The End Of A Progressive Champion: Russ Feingold Loses To Ron Johnson

Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI) and Fmr. Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

As the Republican wave spreads across the country, it’s time to say goodbye to one of the big-name progressive champions of the past 18 years: Sen. Russ Feingold (D-WI), champion of campaign finance reform and longtime opponent of the Patriot Act, has gone down in defeat against Republican businessman Ron Johnson. It marks the first time since 1986 that Republicans have won a Senate race here.

With 30% of precincts reporting, Johnson leads by 57%-42%, and has been projected as the winner by NBC News and Fox News.

Feingold won his first term with 53% of the vote in 1992, defeating incumbent two-term Republican Sen. Bob Kasten. He had started out in that race as a seemingly third-place underdog in the Democratic primary, but then won the primary with only 70% after after the two other candidates attacked He was then re-elected narrowly with 51% in 1998 against GOP Rep. Mark Neumann, then expanded that margin to 55% in 2004 against businessman Tim Michels. But the bad economy and the Republican tide this year were clearly too much to overcome.

So how did Johnson win? The biggest thing he did was campaign on not being a creature of Washington, a fresh face appealing to an atmosphere of anti-incumbency. As he explained in this ad, he’s not a lawyer:

Johnson’s other theme was to attack federal spending, strangely turning Feingold’s past fiscal conservatism and anti-pork crusades right back at the incumbent in the wake of the federal stimulus and other Obama administration programs:

Johnson stuck to his themes — sometimes to a fault. This became clear after his multiple admissions that he doesn’t actually have any detailed policy proposals, only a general conservative philosophy and his manufacturing business background. “When I interview people, I don’t expect them to come into that interview and say here are the problems and how to solve them,” he famously said.

This flap cost him the endorsement of at least one newspaper, the Green Bay Press Gazette, which endorsed Feingold for the first time ever. But ultimately it wasn’t enough to cost Johnson the race.

In addition, one thing that definitely tripped up Feingold this year was that a lot of Democratic-leaning Wisconsinites simply didn’t vote.

As a recent Public Policy Polling (D) survey found:

Wisconsin has one of the largest enthusiasm gaps of any state in the country. Although it appears Democrats will have turnout issues pretty much everywhere the problem is unusually severe in Wisconsin. Those saying they’re likely to vote this fall report having voted for Barack Obama by only 3 points in 2008. He actually won the state by 14 points.

A Marist poll found Feingold trailing by 52%-45% among likely voters. But among the wider pool of registered voters it was a much closer race, with Johnson only ahead by 44%-42% — a deficit that would have been much more feasible to overcome.

Feingold’s main legacy is the McCain-Feingold campaign finance reform law. But even here, the Washington Post noted this week, that law has been steadily worn down by the Roberts Court in a series of Supreme Court rulings, most notably the Citizens United decision that reopened the floodgates of corporate money in politics.

In addition, Feingold will be remembered as the only vote in the Senate against the Patriot Act, expanding the surveillance powers of the federal government, which was hastily passed in the wake of the 9/11 attacks in 2001. At Feingold events in 2004, he frequently told constituents that he was the only Senator to vote against the Patriot Act — because he was the only Senator to read the Patriot Act.

Late Update: Watch Feingold’s concession speech here.

Latest DC
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: