Editors’ Blog
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
05.26.09 | 6:14 pm
Deep Thought

I’m glad we’re in the post-racial era so we can get on to discussing whether Judge Sotomayor is a luke-warm IQ affirmative action hire.

05.26.09 | 4:37 pm
Ouch …

It seems the tide may be turning against Benjamin Cardozo’s candidacy to serve, in a time warp sense of the term, as the nation’s first Hispanic Supreme Court Justice. Over at USNews Robert Schlesinger finds the official US government definition of ‘Hispanic’ (as defined by the Census Bureau) which they define as “persons who trace their origin or descent to Mexico, Puerto Rico, Cuba, Central and South America, and other Spanish cultures.”

05.26.09 | 4:23 pm
Kerik Tries to Get Back Into the News with New Indictment

Disgraced former NYPD Commissioner Bernie Kerik has been indicted by a DC grand jury for lying to White House officials when he was being vetted for his failed Secretary of Homeland Security appointment.

Kerik’s lawyer, Barry H. Berke told WCBS that the indictment was an example of the DOJ’s “overzealous pursuit of high-profile public figures.”

I can’t say I agree with that. But being indicted for lying to folks in the Bush White House Counsel’s office does seem a bit rich. And Kerik has so much real sleaze to work with.

So much sleaze, so little time.

05.26.09 | 2:48 pm
Neanderthal Caucus Weighs In

Sen. James Inhofe (R-OK): “In the months ahead, it will be important for those of us in the U.S. Senate to weigh [Sotomayor’s] qualifications and character as well as her ability to rule fairly without undue influence from her own personal race, gender, or political preferences.”

05.26.09 | 1:24 pm
Not Enough Hispanics in Rolodex?

CNN found it necessary to bring Alberto Gonzales on to reflect on the Sotomayor nomination.

05.26.09 | 1:20 pm
The Day in 100 Seconds: It’s Sonia!

Full-size video at TPMtv.com.

05.26.09 | 12:54 pm
Beware the Numbers

So what to make of the charge from the right that Judge Sotomayor has an allegedly high rate of reversals by the Supreme Court? Fox News’ Major Garrett just raised it with Robert Gibbs at the daily White House press briefing. Here’s the text of exchange (video here):

Garrett: Is a nominee’s history of opinions and reversals a relevant factor for the public and the Senate?

Gibbs: Well, I think it is one of the many factors that likely will be picked over and weighed as we go through this.

Garrett: How does the White House evaluate Judge Sotomayor’s record on this score?

Gibbs: Well, I think if one were to create 380 opinions and have 3 reversed.

Garrett: What’s the Supreme Court ratio?

Gibbs: You tell me.

Garrett: 6 opinions, 3 reversals.

Gibbs: Well, Major, don’t just judge, I wouldn’t judge you on the stories I call you about, I might judge you on the full package of your repertoire. Whether or not you ultimately see fit to change any of the rhetoric on …

Garrett: I am not a nominee for the Supreme Court, let the record reflect.

Gibbs: I would agree with that.

So when outfits like the conservative Judicial Confirmation Network say that Sotomayor has a “terrible record of reversals by the Supreme Court,” what they’re referring to is the narrow and misleading issue of how the Supreme Court has ruled when it has gone so far as to accept the case on appeal. There does not appear to be any sort of unusually high number of her cases making it to the Supreme Court.

Late Update: TPM Reader JH checks in:

About those reversals: It’s worth pointing out that the Supreme Court reverses most of the decisions it takes. The percentage of cases it affirms usually is somewhere in the 25 to 30 percent range, and rarely as high as 40 percent. There’s actually a saying among Supreme Court lawyers that the court grants cert to reverse. In that context, a .500 record is pretty good.

Later Update: Here’s a piece on the Supreme Court reversal rate in recent years that confirms what JH is pointing out.

05.26.09 | 11:28 am
From the Coleman Alt. Universe

Norm Coleman sends word that as soon as he’s sworn in he’ll be reviewing Judge Sotomayor’s record and deciding how he’ll vote.

05.26.09 | 11:05 am
The Opposition

Judicial Watch’s Tom Fitton earlier this afternoon on MSNBC …

The President said that he wanted a judge who had empathy and I read empathy to mean bias in favor of politically correct individuals, whether they be women or a gay person or a black or Hispanic. You know that’s the way they should decide in favor of them no matter what the law is.

05.26.09 | 10:50 am
Sotomayor Slideshow

Scenes from this morning’s Sotomayor announcement.