They've got muck; we've got rakes. TPM Muckraker

Wisconsin Lawmakers Who Cheered Impact Of Voter ID Law Revealed In Court

AP Photo / Morry Gash

According to Allbaugh's testimony Monday, Grothman said at the 2011 meeting, "'What I'm concerned about here is winning and that's what really matters here. ... We better get this done quickly while we have the opportunity."

Lazich, meanwhile, "got up out of her chair and hit her fist or her finger on the table," Allbaugh recounted, and said, "'Hey, we've got to think about what this would mean for the neighborhoods around Milwaukee and the college campuses.'" Milwaukee is a minority-majority city.

Allbaugh also identified a handful of Republicans who were visibly uncomfortable -- "ashen-faced" in Allbaugh's account -- over the bill. His boss at the time, then-Sen. Dale Schultz, had already left the meeting due to his objections to the legislation. Schultz has resisted confirming or denying Allbaugh's account of the meeting but has indicated he believed Allbaugh to be trustworthy.

When Allbuagh first made the claim that Grothman was among those cheering the bill, the congressman told the Journal Sentinel that Allbaugh's "memory is faulty or he's outright lying."

Allbaugh also said in his testimony Monday that Grothman had contacted Allbaugh after he made the initial claims to tell him the ex-staffer was not remembering things correctly.

"Here’s the thing, I fundamentally believe that Democrats cheat, and I don’t believe our side does, and that’s why we need this bill," Grothman told Allbaugh, according to Allbaugh's account as reported by

The state Attorney General's office, which is defending the law, dismissed the testimony as "hearsay" and said it should not be relevant to the case, according to the Wisconsin State Journal.

“These are very serious claims and they require very concrete proof,” Assistant Attorney General Clay Kawski told Judge James D. Peterson.

About The Author


Tierney Sneed is a reporter for Talking Points Memo. She previously worked for U.S. News and World Report. She grew up in Florida and attended Georgetown University.