
Minnesota’s Amy Klobuchar, a Democrat who headed the prosecutor’s office in Minneapolis before coming to the Senate, turns to another line of criticism against conservative legal ideology: the claim that Justices are like umpires, whose job is simply “call balls and strikes” (a metaphor that Chief Justice Roberts suggested during his confirmation hearing).
She asks Kagan whether the metaphor fits. Kagan says it does in some ways, but it doesn’t in others. Read More

Senator Whitehouse, a Democrat from Rhode Island with experience as his State’s Attorney General and as the United States Attorney for Rhode Island as well, uses his questioning of Elena Kagan to launch a tough attack on the current Supreme Court.
His contention: Justices “with a particular mission and are selectively knocking out precedent that does not coincide with their ideological views.” Read More
Supreme Court nomination hearings are usually pretty boring and ridiculous or Kagan herself once called them “farce.” But yesterday Kagan herself turned in one of the most laugh-line rich performances in recent history. This morning we look at Kagan’s top five jokes and laugh lines from yesterday’s hearings.
As Day Three of the Kagan hearings kick off, our Christina Bellantoni tells us the press seats are near deserted. But our reporter is still there! Catch every development in the story in our special Live Updating TPM Kagan Confirmation Wire.
Sen. Graham tells President Obama to forget about climate and immigration legislation until the next Congress.
In her interview tonight with Jon Ralston, Sharron Angle did her best to walk back her suggestion that people may need to resort to “second amendment remedies” against Obama’s tyranny and the need to “take out Harry Reid.”

Kagan sailed through today’s hearings. She was well informed and well spoken; deferential without appearing craven or intimidated; and her sense of humor was on display. (Best example: during her discussion of terrorism-related legal issues with Senator Graham, he began a series of questions about the failed Christmas Day bombing of the plane headed for Detroit by asking where Kagan was on Christmas Day. Kagan: “like all Jews I was probably at a Chinese restaurant.” (Explanatory note: Many Jews go to a movie and eat dinner out on Christmas Day; usually Chinese restaurants are the only ones open.).)
It is hard to see anything in today’s hearing that could increase opposition to Kagan’s confirmation. But the vast majority of the Committee’s Republican Members – all of them other than Senator Graham, and perhaps Senator Hatch — seem pretty firmly set in their opposition.
A visibly tired Kagan seemed happy to have the day end. We’ll be back again at 9 am tomorrow.

Senator Cardin, one of the more junior Democrats on the committee, begins with a defense of Justice Marshall (a Maryland native). He talks about what Marshall achieved by convincing the Court to reject its decision in Plessy v. Ferguson authorizing segregation. And how that made our union more perfect.
Cardin says that protecting indivduals against abuses of power is crucial, and asks how the Constitution does that. Read More

Several times, Kagan has been asked her view of the scope of Congress’s power under the Commerce Clause. In the 1930s, a limited view of the Commerce Power was used to invalidate New Deal legislation. After President Roosevelt announced his proposal to expand the number of Justices, the famous “switch in time to save Nine” occured, and the Court repudiated its prior decisions and adopted a much broader view of Congress’s power.
That issue is back with a vengeance today. Read More
Fun moment of video when Sen. Grassley appears to ask Elana Kagan whether gun rights don’t come directly from God rather than the constitution.