On the call, Gorka attempts to get Smith to agree to meet at the White House to discuss Smith's concerns about his background, growing increasingly frustrated as the analyst returns to his criticisms of the White House aide. Both men, who note they've never met before, get heated as the conversation drags on and cast doubt on each other's bona fides in the field.
"I would submit to you that a majority of terrorism experts who have experience working with policy makers, which you do not until now, would agree that you are not an expert of level sufficient to be working in the White House with the President's inner circle," Smith says in one representative exchange.
"But that's one man's opinion," Gorka objects. "A man who has a 2-year-old TV clip pinned to his Twitter feed and having to point out that he had an op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal as your header. I mean that's your qualifications?"
According to Business Insider, which first reported on the phone call, Smith said Gorka called him at home Tuesday night "berating him" about his critical tweets. Smith has taken to hashtagging posts about Gorka with #FakeTerrorismExpert:
— Michael S. Smith II (@MichaelSSmithII) February 21, 2017
— Michael S. Smith II (@MichaelSSmithII) February 18, 2017
Smith told Newsweek that he started recording the call with Gorka only after he allegedly threatened legal action. In the audio of the call, Smith repeatedly refers to a threat of a lawsuit without pushback from Gorka on that point.
Gorka didn't respond to Newsweek's request for comment, and an emailed request for comment from TPM was not immediately returned Thursday. He took issue with Smith's version of events in an email to Business Insider, however, while acknowledging that he did mention bringing Smith to the attention of White House lawyers during the conversation.
"Mr. Smith has been sending disparaging emails to [US government] officials about me and my work and I indicated that I may have to consult with legal staff at the [White House] about what he is doing," Gorka told the news site. "However I ended the discussion by inviting him to meet at the [Eisenhower Executive Office Building] for a coffee to discuss why exactly he feels the need to constantly be tweeting about me."
Alas, that coffee summit was not to be:
— Michael S. Smith II (@MichaelSSmithII) February 23, 2017
Listen to the full audio of the call over at Newsweek.