Republican presidential frontrunner Donald Trump is so determined to prove that American Muslims celebrated the 9/11 attacks that he used an MTV clip debunking his claim as supporting evidence.
Trump on Tuesday morning posted a clip from a 2001 MTV News report in which Curtis Sliwa, the radio host and founder of the Guardian Angels, described people “cheering” at the news that the Twin Towers had been toppled:
Curtis Sliwa – doing tv commentary on 9/13/2001. Good job Curtis. Please send your apologies to @realDonaldTrump. pic.twitter.com/g07VZmNmAW
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) December 1, 2015
But that 11-second clip cut out key information.
MTV did interview New Jersey residents who claimed to have seen such incidents in the immediate aftermath of the attacks, including a young Paterson resident named Emily Acevedo. Acevedo said at the time that she witnessed a group of teenagers shouting “burn America.”
The MTV report was recently cited by conservative blogger Debbie Schlussel as proof that Trump was correct about the cheering, prompting the network to release a repackaged video titled “Trump Is Wrong About People ‘Cheering’ 9/11 In New Jersey—Here’s The Evidence.” The original footage is accompanied by a follow-up interview with Acevedo, who now denies that the kids she saw were saying “burn America.” Instead, Acevedo said they were just behaving like teenagers would “on any other summer night.”
The repackaged MTV report appears to be the video from which Trump grabbed the clip he said supported his claim. Sliwa called Trump out for it on Twitter, pointing out that the footage was edited:
Thanks @realDonaldTrump for the trip down memory lane. I was saying there were a handful of people. Clip is edited. https://t.co/PnqhCv8zvV
— Curtis Sliwa (@CurtisSliwa) December 1, 2015
Last week, Sliwa wrote on his Facebook page that Trump incorrectly implied that video of groups of people in the Middle East cheering the attacks actually took place in the U.S. Sliwa wrote that the video actually came from “the West Bank of Palestine, not the East Bank of the Hudson River!”
Though footage of a small gathering of Palestinians celebrating in the West Bank was captured by Reuters journalists, no such video of comparable incidents occurring in the United States exists. As TPM previously reported, a smatter of contemporaneous news reports mentioned rumors of New Jersey residents celebrating the attacks but none of them were substantiated.
Watch the full re-released MTV report below:
Obviously Black Lives Matter representatives are pressuring Sliwa and MTV to change their stories.
TPM says Oops! Trump won’t.
So the best evidence that Trump and other haters have is this one woman who now contradicts the unsubstantiated claims she made 14 years ago. And even then she said it was around a dozen kids.
Trump: See–you’re wrong about criticizing me for saying something that many, many people agree did not happen in the way that you said I was wrong in denying, as most people–really smart people, thousands of them-- all agree was not that way at all. Got it? I win again!
Of course there were some Muslims cheering 911. I am sure some Christians are cheering the recent terrorist attacks in Colorado. In both cases it is appropriate to ask religious leaders to step in and remind the flock what it is to be moral. In the case of 911, most Muslim leaders came out with a visceral, negative reaction very quickly.
Donald is not trying to address the very real issue of extremist Islam. He is trying to anger people. Rational people know their opponents sometimes celebrate unseemly things. Rational people don’t use that to make crazy people angry.