Roberts: Precedent Validates Constitutionality Of Mandate

In Chief Justice John Roberts’ majority opinion upholding the individual mandate, he invoked two key precedents — Gonzales v. Raich and Wickard v. Filburn — that authorize sweeping federal power to regulate matters that have a substantial affect on interstate commerce.

Some excerpts:

Our precedents read that to mean that Congress may regulate “the channels of interstate commerce,” “persons or things in interstate commerce,” and “those activities that substantially affect interstate commerce.” …  The power over activities that substantially affect interstate commerce can be expansive.

Our permissive reading of these powers is explained in part by a general reticence to invalidate the acts of the Nation’s elected leaders. 

1
Show Comments