Cook Report: Dems Have Lost Control Of The Debate


The newest analysis from the Cook Political Report — one of the most respected political commentators out there — finds that the Democrats have lost control of the political environment, and that current trends could point to significant Congressional losses in 2010:

These data confirm anecdotal evidence, and our own view, that the situation this summer has slipped completely out of control for President Obama and Congressional Democrats. Today, The Cook Political Report’s Congressional election model, based on individual races, is pointing toward a net Democratic loss of between six and 12 seats, but our sense, factoring in macro-political dynamics is that this is far too low.

Many veteran Congressional election watchers, including Democratic ones, report an eerie sense of déjà vu, with a consensus forming that the chances of Democratic losses going higher than 20 seats are just as good as the chances of Democratic losses going lower than 20 seats.

Cook cites some examples of national polling data, to show that the Democrats are no longer untouchable. President Obama’s approval rating is now consistently hovering just above 50%. There is also heavy disapproval of Congress, with 70% disapproval among the key independent voters in the latest Gallup poll. It should be noted that there isn’t anything in the way of race-specific data, which doesn’t really exist and wouldn’t be of much use at this early point in the cycle.

The analysis later adds: “That all of this is happening against a backdrop of an economy that appears to be rebounding and a resurgent stock market underscores how much the President’s and his party’s legislative agenda have contributed to these poor poll numbers.”

It really is interesting to consider what has happened here. Democrats have the White House, 60 Senate seats and 257 House seats — but they have managed to lose control of the debate and a sense of party cohesion.

Taking Cook’s analysis at face value, a loss of 20 seats wouldn’t be too bad. It would simply take Democrats back to where their majority was before the 2008 election. And some kind of loss was bound to happen, considering that Dems won nearly everything they could in two successive wave elections in 2006 and 2008. The only real question is whether the losses will be a minimal erosion of Democrats from the political landscape, or a larger-scale mudslide.

But the trend isn’t encouraging, either. It would take a loss of 40 seats to actually flip control of the House back to the Republicans — and 20 is closer to that than six or twelve are. A lot can happen in the next year, and any of these trends can flip around again. But this summer definitely seems to have thrown the Dems off balance.