WASHINGTON (AP) — A U.S. aerial gunship attack on a hospital in Afghanistan that killed 42 people occurred because of human errors, process mistakes and equipment failures, and none of the aircrew knew they were striking a trauma center, a top U.S. general said Friday.
“This was an extreme situation” complicated by combat fatigue among U.S. special operations forces, Gen. Joseph Votel told a Pentagon news conference. Votel headed U.S. Special Operations Command at the time of the tragic attack last fall. In March he took over U.S. Central Command, which oversees military operations in Afghanistan.
Votel said investigators concluded that certain personnel failed to comply with the rules of engagement and the law of armed conflict. However, they also determined that these failures did not amount to a war crime, he said.
“The label ‘war crimes’ is typically reserved for intentional acts — intentional targeting (of) civilians or intentionally targeting protected objects or locations,” Votel said. “Again, the investigation found that the incident resulted from a combination of unintentional human errors, process errors and equipment failures, and that none of the personnel knew they were striking a hospital.”
Votel expressed “deepest condolences” to those injured and to the families of those killed.
No criminal charges have been leveled against U.S. military personnel for mistakes that resulted in the Oct. 3, 2015, attack on the civilian hospital in Afghanistan operated by the medical charity Doctors Without Borders. The group has called the attack a war crime and demanded an independent investigation.
Votel said that the trauma center was on a U.S. military no-strike list but that the gunship crew didn’t have access to the list because it launched its mission on short notice and as a result did not have the data loaded into its onboard systems. He said the military has sought to avoid similar mistakes in the future by requiring that such data be pre-loaded into aircraft.
Central Command released a redacted version of the full investigation report on Friday, including details about what exactly led a U.S. Air Force special operations AC-130 gunship to bomb the hospital and how those mistakes were made.
“The investigation determined that all members of both the ground force and the AC-130 air crew were unaware that the aircraft was firing on a medical facility throughout the engagement,” Votel said. “The investigation ultimately concluded that this tragic incident was caused by a combination of human errors, compounded by process and equipment failures.”
Votel said 16 military members, including officers as well as enlisted, have been disciplined. He said none of their names will be released to protect the privacy of the individuals and in some cases because they are still assigned to sensitive or overseas positions.
According to one senior U.S. official, a two-star general was among about 16 disciplined. A number of those punished are U.S. special operations forces.
No one was sent to court-martial, officials said. However, in many cases a nonjudicial punishment, such as a letter of reprimand or suspension, can effectively end a military career. The official were not authorized to discuss the case by name and requested anonymity.
The U.S. airstrike in the northern city of Kunduz last October was carried out by one of the most lethal aircraft in the U.S. arsenal. Doctors Without Borders has called the attack “relentless and brutal.”
The Associated Press reported in March that more than a dozen U.S. military personnel had been disciplined in connection with the bombing, and that the punishments were all largely administrative.
The crew of the AC-130, which is armed with side-firing cannons and guns, had been dispatched to hit a Taliban command center in a building 450 yards from the hospital, the U.S. military said in November. Hampered by problems with their targeting sensors, the crew relied on a physical description that led them to begin firing at the hospital even though they saw no hostile activity there.
Officials have said the attack was caused by human error, and that many chances to prevent the attack on the wrong target were missed.
A separate U.S. report on the incident, obtained last fall by the AP, said the AC-130 aircraft fired 211 shells at the hospitalcompound over 29 minutes before commanders realized the mistake and ordered a halt. Doctors Without Borders officials contacted coalition military personnel during the attack to say the hospital was “being ‘bombed’ from the air,” and the word finally was relayed to the AC-130 crew, the report said.
The attack came as U.S. military advisers were helping Afghan forces retake Kunduz, which had fallen to the Taliban on Sept. 28. It was the first major city to fall since the Taliban were expelled from Kabul in 2001.
Afghan officials claimed the hospital had been overrun by the Taliban, but no evidence of that has surfaced. The hospital was destroyed and Doctors Without Borders, also known by its French acronym, MSF, ceased operations in Kunduz.
Copyright 2016 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
And then, a few months later, Saudi Arabia bombed 2 Doctors Without Borders hospitals in Yemen using bombs Obama sold them. Reported here and elsewhere, bomb fragments had “Made in the USA” on them. Laughable apology, then repeated Crimes Against Humanity only a few months later again. That’s Obama, folks, serial lying coward, the worst. And who is bombing the hospitals in Syria now? Guess who. And who is creating these false flag War Crimes and then blaming Syria and Russia? Guess who, folks. Right, you got it.
So, every systemic evil within our massive national foreign military machine, developed by millions of Americans working over many decades, is down to, Thanks, Obama.
You really are an idiot.
How can you blame this on Obama. I’m sure you have no knowledge of what happened in Kunduz that day other than media crap. How is Obama to blame?
If My Lai was fine, an hospital with 47 deaths should be OK as well.
Ohhh boy…here it comes!!! Come on TPM’ers…get your goody two shoes on.
MSF went into a combat zone. On their own volition. They were operating in a “hot zone”…a place where hostilities are inevitable. That was very brave and noble of them but it was risky as hell too.
The USA is not involved in land operations in Afghanistan other than as consultants. It supports the Afghan Army. Afghan soldiers in Kinduz reported receiving small arms fire from a block of buildings to their American helpers. Those Americans opted for an AC 130 attack rather than a ground troops one. The AS 130 is a cargo aircraft equipped with 105 mm howitzers that are stabilized for direct fire and it has mini guns or electro-driven machine guns capable of thousands of rounds a minute. The planes engage by direct fire ( they are looking at their targets ) and acquire their targets by grid called into the FDC from the ground. They use the “nature of target” in the fire mission request to determine the weapon system they will use. For troops within a building it would be the 105’s.
Target named by Afghan troops. Referred to Tac Air by American Infantry serving in advisory capacity. Air Force requests appropriate weapon system, in this case a AC 130 and moves on target. It was a hospital WITHOUT an H on the top. The hospital was a long standing one and know to ground forces as such. The crew in the AC 130 were Air Force and had no idea what it was.
The Afghan forces claimed the building was used by Taliban as a rendezvous or staging area. There appears to be no truth to that but that’s what they believed. So, despite it being a hospital, they had no hesitation calling it in as a location of hostiles. And they did. That location was referred by US Forces that had no idea was was a hospital. And it was struck.
MSF Claimed the US Forces knew it was a hospital an attacked it as such. That was not true. They claimed the US changed its story. That was not true. They claimed there was adequate warning but it went unheeded. That was not true. Its a God damn fucking combat zone. Where the fuck do you think phrases like FUBAR, SNAFU and Catch 22 came from? Combat Zones. It is ridiculously unreasonable to think folks are going to have the demeanor of a Sunday Brunch when they’re getting their kidneys blown out of their backs. When you are dirty, exhausted and in mental collapse. So, yes, the hospital was “on record” as such but in that Combat Zone no one had the fucking records or was in any shape to read or comprehend them. MSF knew damn well what they were getting into. A mess like the one I described.
The USA did NOT deliberately kill folks in a hospital. Fuck MSF ( va te faire foutre MSF ) for saying so. The folks that got punished did so for failures that should not have been made even under the circumstances that existed that day in Kinduz. But no one deserved a firing squad nor does any American have to take orders to self loath from a fucking bunch of French doctors. The Americans and the French are there for the same reasons: to help.