Maddow Fillets Bill O’Reilly’s Tale Of Witnessing JFK Figure’s Suicide (VIDEO)

Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

If you come at “the king of cable news,” you best not miss.

After calling Fox News host Bill O’Reilly “the king” of the business, MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow went for the jugular on Wednesday night, mercilessly ridiculing O’Reilly for reportedly exaggerating stories throughout his career.

The attack on the Fox host’s credibility started with a Feb. 9 article in the Nation magazine that questioned O’Reilly’s reporting on the civil war in El Salvador. Soon after, a report by Mother Jones cast doubt on his claims to have been in a “war-zone” in Argentina, and kicked off a wave of fact-checking.

On Wednesday night, Maddow ran through other things that have come to light, such as the host’s tendency to say he has “seen,” say, people shot in the head, only to later clarify that he merely saw pictures of violence.

Then, Maddow leaned in.

“What [O’Reilly and Fox] haven’t touched at all thus far is one where there appears to be no plausible, innocent explanation for what Mr. O’Reilly said,” she said.

She ran a clip of O’Reilly on “Fox & Friends” repeating a story he has told in multiple books: That in 1977, he was on the scene in Florida at the suicide of George de Mohrenschildt, a friend of President John F. Kennedy’s assassin.

Then, Maddow played audio tapes released by CNN last week, of phone calls made by O’Reilly from 1977 in which he said he was “coming down” “to Florida” after the suicide.

“Mr. O’Reilly does not seem to have been standing on the porch listening to the gun shot ring out as the guy killed himself,” Maddow said.

“I mean, not unless that guy’s porch was long enough to extend from that house in Florida all the way into Texas where Bill O’Reilly was working as a Dallas reporter,” she added.

Maddow noted that she had reached out to Fox News about the stories, but was given an interesting response: Information on Bill O’Reilly’s “great” ratings.

Maddow burst out laughing.

“Your ratings are great! I’ve seen your ratings shoot my ratings right in the head,” Maddow said. “Well, I’ve seen pictures of that, I should say.”

Watch the video, courtesy of Media Matters:

Latest Livewire
41
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. This is what Rachel does best, kind of investigative reporting but a quick hit, and if Ailes ignores O’Reilly’s outright lies, we’ll know once again the fix is again.

  2. Avatar for dweb dweb says:

    There is clearly NOTHING bill O’ could do that would cause Fox to dump him:

    Not costing them millions to settle a sexual harassment suit
    Not having him repeatedly lie about being on the scene and in the center of the action at major news events.
    Not claiming to have won a Peabody/Polk/Polk award to a show I left two years earlier.

    But clearly there is ONE thing that would see him dumped…

    If his ratings tanked.

    And for Bill’s audience, none of the above stuff matters. To them it is all just part of the usual smear attempts by the liberal media and it plays right into his narrative.

    Fox and Bill will ride this one out…

    Count on it.

  3. I missed her show last night which is a rare occasion for me but I i will definitely go online to watch this,

    I love Rachel Maddow

  4. You’re right. To Fox if’s all about the ratings and his loyalist would never believe it, They will blame the liberal media for trying to smear him. He’s got a win win situation

  5. “Suicide…He’s dead?”

    Mind like a tin foil trap…

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

35 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for rook429 Avatar for ajm Avatar for markslp Avatar for richardinjax Avatar for jw1 Avatar for littlegirlblue Avatar for mattinpa Avatar for humpback Avatar for chammy Avatar for dweb Avatar for vonq Avatar for arrrrrj Avatar for rudesan Avatar for inlabsitrust Avatar for mantan Avatar for rev Avatar for johnbarleycorn Avatar for 538liberal Avatar for serendipitoussomnambulist Avatar for ronbyers Avatar for pine Avatar for artmofo Avatar for henk

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: