This Is Not Normal: GOP Convention Unites Around Jailing Hillary Clinton

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump stands onstage as he listens to his son Donald Trump, Jr., speak during a rally at Ohio University Eastern Campus in St. Clairsville, Ohio, Tuesday, June 28, 2016. (AP P... Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump stands onstage as he listens to his son Donald Trump, Jr., speak during a rally at Ohio University Eastern Campus in St. Clairsville, Ohio, Tuesday, June 28, 2016. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

CLEVELAND – If it were a typical Republican convention, the convention speaker might attack Hillary Clinton’s position on immigration, her record on health care, her plan to grow the economy.

In 2016, the GOP is accepting a new refrain to beat their opponent: “Lock Her Up.”

As the Republican Party struggles to heal itself after a divisive, year-long primary that culminated in the nomination of Donald Trump, Republicans are finding it easier to rail against Clinton than rally around their own nominee.

“I think it just creates a sense of camaraderie that people are on the same page. I don’t think anybody really expects that to happen,” Ben Carson told TPM.

Since the convention began on Monday, Clinton behind bars has emerged as a potent slogan. On Tuesday, Gov. Chris Christie (R-NJ) egged the audience on as they chanted from the convention floor to “lock her up.” T-shirts, buttons, bumper stickers lining the sidewalks pronounce that jail is where Clinton belongs. On Wednesday night, Florida’s Attorney General Pam Bondi joined in the fun from the stage when the chanting once again erupted among the delegates.

“I love that,” she remarked during her nationally televised speech.

But some elected officials are concerned that taking the party down a road where they have their opponent locked up is out of bounds, in bad taste and unnecessary,

It might be catchy, yet other Republican lawmakers aren’t entirely willing to take the chants to their logical conclusion.

“I have concerns that she didn’t tell the truth repeatedly. She didn’t tell the truth on Benghazi. I saw it first hand. … I don’t think she told the truth about her emails nor was she judicious about them and so look she’s gonna have to answer to the American people. There’s an election,” said Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR), the chairman of the National Republican Congressional Committee.

Pressed further if he thought Clinton should go to jail, “She hasn’t been indicted has she? In America you have a chance to make your case,” Walden said.

Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback (R) told TPM that conventions are ripe for impassioned speech but that a positive message might be a better way to go.

“People talk very aggressively at conventions. You’ll listen to the Democratic convention and you’ll hear some pretty strong things. I think the best thing for us to do is to put our best case forward of why positively to elect the Trump-Pence ticket,” Brownback said “I just always think you’re best off arguing on major policy issues as the best thing to do.”

Some elected officials weren’t all that interested in answering the question at all.

Gov. Rick Scott (R-FL) thought about answering the question of whether the “lock her up” chant was appropriate when his spokesman quickly rushed him away.

“So,” Scott began, before an aide rushed to his side.

“Hi, we’re walking somewhere what’s your name … yeah we’re heading somewhere. Sorry,” his aide said.

Many rank-and-file delegates, however, don’t see any problem with the chant. At their core, they believe Clinton has broken the rules not just in the most recent email scandal, but with Benghazi and with the Clinton Foundation. If the emails don’t lock her up, something else, they believe should.

“She deserves to be indicted. It’s not fair,” said Arkansas alternative delegate Barbara Durkee. “Is it really fair what she has done to the United States and our American men who are fighting for us in the Benghazi situation? It’s more than just those emails.”

Former Trump adviser Roger Stone, a proud veteran of the 1972 Nixon campaign, echoed the sentiment when asked if Clinton should be jailed.

“I think she should stand trial for her many, many crimes, yes,” Stone said. “There are six billion dollars missing from the time she was secretary of state. How about that for an opener? Because she has bullied and intimidated and threatened the women who are her husband’s sexual assault victims. … How do you feel about rape, you know?”

“Bill and Hillary Clinton are habitual, career criminals,” Stone said.

With the split GOP crowning its most divisive nominee in decades, there is much on which to disagree. The bloodlust to see Hillary Clinton in jail provides common ground on which to rally.

Latest DC

Notable Replies

  1. Banana Republicanism may taste sweet now but will it stay fresh through November? Jailing your political opponents is an acquired taste, kinda like caviar or Limburg cheese.

  2. The irony is that Ronald Reagan should have been locked up, and George W. Bush should have been locked up. But, as in the area of sexual indiscretions, its always OK if you’re Republican.

  3. The critical thing to note here is that the facts supporting locking Hillary up are not based in reality…they are whipped up BS based in a hatred of Hillary (and Obama, and anyone not conservative enough in general). Based on these “facts”, people are willing to skip the inalienable rights that Hillary has and throw her in jail, or execute her.

    Everyone in this nation needs to realize that is the meme the Republicans are presenting as their plan…it should be front and center that the “law and order” party is willing to ignore the law when it suits them.

  4. …since when is that new?

  5. Republicans have always applied “the ends justify the means” theory in their battles against democrats. By using this approach you can say anything to whip up the crowd ie… he was born in Kenya, isn’t a christian, “in Real America”, left them to die, everything from A to Z with a smile on your face. “Lock Her Up” won’t persuade enough voters to overlook how much Trump has in common with Sarah (I can see Russia from my house) Palin.

Continue the discussion at

36 more replies


Avatar for fgs Avatar for charliee Avatar for tomconoley Avatar for sysprog Avatar for the_lone_apple Avatar for deckbose Avatar for leftflank Avatar for humpback Avatar for trnc Avatar for labman57 Avatar for Lacuna-Synecdoche Avatar for inversion Avatar for drriddle Avatar for sherlock1 Avatar for denisj Avatar for redraleigh Avatar for dickweed Avatar for darrtown Avatar for benthere Avatar for cincypix Avatar for motownvoice Avatar for firewing2 Avatar for burdyblue Avatar for centralasiaexpat

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: