
The guy on the right is defeated presidential candidate Mirhossein Mousavi. The guy on the left? Not sure who he is. But Fox News ran video of him at the big rally in Tehran today, and anchor Bill Hemmer identified him as Mousavi. Watch here. (Note that in a wider shot in the video a protester right next to our mystery guy is holding up a picture of the real Mousavi.)
Late Update: A TPM reader emails in to say that the guy on the left is Mohammad-Reza Khatami, and the resemblance seems pretty striking. So not a random protester, but another significant figure in the reform movement.
For much of the weekend it seemed that the Iranian reformists were set for one of those righteous defeats, in which a united phalanx of state power stands down rioting protesters who must be content that their defiance will lay the groundwork for change not today but at some unknown point in the future. But this morning we awoke to word that Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has directed the country’s Guardian Council to review claims that the election was tainted by fraud. And Mousavi himself reportedly appeared at a rally today in Tehran, his first appearance post-election. Read More
Addressing the Minnesota GOP convention over the weekend, Norm Coleman rallied the troops around denying Dems a magical 60th vote in the Senate.
Iranian President Ahmadenijad has claimed defiantly that his reelection was legitimate, but allegations of election stealing have sparked protests in the streets of Tehran. Does the Obama administration accept the results? And what does the outcome say about Barack Obama’s push for reconciliation between the West and the Arab world?
Full-size video at TPMtv.com.
The focus is on the evolving situation in Iran, but also today Obama pitches health care reform to the AMA’s annual conference. That and the day’s other political news in the TPMDC Morning Roundup.
Bill Keller (editor of the whole operation) and Michael Slackman have a piece in Times arguing that Ahmadinejad and the hard line clerical establishment emerge from Friday’s selection with a stronger hand than ever before. I’m curious whether others share that impression.
I guess you could wrench some reason for optimism from PM Netanyahu’s speech today if you view it as an opening gambit, albeit couched in a lot of deal-breakers necessary to keep his rightist coalition intact. But that strikes me as a bit of a stretch. Most reactions in the US press are treating this as a major move by Netanyahu, endorsing the idea of a Palestinian state. But that seems doubly naive a) since that’s been the premise of US policy for almost 20 years as well as a goal accepted by several Israeli governments and b) because Netanyahu’s conditions amounted to deal breakers.
It’s been a premise of all the negotiations that a future Palestinian state would have to have some real restrictions on ‘heavy’ weaponry and wouldn’t be able to do things like invite foreign armies on to its soil. But what the Palestinian state Netanyahu described is something that lacks the key attributes that apply to almost all states, like statehood, for instance. It was a relabeling of what Netanyahu was pushing back in the mid-1990s, which is a sort of regional autonomy and self-government.
On the point of the need for the Palestinians to unequivocally recognize “Israel as the nation state of the Jewish people,” a few thoughts.
I’ve seen a few different wordings of this in the press. And the English language advanced transcript sent out by the Israeli government press office, there are a few different formulations. What to make of it? There are things you say when you are trying to settle differences and things you don’t.
All of the negotiations to this point have been premised on recognizing Israel as a Jewish state.
Where the rubber meets the road in a real sense is on the issue of refugees and a Palestinian right of return. The Israelis will never accept a right of return for every descendent of the refugees of the 1948. It would make Israel no longer a Jewish state. If that’s the Palestinians condition, then really no deal is possible. But this is an issue that’s been worked through in great detail at the negotiating table. And there’ve been a number of rough outlines of a possible compromise — most of which allow a right of return in principle but satisfy the vast majority with compensation while allowing a small number to resettle in Israel, small enough not to substantially change the demographic make-up of the population.
Regardless of all these details, what Israel needs and has a right to ask for is a final settlement that, once all the compromises are made, recognizes the State of Israel and declares all the unclosed issues of borders and refugees closed forever. Facts and commitments are what treaties and negotiations and peaceful coexistence are made of. Getting the other side to ascribe to your national dreams and mythologies is too much to ask.
I hope I’m making the distinction clear. Perhaps it’s a subtle one. But it’s a critical one. Of course, any peace settlement will require the Palestinians to recognize Israel as what it is, a Jewish state, and put in the past any questions of whether a Jewish state, Israel, is legitimate in Palestine. But the upshot of Netanyahu’s speech has him almost demanding the Palestinians themselves become Zionists.
I think before he was arrested but during the Second Intifada, I saw an interview with Marwan Barghouti in which he said that for peace the Israelis would have to give up the ‘mentality of occupation.’ That phrase has rattled through my head ever since. And that, I think, is what Netanyahu’s speech was mainly about.
Late Update: Akiva Eldar, writing in Ha’aretz, puts it well …
The demilitarization of the Palestinian state was mentioned in the Clinton guidelines, the Taba understandings and the Geneva accord, as was the right of return to Palestine, not Israel. The difference between these documents and the Bar-Ilan address is not only that the former recognized the Palestinians’ full rights to the West Bank and East Jerusalem. The real difference lies in the tone – in the degrading and disrespectful nature of Netanyahu’s remarks. That’s not how one brings down a wall of enmity between two nations, that’s not how trust is built.
It’s hard to believe that a single Palestinian leader will be found who will buy the defective merchandise Netanyahu presented last night.
The text of PM Netanyahu’s speech today, as prepared for delivery.
It’s about time someone said it.
From Jane Mayer’s article on and interview with Panetta.
CIA Director Leon Panetta on Dick Cheney: “It’s almost, a little bit, gallows politics. When you read behind it, it’s almost as if he’s wishing that this country would be attacked again, in order to make his point. I think that’s dangerous politics.”
It wouldn’t be the first time an extremist got so twisted up trying to prove he was right about how to protect his country that he was willing to sacrifice some of his countrymen to prove it.
Vice President Biden expresses doubts about the Iranian election. That and other political news in today’s TPMDC Sunday Roundup.