And not just with Sarah Palin …
I have a pretty hard time imagining he’d actually lose a race for reelection. But a new poll has him running neck and neck with professional bombast and former Rep. J.D. Hayworth in a potential 2010 Republican primary.
Jim Comey and Jack Goldsmith defend Holder’s decision to have KSM & Co. tried in civilian courts in New York City — make many of the now standard arguments and make factual points about the overselling of military commissions/tribunals that a lot of people are ignoring.
Some key points — the Bush administration used civilian courts to secure numerous convictions of al Qaeda terrorists since 2001 and the record of military commissions has actually been rather poor, not simply on constitutional or civil liberties grounds, but by the concrete measure of actually convicting people and securing long sentences. What’s difficult to question is that convictions in civilian courts would be vastly more durable and secure against second-guessing than any from military commissions, given how uncertain their status is in US and international law.
A close observer from up on the Hill shares some history and insights about filibusters and sundry delaying tactics …
Reams could be and have been written on the origins, history, evolution and current relevance of the filibuster, but on DC’s point, the answer is pretty simple – any debatable motion can be filibustered. The motion to proceed to a bill or nomination has always been debatable. That’s why it will ultimately take two cloture votes to cut off debate and get a vote on the final bill. Several other motions to move the bill to conference are debatable too. Most of those motions are usually adopted by unanimous consent, but they may not be in this case. Passing a bill when there is passionate opposition to it is hard. That’s just the way it is. It may seem silly to endlessly debate a motion that only starts the debate, but that’s Senate procedure, and it has little to do with the filibuster rule itself.
TPM Reader DC is perplexed …
I’m genuinely puzzled at this. The filibuster, as we know, is rooted in the old Senate tradition of unlimited debate, which can only be waived by an extraordinary supermajority. Some twenty years or so ago, in the interest of keeping the Senate from being utterly tied up, the body changed the rules to permit a sort of virtual filibuster, which still can only be quelled with a supermajority. But here we have a situation in which the threat of unlimited debate is being used to prevent–what? Debate???? Something does not compute. Why can the filibuster rule be used to prevent debate. Even if you like filibusters, it seems an absurd use of the rule.
I’m not sure DC’s chronology is right. I thought the evolution was more complex and over a longer period. But it’s not a bad global point.
Actually, of course, going into this on the health care front. We’re talking about a series of 60 procedural hurdles. 60 votes to start debate. 60 votes to end debate and move to a vote. And probably a bunch of other 60 vote votes for things like emptying the garbage and okaying Orrin Hatch declaring a holy war against health care reform.
Looks like the cloture vote on bringing the health care reform bill to the Senate floor will be held at 8 p.m. Saturday (much to the delight of aides and reporters across the DC metro area).
Fox News did a poll of what Americans think of an American president bowing to the Japanese Emperor.
You’ll remember, this is when Obama shamed America and sent a signal of weakness to emperors worldwide by bowing to the Emperor Akihito, as is the custom in that country.
Oddly enough, Fox phrased the question in a pretty fair way. And Americans answered overwhelmingly that it was fine: 67% to 26%.
Giuliani not running for governor, but he is running for U.S. Senate, reportedly. Oh happy day!
Disappointing Late Update: Not true! says Rudy spox.
After meeting with Sen. Reid (D-NV) yesterday, Sen. Nelson (D-NE) told TPM that Sen. Reid was still floating the possibility of using budget reconciliation for the health care reform bill if he had no other option. But just earlier this afternoon, Brian Beutler asked Sen. Reid what he’d said and he answered pretty categorically.
“I’m not using reconciliation,” Reid told TPM.
That would mean that getting the votes of every Democrat on every procedural vote going forward is the only way reform will pass — all 60 votes.
I would say that no one should treat anything anyone says as definitive in this story, as the final word. You can read into what Reid says, I’m not using it today, I’m not using it, I won’t use it ever. For my part, I like I said, nothing’s final in this story until it’s final. But that’s what he said today.
Like Sarah Palin, another prominent GOPer prefers being a talking head to being governor: The NYT is reporting that Rudy Giuliani has decided not to run for governor of New York.
We just had that new daily segment on Fox News where they apologize for getting caught using phony video to inflate GOP crowd sizes the previous day.
Fun new segment.