President gaming out what might happen to him if he were caught trying to break into the White House.
It’s a funny thing. When I was watching the press conference tonight during the Gates question, I think I must have looked away or maybe been writing when Obama made the “stupidly” comment. Because I didn’t hear it. But I don’t think it changes my mind or my original impression.
Now there’s a flood of para-commentary: not necessarily what he said, which is inconveniently unremarkable. But are we surprised that he said it? Should he have gone into such detail? What’s the fallout?
The political press is all atwitter over this, a bit like just after two high school kids square off for a fight but just before the punches start flying. But let’s be honest: this is all about a black guy getting on the side of another black guy who got crosswise with the cops. Why would he touch such a powder keg? Like it’s going to ignite at least one more battle in the late lamented Culture War.
Hopefully now Obama can appoint Gates to the Supreme Court so we can have the Republicans create a media circus when the cop who arrested Gates testifies at Gates’ confirmation hearings.
Here are some salient facts. The house was Gates’ house. From what I understand, no one disputes that prior to his arrest and while in the house, Gates provided proof that the house was his. When you have those facts and the guy whose house it is ends up getting arrested, I think that’s prima facie evidence of bad police work.
We certainly can’t know it was racism. And perhaps there are extraordinary facts that would show the arrest was proper — that all the escalation came from Gates, was unwarranted and left the officer no choice but to arrest him. But I think the assumption has to be that the officer mishandled the situation. Because we hire the police to protect us from burglars breaking into our homes, not to arrest us in our own homes if we get a little miffed at being mistaken for burglars. Police are trained to prevent situations like that from escalating. They’re professionals. And I suspect that people who actually train recruits in best practices policing procedure, as opposed to political analyst and GOP press secretaries, would probably agree with that.
I’m failing in my efforts to feign shock that the president said it.
Longtime reader previews the press coverage we can look forward to after Obama’s comments on the Henry Louis Gates case:
Tonight sums up where we are in America: the headlines are all about, not how to get to secure and affordable health care, the preeminent social inclusion issue
relevant to millions of American families, but about African American Obama defending his millionaire friend Skip Gates on the race issue! (Yes, the Cambridge police were stupid, but so was arrogant Skip, who lost his temper and is turning it all into self-promoting race fiction.)Race trumps social-economic justice: just what the right wing wants, and just what has repeatedly derailed possibilities for redistributive reform since the 1960s.
This was Obama’s best chance to get through to millions of ordinary
Americans on health care — and he blows it, with self-obsessed Skip Gates, the race-obsessed press aiding and abetting all the way.
After refusing to make visitor logs public, the White House late today released a list of health care executives who have visited the White House.
8:26 PM … DeMint too pitiful to be named? Probably.
8:27 PM … No mention of faction in Democratic party owned by insurance industry.
8:27 PM … Sheesh, “Jake” requires no identification. That’s fame. Obama’s answer is pretty solid. Jake’s was essentially assuming that reform means rationing.
8:41 PM … Half hour plus, health care not interesting enough. On to transparency and bailouts.
8:44 PM … Broad-ranging defense of bailouts.
8:45 PM … This seems to be what Obama was referencing, a list released tonight of health care execs who have visited the White House to discuss reform.
8:48 PM … I’m sure we’ll hear GOPers mention that line about “taking out some of the profit motive.”
8:53 PM … Obama arrested trying to jimmy the front door at the White House. Quite a moment to consider.
8:55 PM … Hmmm. I may be mistaken but I think he managed to navigate his way through that Gates question and pull it off by hitting the key points and not getting tripped up on any of the tripwires. That was pretty impressive.
8:05 PM … Reform not just about uninsured, but deficit and economic future too.
8:09 PM … This push, these arguments, make me wonder why the conversation didn’t begin with them, rather than get to them now.
8:10 PM … Who’s the GOP strategist who said go for the kill? Bill Kristol.
8:12 PM … Here’s the transcript of Obama’s opening statement.
8:13 PM … Curious whether we get a sharp-edged public option question.
8:15 PM … Interesting angle, Kleefeld points out: president framing status quo as alternative plan. Just one that’s a lot more expensive and involves a lot more people losing their coverage.
8:18 PM … Sheesh, glory night for the wire services. AP, Reuters … UPI next?
8:19 PM … “The default is inertia.”
8:20 PM … It’s interesting to note this list Obama has of just how many interest groups or organizations are behind the plan and yet it seems to be so jammed up. The key is that most of these groups are extremely fair weather friends. Happy to sign on nominally but not putting an ounce of muscle into the effort.
8:22 PM … Chuck Todd rolling out the seldom seen extemporaneously articulated question.
7:52 p.m. ET … Excerpts from Obama’s prepared introductory remarks.
7:54 p.m. … Washington press corps mindset: Whether one man can save his presidency/salvage his domestic agenda is a faux drama much more compelling than whether millions will actually benefit from health care reform.
7:58 p.m. … The Nation‘s Chris Hayes twitters about what presidential presser is like for non-prestige media: “Headed to WH to go pretend I might get called on. Sort of like putting on a tux on prom night and waiting for an imaginary date to show up.”
8:01 p.m. … Here we go …
8:03 p.m. … Complete text of Obama’s introductory remarks.
Rep. Marsha Blackburn (R-TN): “We’re not going to cry ‘emergency‘ every time we have a Katrina.”
How can we ever have real health care reform if Orrin Hatch isn’t on board?