In a sense the revelations of Mark Penn’s ‘xenophobia’ memos is old news, a post-mortem on a campaign that was all-consuming three months ago and now part of history. But seeing the memos beyond the message is instructive, highly instructive for another reason.
During the campaign there was a lot of clucking about whether the campaign’s message just accidentally stumbled on to charged words and associations. And now we can see what was obvious at the time — that the people in charge of the message weren’t sloppy and unlucky but rather what you would expect, professionals following a detailed plan.
Now how about Sen. McCain? You see his ads lining Obama up with Paris Hilton and Britney Spears, a new ad with the tagline “hot chicks dig Obama” (yes, those are the actual words in McCain’s ad) and countless montages of Obama as pop music sensation. How do you think McCain’s memos read?
Only the deeply naive or the deliberately oblivious — which regrettably includes the greater number of the people covering the campaign — don’t know the answer to that question.
In Newsweek, John Barry makes the argument for the truly insane approach to the Georgian crisis — first, the simpleton’s historical analogies, then the totally loopy prescription — issue a guarantee of Georgia’s independence and sovereignty and back it up by sending the 82nd Airborne (after all they’re done in Iraq, so they’re available) into the country as a tripwire.
Brilliant.
(Do whatever you can to make sure John McCain is not elected president. Too many opportunities for crazy mischief to let him get his hands on the military and the bomb.)
Andrew Sullivan is right about this. This is something that transcends whatever immediate campaign tactics or even strategy Barack Obama may be pursuing. It goes beyond him. It goes beyond the Democrats. The whole country needs to wake up.
The foreign policy of the last seven-plus years has been an unmitigated disaster for the United States by virtually every measure. And John McCain would ramp up all the worst traits of the current administration. His instincts are always toward force and the people advising him come squarely from the Cheney wing of the current administration. In comparison to Bush he’s not just more of the same. There’s every reason to believe he’d be much worse.
The current situation in Georgia and his response should make clear to everyone how dangerous a president John McCain would be.
Josh Green’s much-anticipated article in The Atlantic about the struggles in Hillaryland has just gone live online, complete with a treasure trove of internal Hillary campaign memos that paint a vivid portrait of the campaign’s internal battles over strategy.
The memos show even more clearly than before that chief Hillary strategist Mark Penn advocated a brutally negative and xenophobic campaign against Obama, and they reveal a host of internal tensions on other matters.
Fred Kaplan on Georgia …
Regardless of what happens next, it is worth asking what the Bush people were thinking when they egged on Mikheil Saakashvili, Georgia’s young, Western-educated president, to apply for NATO membership, send 2,000 of his troops to Iraq as a full-fledged U.S. ally, and receive tactical training and weapons from our military. Did they really think Putin would sit by and see another border state (and former province of the Russian empire) slip away to the West? If they thought that Putin might not, what did they plan to do about it, and how firmly did they warn Saakashvili not to get too brash or provoke an outburst?
It’s heartbreaking, but even more infuriating, to read so many Georgians quoted in the New York Times–officials, soldiers, and citizens–wondering when the United States is coming to their rescue. It’s infuriating because it’s clear that Bush did everything to encourage them to believe that he would. When Bush (properly) pushed for Kosovo’s independence from Serbia, Putin warned that he would do the same for pro-Russian secessionists elsewhere, by which he could only have meant Georgia’s separatist regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Putin had taken drastic steps in earlier disputes over those regions–for instance, embargoing all trade with Georgia–with an implicit threat that he could inflict far greater punishment. Yet Bush continued to entice Saakashvili with weapons, training, and talk of entry into NATO. Of course the Georgians believed that if they got into a firefight with Russia, the Americans would bail them out.
Scott Horton has some more sage thoughts.
Anatol Lieven of DC’s New America Foundation has a very different take on the Georgia crisis than you’re likely to see in the US press. It appears in the Times of London.
I don’t sign on or not sign on to the entirety of his take. I need to learn more. But it is at least a needed counterbalance to a lot of the rah-rah nonsense I’m seeing in a lot of coverage I’m seeing. Take a look.
Cowdery Pleads Not Guilty
House Judiciary To Probe Allegations White House Ordered Forged Letter Linking Saddam-Al Qaeda
DHS Flouts Experts’ Evaluations, Awards Mississippi with Spot on Shortlist
Lawmakers Still Seeking Details On FBI’s Illegal Records Demands