This is the sort of mind-numbingly banal observation that passes for political analysis these days. Tut-tutting over the timing of Barack Obama’s family vacation, Cokie Roberts yesterday on ABC’s This Week added that Hawaii was not an appropriate destination: too foreign and too exotic. “I know Hawaii is a state, but …” Roberts declared, while insisting Obama vacation in some place like Myrtle Beach, S.C.:
She picked the theme up again this morning in her regular Morning Edition appearance on NPR:
RENEE MONTAGNE: Now Obama is spending the week on vacation in Hawaii, he’s taking a vacation, he says, because it’s good for his family, but is it a good point in the presidential campaign?
COKIE ROBERTS: It’s a little rough to be doing it at this point, although I think he’s feeling somewhat secure, but Hawaii is also a somewhat odd place to be doing it. I know that he is from Hawaii, he grew up there, his grandmother lives there, but he has made such a point about how he is from Kansas, you know, the boy from Kansas and Kenya, and it makes him seem a little bit more exotic than perhaps he would want to come across as at this stage in the presidential campaign.
I drove all the way across Kansas and back last week, and Cokie is right: It’s anything but exotic. But Hawaii as too foreign? Seriously?
It got us to thinking. What is the most white-bread place for a black presidential candidate to vacation, since that’s apparently the new standard? Surely we can do better than Myrtle Beach. The best we’ve come up with so far is Branson, Missouri — so long as he avoids the Shoji Tabuchi Theatre, which is way too exotic.
Late Update: TPM Reader JH suggests:
1) The Wisconsin Dells
2) Wall Drug, South Dakota
3) Wildwood on the Jersey shore.All of this must be done with Barack driving the family in a station wagon, preferably wood paneled. Just don’t pull a Romney and put the dog on top …
TPM Reader DW continues the Mitt theme:
I nominate Kennebunkport for a white-bread vacation spot. From Wikipedia: The racial makeup of the town was 98.49% White, 0.22% Black or African American …
Failing that, go wherever it is Mitt Romney vacations, that’s gotta be white
Later Update: TPM Reader CG says don’t forget Dollywood.
Latest Update: Some intra-reader squabbling over what constitutes “white bread.” From TPM Reader M:
Wildwood, N.J., may be white — but it sure as hell ain’t white bread!
That’s like saying ‘The Sopranos’ is just too darn WASPy. Too Edith Wharton.
Wildwood was made legendary by working-class Italian-Americans from South Philly and (to an only slighter extent) the swampier regions of the Garden State. Those folks still come out in droves, but now you get working-class Russians and even African-Americans too. (Though, okay, in no great numbers.) It’s the kind of place where women wear make-up on the beach and the boardwalk is fragrant with the smell of Zeppolli [look it up] from all the stands. (Zeppolli — not white bread!)
As a fan of gross cultural ignorance I stand in awe of you and JH.
Man, are you two clueless!
Obama supporter Bill Richardson floats a new “Washington celebrity” line against McCain, McCain campaign manager Rick Davis attempts to defend his own lobbying record, and some quintessential old Washington pundit flummery. All in today’s Sunday Show Roundup …
High-res version at Veracifier.com.
If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then the new Obama ad targeting McCain as a celebrity suggests McCain’s Paris/Britney line of attack may have been seen within the Obama camp as successful. That and the day’s other political news in the TPM Election Central Morning Roundup.
Late Update: A longtime reader disagrees that the new Obama ad is a response to McCain’s Paris/Britney ad:
Nope. It means that they know that they can get the national press corps (especially the campaign press corps) to write about “McCain = corrupt establishment, not really a maverick” as long as they throw in the word “celebrity” so it looks like a response to McCain’s ad.
Which it is not.
As has already been pointed out by far worthier observers than I, making the election about Obama is the only way Obama loses. If it’s about Bush? Obama wins. If it’s Obama vs McCain? Obama wins. If it’s about some more vague “are you better off than you were four years ago?” Obama wins. Ah, but what if it’s a referendum about Obama? Can Team McCain/GOP build enough doubts and worries about Obama? You bet. I think that’s where all of those McCain ads want to go.
Halperin gives you the run-down of election insight in some sort of dingbat aphorisms …
-Obama’s running mate: will seem safe, but will be risky.
-McCain’s running mate: will seem risky, but will be safe.
-Obama’s pick timing: sooner than you think.
-McCain’s pick timing: later than you think.
It gets worse from there. Sort of like The Note, only without the substance …
A note from TPM Reader JB, who’s a Republican, albeit of a slightly lapsed sort …
I’ve noticed something about both your recent, frequent campaign posts and most of what the Obama campaign itself has had to say recently. Both talk about Sen. McCain — sometimes mentioning Sen. Obama as well, sometimes not — and neither mentions President Bush very much at all.
Now, of course as a blogger you can write whatever you feel like — though I have to say your bitter comment a couple of days ago about McCain having married into his money sounded pretty strange coming from a guy who supported John Kerry four years ago and who had until fairly recently many nice things to say about Hillary Clinton. As far as Obama’s people are concerned, though, doesn’t it seem to you that they are doing things the hard way?
After all, it is President Bush whose approval ratings are in the mid-20s, not McCain’s. Obama is trying to promote himself as the candidate of change, but from what? Obviously, from Bush and Bush’s administration. The biggest question voters have about Obama is, what kind of President would this guy be? This isn’t just about what he would do (or try to do) but about how he would operate and the kinds of things that are important to him. He can’t answer that question very well by contrasting himself to McCain — not because McCain is a phony maverick or gives lousy prepared speeches, but simply because McCain has never been President.Bush has, and so far it seems to me that Obama’s campaign has rather taken for granted Bush’s unpopularity and its usefulness in helping Obama overcome voters’ uncertainty toward his candidacy. Moreover, Obama’s rote linkages of McCain to “Bush’s failed policies” are delivered in a way that demands nothing of McCain. Specifically, they don’t put McCain in the position of having to either defend Bush or agree with Obama’s criticism: the former identifying him further with the unpopular President, the latter antagonizing Bush’s admirers in the GOP base, most of whom don’t like McCain to begin with. Finally, Bush will never be provoked into answering attacks from Obama if all Obama’s attacks are aimed at McCain, and provoking Bush should be an Obama campaign objective.
I wouldn’t call this campaign advice for Obama’s camp, not really. This is because I don’t know exactly what they are trying to accomplish (it is, of course, possible that with so much time left until the election they are merely pacing themselves). It looks as if his people are running a fairly conventional “base-plus” campaign that will emphasize maximizing turnout among likely Democratic voters and doing just enough otherwise to make it across the finish line first. I think they can do this for Obama doing what they are doing now — again, simply because the dead weight of Bush’s unpopularity is not something any Republican candidate this year could shed. This strategy worked for Nixon in 1968, and should work for Obama this year.
I can’t help thinking, though, that such a strategy doesn’t aim very high. In no meaningful sense is the Republican Party today John McCain’s party. It is George Bush’s party. Its elected officials and political consultants (including some on McCain’s campaign payroll) owe their primary loyalties to Bush, not McCain; its platform this year will be written mostly by people who would nominate Bush for a third term if they could. A candidate promising a clean break from Bush can quote chapter and verse from too many policies and people to list here, better defining himself while making it difficult for McCain to respond as his own man (and incidentally presenting the same difficulty for Republican candidates for the House and Senate).
I suppose it might be possible to so “expose” a candidate far more popular personally than either the incumbent President of that candidate’s party or the party itself that the candidate would become unpopular. That seems to be what Obama and his supporters are trying to do at the moment — as I suggest above, really doing things the hard way.
The Obama campaign posts a Web video firing back on the McCain campaign’s ad saying Obama will raise taxes on the middle class: “In summary, this ad is a lie.” That and other political news in today’s Election Central Sunday Roundup.
Hmmmm. Looks like someone got to hop over the embargo.
Anyway, since Mike Allen, presumably, was already given the go-ahead to spill the beans, I can tell you that I’ve read the piece and the most salient information is confirmation that Mark Penn was actively pushing for the kind of xenophobic campaign against Obama that many of us argued he was during the campaign.
BMW Direct Mailer For Georgia Republican Lands On Iowa Doorstep of Weekly Standard Reader
The Daily Muck