In a statement to and interview with TPMDC, the NYT‘s Andrew Ross Sorkin apologizes for the flip nature of his union-bashing comments and says he “did not mean to suggest that there are literally no successful companies that employ union workers.”
We’re still at it compiling our list of successful companies (defined as profitable in 2008) which are unionized. You can watch the Sorkin performance in this union-bashing segment of MSNBC’s Morning Joe.
A few things become quickly apparent as you start going over the list and thinking for a moment about the degree of unionization in U.S. industry. The first is that unions remain pervasive in old economy industries like natural resource extraction and manufacturing, industries which have taken their licks of course but continue in many cases to remain profitable. Unions also remain pervasive in older industries that we don’t always think of as old economy because they’ve adapted to new technologies, industries like telecommunications and entertainment (from the TV networks to the movie studios), where many companies have done very well.
Then there’s the mergers and acquisitions dynamic, which complicates what it means to be “unionized.” Divisions and subsidiaries of the same company may have vastly different levels of unionization, depending on the kind of work they do and their history prior to being acquired. So there’s less black and white in large companies, and they can’t be as easily categorized as union or non-union shops.
If all of those nuances complicate putting together a list of successful unionized companies, then they surely argue against as sweeping a charge as Sorkin’s: that you can’t name any such companies.
Yep, he’s sure running for president.
Out-going Gov. Pawlenty (R) of Minnesota is on Fox right now talking about Obama’s ‘nationalization’ of the health, auto and energy industries in the US and comparing to the country to a Latin American dictatorship circa 1970.
We’ll bring you the details shortly.
As a white man, I’m proud that Pat Buchanan is becoming the lead public advocate for the White Male Movement.
As you’ve seen, this morning on Morning Joe, The New York Times Andrew Ross Sorkin suggested
that few if any unionized companies are successful and profitable — a demonstrably false claim. And David Kurtz and our news team are on the case, reporting the story out and compiling a list of companies that belie this claim.
Now, it’s no secret to you that TPM has an editorial outlook that is broadly sympathetic to the union movement. But what strikes me about this comment is that it’s not some random chat show yakker like Hannity or Scarborough. This is one of the Times top business reporters. He runs their markets and finance blog — Dealbook, which is actually quite good and a sign, I think, that the Times is very much in the new media, iterative journalism chase. So quite apart from the politics of it, this is just a jarring level of ignorance about corporate America from someone in that position.
Former GE CEO Jack Welch, challenging Joseph Stiglitz last week at a Vanity Fair forum moderated by … Andrew Ross Sorkin: “Give me a highly successful unionized industry.”
There’s really no topic I’m following with more interest at the moment than the back and forth between the Netanyahu government and the Obama White House over the issue of settlements. Netanyahu’s advisers now seem to be pushing the line that Prime Minister Sharon had understandings with President Bush that on-going settlement building was fine within areas already designated for settlement growth and that, at least implicitly, a broad swath of settlements the US now accepts as permanent.
This is an iffy argument on a number of levels — not least of which is that such an agreement would conflict with the ‘Road Map’, which would have a higher standing than a bilateral agreement reached by the US and Israel. More to the point, though, while governments generally put a lot of weight on honoring understandings of predecessors, the Bush ‘letter’ wasn’t a treaty or even a formal bilateral agreement. So I don’t think it has any force at all — setting aside that it conflicts with the Road Map.
More generally, as I said, I’m extremely interested to see how this develops. And we’re also interested as an organization. And this is a question that’s all going to be in the murmurs and nuances, in terms of seeing how the jousting between the two governments evolves. So if and when you see new details in articles you read, please send them along to me.
Late Update: A key part of this equation is what happens in Congress — particularly on the Democratic side of the aisle. There have been signs that AIPAC has been having its usual level of success getting members of Congress to sign letters to the president, and so forth. But I’ve been more interested to see indications that when Netanyahu’s intermediaries have gone to members of Congress to sound out what they’re willing to do to push back against the emerging policy, that they have not been hearing what they’d like to hear. TPM Reader LR just sent me this post by James Besser at The Jewish Week that looks more deeply into this part of the settlements equation.