Hillary Clinton Is Noncommittal On Social Security Expansion — For Now

Photo by: Demis Maryannakis/STAR MAX/IPx 3/10/15 Hillary Clinton at the Step It Up For Gender Equality event celebrating the 20th anniversary of the fourth World Conference On Women in Beijing at Hammerstein Ballroom. (NYC)
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

WASHINGTON — Hillary Clinton is not taking a position just yet on Social Security expansion, an issue with growing support in the Democratic Party that several of her prospective presidential primary rivals have endorsed.

The Clinton campaign told TPM on Thursday, in response to a query, that the Democratic frontrunner “will have a lot to say” about the issue and emphasized her opposition to privatizing Social Security.

“Hillary has spent a lot of time these last several months looking at bold solutions for our toughest challenges and she’s now asking questions and sharing ideas directly with voters. As the campaign ramps up, she will have a lot to say about strengthening retirement security,” Jesse Ferguson, a spokesman for Clinton’s newly minted campaign, said in an emailed statement. “Hillary has a record of fighting against privatizing Social Security and opposing cuts to seniors benefits and, as she said yesterday, dealing with challenges facing older Americans is a top priority for her.”

Two other potential Democratic primary contenders — former Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley and Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders — have championed Social Security expansion, which primarily involves providing more generous benefits and paying for them by lifting the income cap on payroll taxes.

O’Malley told WMUR last month in New Hampshire that he would push to expand Social Security if elected president. He intends to reaffirm that position in a speech about the economy Thursday evening at Harvard Kennedy School. “Rather than reducing Social Security benefits or privatizing Social Security, we need to expand Social Security benefits,” O’Malley will say, according to his political team.

Sanders, a self-described democratic socialist, has long been a supporter of expanding Social Security benefits. He said Tuesday at a Capitol news conference that the next president should “absolutely” support expansion.

Clinton is crushing all of her Democratic hopefuls in the polls.

The issue, once confined to the fringes of the Democratic Party, is quickly gaining traction. A non-binding budget amendment to expand Social Security last month offered by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) and Joe Manchin (D-WV) won the votes of 42 out of 46 Democratic senators. Just two voted against it. Progressive advocates, with the blessing of Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV), are pushing Democratic 2016 candidates to embrace expansion.

Adam Green, the co-founder of the Progressive Change Campaign Committee, which has been aggressively pushing the issue, said he has discussed it “numerous times” with the Clinton campaign.

“I’m confident they are aware of what expand Social Security means, that Senator Tom Harkin from Iowa kicked off this debate in Congress, and that it’s now the near-unanimous position of Senate Democrats thanks to Elizabeth Warren and Joe Manchin,” he said in an email. “I’m hopeful this is something they choose to embrace sooner rather than later, and think they’d win major props from voters and progressives for showing leadership on this issue.”

Republicans are united against the idea — many of them prefer to trim benefits to avoid letting the Social Security trust fund dip into the red.

This article has been updated.

Latest DC

Notable Replies

  1. Sure. And she’s noncommittal about TPP. Noncommittal about the NSA, DEA, CIA, FBI hovering up private communications. Noncommittal about Wall Street owning the government. Noncommittal about making a nuclear deal with Iran. And so forth. But, oh, she wants to be a champion for “everyday Americans.”

  2. If Bernie Sanders is on the ballot, I’ll vote for him. If Elizabeth Warren is on the ballot, I’ll vote for her; but rather than waste my vote writing in the name of someone who is not running and cannot win, I’ll vote for Hillary.

  3. Other than few idiots who believe Snowden, I don’t think anybody cares about people who can’t spell whining about NSA. Poor Snowden, he spent so much time with Libertarian government haters he was sure that if he stole a million documents he’d find a smoking gun. He was wrong. I hope Snowden enjoys his extended vacation in Siberia when Puten has mined the little traitor for all the information he can get. I hope no presidential candidate wastes a moment on the non issues that Snowden and his fellow subversives hold so dear. To be sure, Libertarians will do their best to sabotage Clinton’s run and elect a Republican. Maybe Rand Paul will run. That would be funny.

    The rest of us care a great deal about Hillary Clinton’s stand on Social Security, especially after Obama talked about “raising the cap” when he was up for election, and then proposed cutting Social Security benefits, with the support of Pelosi and Hoyer, as soon as he had no further need to face the voters. I will be listening very carefully and saving video from this election, to post if Hillary tries to support Social Security to get elected, then betray it once elected.

  4. Avatar for darcy darcy says:

    You make good points but let’s give her some slack. She’ll have to take a stand as soon as she has competition for the nomination.

    I’m wondering if Hillary Fatigue is already setting in. This thread was put up yesterday and we now have 4-5 posts.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

9 more replies


Avatar for system1 Avatar for meri Avatar for trippin Avatar for arrrrrj Avatar for condew Avatar for squeakyrat Avatar for darcy Avatar for theworm Avatar for occamsrazor2 Avatar for shorebreeze

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: