingrich declares that Gitmo should remain open until “the terrorists disappear.” That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Sunday Roundup.

05.24.09 | 6:41 am
How Much Do Safe Havens Matter?

I’m still trying to decide what I think about this question. But given how much strategic focus we’re giving to Afghanistan, I’m confident we haven’t given the question enough collective thought. Matt Yglesias had a post a couple months ago asking a basic question: how much does it really matter if al Qaida has safe havens in Afghanistan?

To be clear, no one’s saying it doesn’t matter at all. But does it matter enough, relative to other threats, to make Afghanistan — and specifically, the escalation of our involvement in Afghanistan — close to the focus of our whole foreign policy? Ethnic Afghans have played little or no role in any of the major terrorist incidents of the last decade. And most were planned and organized either in Europe, the US or in other Arab or majority Muslim countries. The training camps we hear a lot about mainly focused on light combat training and maybe car-jackings. As Matt puts it, the ‘safe havens’ in Afghanistan were neither necessary (the training could be and often was done elsewhere) nor sufficient (you still needed cells in the target countries) conditions for any of the major terrorist attacks. So why is this such a critical focus of our policy?

On the other side of the spectrum, I’d put the following considerations. If al Qaida types get plugged in in the thriving opium trade in Afghanistan that’s clearly a source of money. And one of the best counter-terrorism strategies seems to be just keeping the members of terrorist organizations under pressure and threat everywhere. So you wouldn’t want one country where bin Laden and his pals could live more or less unmolested and in the open — though given what happened and how many drones we have on patrol, it’s not really credible to me that quite that would ever be allowed again.

Then there’s the question of Pakistan. On really every front, money, safe havens, weaponry, even nuclear weapons, Pakistan has everything that Afghanistan has, only ten-fold, though there’s probably a decent argument that the two countries are umbilical when it comes to counter-terrorism policy.

And let me finish on two further points. Through much of the last decade, I’ve been in the group of people saying that Iraq was a distraction and that Afghanistan was the place we really needed to be focusing on. So this is in conflict with much I’ve said before. Furthermore, if you look at the history, the role of Afghanistan going back over the last few decades, wasn’t so much that it allowed for safe havens but that the guerilla, semi-irregular wars there spun off thousands of violent, highly-trained and religiously intoxicated extremists who later spread out around the world spreading terror right and left. And that makes intensifying the conflict in Afghanistan to prevent the growth of safe havens a logically questionable proposition.

Like I said up top, I’m not sure where I come down on this one. But given how central a role ‘safe havens’ play in current policy and how much focus we’re giving to this policy, it really requires more scrutiny. Let me know your thoughts. I’m curious what others have to say.

05.24.09 | 4:53 am
Will Jihad for Cash and Weed?

Girlfriends of two of the ‘Newburgh Four’ have come forward now — in articles in the Daily News and New York Post. And while, as you’d expect, they’re putting their men in the best light, suggesting they were tricked into the plot, it does seem clear that cash gifts, free rent and bags and bags and bags of weed may have been a stronger enticement for these goofballs than Islam.

David Williams is the one of the four who’d recently moved to Newburgh to help his mom care for his brother, who reportedly has terminal cancer. His mom says that “Maqsood”, the name the informant was using, promised to pay for the brother’s hospital bills.

These are all, of course, claims from highly interested sources. So we’ll have to watch closely what gets borne out in court proceedings. But it bears watching.

05.23.09 | 9:06 am
TPMDC Saturday Roundup

You can’t keep a good man down. Former Vice President Dick Cheney is reportedly shopping for a book deal — and wants an advance of over $2 million to tell his story. That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Saturday Roundup.

05.23.09 | 3:00 am
What Happened Yesterday?

Full-size video at TPMtv.com.

05.22.09 | 6:27 pm
Deep Thought

Why is Dick Cheney’s daughter the only person he can find to go on TV to defend him?

05.22.09 | 5:39 pm
From Olbermann

This out from MSNBC …

MSNBC’s Keith Olbermann on tonight’s “Countdown” pledged to donate $10,000 to charity after disc jockey Erich “Mancow” Muller was waterboarded today on live radio, in an attempt to prove the technique was “not torture.” After six seconds Muller said it was “absolutely torture” and that were he to be interrogated by the use of waterboarding he would “confess to anything.” Olbermann promised to donate $10,000 to the charity Veterans of Valor, founded by Sgt. Klay South, who administered the waterboarding to Muller today, and withdrew his offer to Sean Hannity to make a donation to the charity of his choice if he followed through on his offer to undergo waterboarding.

If you haven’t seen the Mancow waterboarding, you can see the full video here. It’s powerful on a number of different levels.

The upshot is that the guy goes into it in cocky Hannity mode and then after maybe 5 or 6 seconds he struggles up and he’s converted, claiming it’s “absolutely torture”, that he never realized it was that bad, etc.

Now, here’s the thing. I’m genuinely surprised that he was was surprised that it was that bad. I’m not saying that for effect. Muller really seemed to think it was like getting dunked by your friend in a pool or something. Just factually, everyone who knows anything about this says that it’s horrific and you pretty much instantly feel like you’re drowning and at the edge of death. And it’s a physiological response. So even if you’ve gone through it ten times and know rationally that you don’t die, it doesn’t matter. You’re instantly put back into the mental space of drowning and being at the edge of death.

I must confess that when I see Hannity or the rest of these guys saying it’s no big deal and it’s not torture, I kind of figured they’re playing semantic games and essentially saying ‘I don’t care what we do to evil Muslim terrorist bad guys.’ Hang them from them toes, waterboard them, whatever, who cares? I don’t agree with that. It’s hideous. But I understand it. But here it turns out they’re just completely ignorant, just haven’t been paying attention. Just in the purest factual sense have no idea what they’re talking about.

I know, I know … why am I surprised?

(ed.note: When does Hannity get waterboarded? That may be waterboarding I can believe in.)

05.22.09 | 2:09 pm
Doesn’t Take Geniuses

From TPM Reader B …

First WTC the guy went back for the security deposit for the truck they blew up…McVeigh did everything short of driving into a police car fleeing the scene…Atta and the boys could only have achieved what they did with the most mind numbingly incompetent executive branch ever. The master plan?

I’ll give you the Tylenol tamperer had some talent but that was a lone nut…In anything with multiple people there has been an extraordinary lack of competence…This was the screw up that helped let 9/11 happen – they were looking for the exotic hollywood terrorists taking over missile silos with Hollywood action figures

I MIGHT be able to give you the attempted take over in South Africa nuke facility was an “A-team” but those guys seemed clearly gov’t backed…So can’t really count em…

Not that I’m arguing the point these guys were not pathetic in the NY case – I’m just saying in history we’ve rarely had a terrorist in the field that wasn’t.

It’s always a balance when reporting out these kinds of cases. It’s certainly true that you don’t need to be a genius to kill a lot of people. I’m not sure I agree with all of B‘s examples. Whatever you can say about 9/11, it was ingenious in its conception and pretty well pulled off. But successful terrorist operations frequently have ‘grunts’ if not the planners who are garden variety morons. So, it’s definitely true you don’t have to be a genius to kill a lot of people.

That said, I don’t think ‘lack of competence’ quite captures the Newburgh crew.