Following the lead of this post by Jon Taplin, you really must read this article in the Times on the battle over including a ‘public option’ in the new Obama health care reform bill. If you’re not familiar with the lingo of this debate, the ‘public option’ refers to allowing the federal government to sell its own insurance plan which would compete with private health insurance providers. Think of it as a version of Medicare that everyone could buy into.
Here’s the key graf from the Times piece …
But critics argue that with low administrative costs and no need to produce profits, a public plan will start with an unfair pricing advantage. They say that if a public plan is allowed to pay doctors and hospitals at levels comparable to Medicare’s, which are substantially below commercial insurance rates, it could set premiums so low it would quickly consume the market.
As Taplin suggests, these ‘problems’ sound remarkably like ‘the point’ of the whole exercise. Most of the argument here is that a big government plan would just provide the insurance ‘service’ much more efficiently and cheaply than private carriers. And that the private carriers wouldn’t be able to make any money off selling the service any more. But this is the argument that single payer advocates routinely make — namely, that a lot of the money that goes into private health insurance goes to paperwork, much of which is tied to finding ways to deny people coverage. That, and the need to earn profits on providing the service.
Presumably if there were other quality advantages to the private plans, the carriers wouldn’t be so worried that everyone would switch to the public plan. I think I might be open to some effective scare-mongering on that front. But the private carriers don’t seem to have much confidence there’s much to scare people about.
Hillary Clinton declares that President Obama has in fact passed the “3 a.m.” test. That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Sunday Roundup.
Last week we discussed the latest polling data out of Israel responding to Obama’s policy push, the settlements question and a two-state solution. Now Bernie Avishai has a much more fine-grained look at the data — both the bad news and the good.
Whatever your political persuasion on this issue, I strongly recommend you give this a read. Among the many things it shows is how deeply divided Israel is today (much like the Palestinian community in the territories) and the simple reality that neither side of this conflict can resolve this on their own — outside pressure is necessary.
It is frequently said that Israel’s chaotic low-bar-to-entry parliamentary system makes the country hostage to single-interest splinter parties which obstruct the popular will.
But though he doesn’t say it explicitly, Avishai’s analysis makes clear that this isn’t really true. It is probably fair to say that while a majority doesn’t support the settlement project and would like a two-state solution eventually — that a consistent majority favors not facing up to the hard choices and perpetuating the unsustainable status quo as long as possible.
Which is essentially what the political system has provided.
Hillary Clinton rejects Israel’s claims of secret deals with the Bush Administration regarding the settlements. That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Saturday Roundup.
Reich: How Pharma and the insurances cos plan to kill the ‘public option’ in health care reform.
Actually it came some time ago. But here’s a telling public opinion nugget. A big majority (58%) of self-identified conservatives now support allowing gays to serve openly in the military.
For the population as a whole, support stands at 69%.
I’ve suggested in my posts on the settlements issue that an Israeli government can’t withstand any serious tension in the relationship with the United States. So as long as he remains popular at home, Obama holds almost all the cards in his battle with Netanyahu over settlements. Jeffrey Goldberg suggests that that is precisely what Obama is trying to do: topple Netanyahu’s government. I’ve considered that too. And at some level I think he’s right. But at another level I think the question is over-determined. I think that Obama and his people know that right now they have to start a series of steps that lead in the near term to a peace settlement. Settlements are the logical place to start. And whether it simply halts settlements, leads to Bibi’s overthrow or forces him into a new coalition, every result gets you closer to the goal which is in the interests of the US, the Israelis and the Palestinians.