I see George “Macaca” Allen is on Fox explaining why John McCain’s gonzo antics trying to get us into a nuclear confrontation over Georgia shows why we desperately need to make him president as soon as possible. But I do notice that McCain is bragging about how he’s been repeatedly on the phone talking with the President of Georgia (as has Obama) and generally conducting his own mini-foreign policy.
Says the FT …
John McCain, the Republican presidential nominee, on Monday upstaged George W. Bush’s administration over the Georgia crisis with his strongest statement so far calling on the US and its allies to come together in “universal condemnation of Russian aggression”.
Mr McCain, who gave his first response early last Friday several hours before any official word from the Bush administration, said the US should take steps to assist Georgia and other democracies in the region that he said were threatened by Russia’s actions.
“Russia’s aggression against Georgia is both a matter of urgent moral and strategic importance to the United States,” said Mr McCain. “The implications go beyond their threat to .â.â.âa democratic Georgia. Russia is using violence against Georgia, in part, to intimidate other neighbours such as Ukraine, for choosing to associate with the west.”
Mr McCain’s statement – his third since the crisis began – stood in clear contrast on Monday to the relatively low-key response of the Bush administration and the Obama campaign. Barack Obama himself issued a statement on Saturday but remains on vacation in Hawaii. President Bush, at the Beijing Olympics on Saturday, expressed “grave concern” about Moscow’s “disproportionate response” in South Ossetia, but did not follow Mr McCain in portraying the crisis as a watershed moment for democracy in the region.
Isn’t this a bit, well … presumptuous.
Someone might want to mention to Sen. McCain that we only have one president at a time (however feeble he might be) and he shouldn’t be reaching above his station.
Was John McCain so up to speed on Georgia that his campaign had to look it up and crib the entry from Wikipedia?
Late Update: TPM Reader JO counter-snarks …
Really great title. But I’m not sure you really want to make this point. It just kills the “McCain can’t work a computer” meme.
A few weeks ago Left Blogistan was mocking McCain for his lack of computer skills. Here he is cutting and pasting, and from Wikipedia no less. I mean, he leaped over the Microsoft Encarta era completely. Give the guy some credit — at least he didn’t copy from World Book Encyclopedia.
Having found most pundits to be incorrigible morons on racial/sexual messaging, McCain decides to push a bit further …
A contrary view from TPM Reader VI …
I have to respectfully disagree with you on your post “Beware”. I never thought I would be agreeing on Cheney and McCain, but here I am, as weird as it seems to me.
First of all your comparison with Kosovo is flawed. Sure it is a “vexed” region as you say, but some areas are more vexed than others. In this case, there is really no history of ethnic strife between the breakaway region Ossetia (home of ethnic ossetians) and Georgia. Even now there is a notable absence of any ethnic based violence, as one would expect to see. Pretty much all of the fighting is between Russian military and Georgians. In fact, the only reason this is a breakaway region is because Russia invaded that part of Georgia in early 90’s and setup a puppet regime. The government that runs Ossetia almost entirely consists of former Russian regional governors, former officials of Russia’s ministries, military and FSB. So this is pretty much an artificial ‘breakaway’ situation.Secondly, how far exactly are we willing to go to avoid a conflict with an aggressive government, like Russia? Would we be willing to let Russia trample a real, legitimate democracy (one of so few in the region) and a true U.S. ally, who is not just another sketchy ‘friend of Bush’ (like Pakistan, for example)?
If Russia gets to win this one, they will surely feel encouraged to pursue their other territorial ambitions. They have ambitions toward parts of Ukraine and Moldova. They frequently express desire to protect allegedly oppressed ethnic russians in the Baltic states, as well as Ukraine and other parts of former USSR.
Russia’s foreign policy is a real threat to regional and world stability. This should not be allowed to stand.
Disagreeing is TPM Reader RC …
A few things need to be considered about possible Georgia adventures:
1) When Kosovo declared independence on Feb. 17, 2008, the United States and most European nations rushed to support it, ignoring Russia’s energetic complaints. This support was the logical outgrowth of nearly two decades of Western backing for the breakup of the former Yugoslavia. In the 1990s, the West also gave clear support to the breakaway republics of the former Soviet Union.
2) Russia has long charged, with apparently some justification, that Georgia gave covert support to the rebels in Chechnya during the 1990s.
3) From most accounts, the South Ossetian and Abkhazian people genuinely support secession from Georgia.
4) The Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline, which traverses Georgia and opened in 2005, was intended expressly as a way to export oil from Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan to the West while bypassing Russia. A growing share of Israel’s petroleum imports traverses this pipeline – surely one of the reasons why Israel has joined with the United States to train and arm Georgia’s military. Israel is also planning to link this pipeline to Israel’s own Ashelon-Eilat pipeline from the Mediterranean to the Red Sea, thus creating an oil export conduit to Asia.
5) Since the 1990s, and accelerating under the Bush administration, Georgia has avidly become an arch-loyal ally of the United States, hosting U.S. military training teams and what is reputed to be a major CIA station. Its 2,000 troops in Iraq (now hastily withdrawn) were a sign of this fealty.
All these factors should give us reason to suspect that U.S. support for Georgia, its tacit opposition to South Ossetian and Abkhazian independence, and its pious complaints about Russian conduct are deeply hypocritical. Democracy and self-determination are fine concepts, but in this case they’re mainly being used by Washington as weapons in a latter-day Great Game of oil geopolitics and lingering Cold War attitudes.
Andrew Sullivan provides some helpful color commentary on the nutballs.
TPM Reader WM responds to my post below …
There is no question in my mind that this is about OIL (as is so much else that happens in this world). There is at least TWO major pipelines in Georgia control of which would give Russia much more control over caspian sea oil.
Russia recognizes (as do the hawks in our admin – all oil people) that at least for now OIL = POWER. Russia has clearly taken over state control of its natural gas and oil resources, is earning major bank from them and is now doing exactly what we did in Iraq; using aggression to secure more. It is not a major leap to think Russia will move further against other neighboring states if this isn’t stopped now, but this alone may accomplish their goals. My recollection was the BTC pipeline’s purpose was to bypass Russia altogether. If Russia takes Georgia over or more likely institutes a regime change then they will have accomplished something detrimental to the rest of the world and will be encouraged to do it again.
I don’t agree with the hawks on going to war with Russia, but there has to be a painful consequence for Russia’s actions, especially when it becomes clear their interest is in taking oil resources over by force. Bush & Cheney being against this is the surest sign is about oil since they haven’t given a crap about Russia for the last 8 years. I also have major suspicions about how this all got starte — and given Russia’s history (as well as our own) in starting wars of agression on false pretenses — and so should you.
There is a lot I agree with in this email. And I don’t really see anything that contradicts my earlier point. First, the energy resources issue is hugely significant, perhaps even the primary issue in play here. (As I side matter, I actually think that Russia’s massive and not unsuccessful reliance on resource extraction is a long term weakness. And those who see controlling Caucasian natural resources as critical to American power in this century are shortsighted. But that’s another question for another post.) I also agree that what now appears to be an invasion of Georgia will undoubtedly cast a big shadow over the other post-Soviet successor states in the region. Nor do I have any illusions that the Russians are fair-dealing players in this matter.
The people around Putin — and many others in Russia — believe that the immediate post-Soviet leadership (mainly Yeltsin) impotently and unwisely allowed recalcitrant border regions of their former country (Czarist Russia > USSR, etc) to break away when they never should have. They may not feel the need to forcibly reabsorb these countries. But they certainly want to reassert effective hegemony over them. I’m sure a localized war that confirms that hegemony would be far from unwelcome to them.
Among many other things, what the Iraq war reminds us is the need to distinguish between critical national security interests and wish-lists that may be nice to fill if they come at little or no cost and all the grey areas in between. My concern here is that we’re getting ginned up into signing on for things we don’t fully understand or fully grasp the price of.
To paraphrase the old saw, those who learn their history from Sean Hannity are condemned to repeat it (and/or do a long list of other stupid things.)
McCain is up by a single point in the latest SurveyUSA poll of Virginia.
Late Update: New polling from Colorado today as well. It shows Obama up 4 points.
James K. Galbraith, professor of government at the University of Texas at Austin, sits in at the TPMCafe Book Club this week to discuss his new book, The Predator State: How Conservatives Abandoned the Free Market and Why Liberals Should Too.
Writes Galbraith:
The judicial coup of December 2000 that installed Bush and Cheney brought back some of Reagan’s men and his most extreme policies – tax cuts for the wealthy, big increases in military spending, aggressive deregulation. But it didn’t bring back the ideas. Instead, it became clear that Bush and Cheney had no real ideas, no larger public justification. … Under Bush and Cheney, oil and gas, drug companies and defense contractors, insurers and usurers control the government of the United States, and it does what they want. This is the predator state.
You can see the extremely bellicose statements of Vice President Cheney and Sen. McCain (soul mates on this issue) on the conflict in Georgia. And a number of Democratic-affiliated foreign policy hands are roughly on the same side of this issue, if not quite as utterly nuts and eager to get into a war with Russia as Cheney and McCain.
But let me briefly (I hope to come back to this later today) register my deep skepticism about a great deal of the coverage we’re seeing about what’s happening. We’re hearing analogies to Czechoslovakia and Kuwait (which was of course supposed itself to be a latter-day Czechoslovakia) and many other charged incidents of the past. But this strikes me as a lot of crap.
To the best of my understanding, the separatism in these ‘breakaway’ regions of Georgia is not something ginned up by Russia, though certainly they’ve exploited it in their effort to either reclaim or dominate parts of what was the Soviet Union. And the Georgians themselves triggered this crisis, however ‘disproportionate’ the Russian response may be.
This is a vexed part of the globe we’re talking about, with a host of overlapping ethnic and separatist conflicts that can make the difficulties of Kosovo and the Palestinian territories seem tractable by comparison. As the standard line goes, my point is not to justify Russian actions. And I should be clear that I have not researched the details of this conflict nearly as deeply as I would now like to. But we should be clear that there are small state actors in the region (Georgia being one of them) interested in making high stakes gambles vis a vis the Russians and they are trying to do it on our dime — that is, both literally on our dime but more importantly by trying to involve us militarily in their defense.
Meanwhile, there are players (largely, though not perfectly, overlapping with the folks who got us into Iraq) in the US who want to use this period of relative (though diminishing) Russian weakness to push American security guarantees (primarily NATO) not just to the borders of the old Soviet Union (which we’ve largely already done) but actually within the borders of the old Soviet Union (which we’ve begun to do in the Baltics). John McCain has been a supporter of inducting Georgia into NATO. And it is worth noting that had we done that we would currently be in effect in a state of war with Russia since we would be obligated to see the treat the attack on Georgia as an attack on us. Indeed, McCain is saying now we should move ahead quickly and bring them into NATO.
It’s worth asking McCain whether he thinks we should be sending American troops into Georgia because in the current circumstances the two moves are close to synonymous.
As I said, there are many complexities to this current situation. And the Russians have a crass and brutal way of expressing their pretensions to regional hegemony. But we need to think closely and carefully just whose defense we’re signing on to and whose risk-taking behavior we’re underwriting.
As I said, do you want to go to war with Russia over Georgia? John McCain, and unfortunately quite a few others, seem to be saying yes, they do. The hawks will say that the example set in Georgia will foreshadow that to be applied in Eastern Europe. But that’s a highly, highly questionable leap. We’re in the midst of being led very far astray.
Scientsts Continue To Question Anthrax Investigation And Case Against Bruce Ivins