Judge Denies Request From FL School Shooter Attys To Step Aside From Case

Broward Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer listens to arguments in the Nikolas Cruz status hearing on Monday, Feb. 19, 2018. Cruz faces 17 charges of premeditated murder in the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. (Mike Stocker/Sun Sentinel/TNS)
Broward Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer listens to arguments in the Nikolas Cruz status hearing on Monday, Feb. 19, 2018. Cruz faces 17 charges of premeditated murder in the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas ... Broward Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer listens to arguments in the Nikolas Cruz status hearing on Monday, Feb. 19, 2018. Cruz faces 17 charges of premeditated murder in the mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla. (Mike Stocker/Sun Sentinel/TNS via Getty Images) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

PARKLAND, Fla. (AP) — A judge has refused to step aside from the case of Florida school shooting suspect Nikolas Cruz as requested by his lawyers.

Court records show that Broward County Circuit Judge Elizabeth Scherer denied the request Monday.

Cruz’s lawyers claimed Scherer has made rulings and comments that indicate favoritism for prosecutors. They say in court papers that Cruz can’t get a fair trial, but Scherer disagreed.

Cruz, who’s 19, is charged with 17 counts of murder in the Valentine’s Day shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida.

Meanwhile, a Tuesday morning hearing in the criminal case against the suspect accused in the Florida high school shooting was canceled after lawyers reached an agreement for prosecutors to get hair samples, fingerprints, DNA and photographs of Cruz.

Cruz, who has been charged with 17 counts of murder, was not expected to appear in court because he waived his right to attend the hearing. He is being held without bail at the Broward County Jail.

As the case moves through the courts, it has fueled a debate over gun control in the halls of the Florida Capitol in Tallahassee, hours from where the shooting took place at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland.

On Monday, a state Senate committee approved a bill Monday to raise the age for buying a gun from 18 to 21 and imposing a three-day waiting period for all gun purchases. The bill would also allow teachers to carry guns in schools if their school district approves and the teachers undergo law enforcement training and are deputized by the local sheriff’s office.

About 300 gun safety advocates packed the room and dozens pleaded with senators to include an assault weapons ban in the bill. That idea was rejected on a 7-6 vote.

A similar House bill was going to be considered by a committee Tuesday.

Students are scheduled to return to school Wednesday, for the first time since the Feb. 14 shooting.

Meanwhile, Broward Schools Superintendent Robert Runcie told the Sun Sentinel that the district’s hands were tied by federal law after Cruz turned 18 and refused to let the school system continue providing him with crucial mental health and other services.

“You can’t make someone do something when the law says they have the right to make that determination,” Runcie told the newspaper.

Cruz was transferred to a school with programs for emotionally and disabled students when he was in eighth grade but wanted to be mainstreamed back into his home school, Runcie said.

“He often perseverates on the idea that his current school is for students that are ‘not smart’ and that he can now handle being in ‘regular’ school,” according to a Broward school system report from June 2015, the end of his ninth-grade year.

Starting in January 2016, Cruz was allowed to spend half his day at the alternative school and half at Stoneman Douglas to ease him into the less-structured environment.

In August 2016, he started back to Stoneman Douglas, but “the situation had deteriorated” by November, Runcie said. That’s when Cruz, who had turned 18 in September 2016, refused the mental health services offered by the school. Runcie said Cruz had the support of his mother.

He remained at the school until February 2017, when school officials finally decided to remove him after unspecified behavior issues. He was told his only option was an alternative school.

Runcie said he would like to see the aged raised to 21 for students to be allowed to refuse such services.

“The Legislature has just proposed raising the legal age by which you could purchase firearms to 21. Maybe 21 should also be the age they can refuse services,” he told the newspaper.

In Tallahassee, the Florida House is expected to subpoena records from Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel and several agencies that interacted with Cruz. Florida Gov. Rick Scott’s office has asked the Florida Department of Law Enforcement to investigate the police response, and the agency confirmed it would begin the probe immediately.

Also Monday, the attorney for the sheriff’s deputy assigned to guard the high school said that his client never entered the building to confront the suspect because he believed the gunfire was coming from outside.

Scot Peterson has been called a coward and worse for failing to stop the massacre. The criticism intensified as President Donald Trump blasted the deputy and other officers who were there, saying they “weren’t exactly Medal of Honor winners.”

Peterson’s attorney issued his first public statement about the attack, saying it was “patently untrue” that the deputy failed to meet sheriff’s department standards or acted with cowardice at the scene of the Feb. 14 assault. He resigned after Broward County Sheriff Scott Israel said he felt sick to his stomach over his deputy’s failure to intervene.

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for tsp tsp says:

    Message to the NRA: We will not let you become the law.

  2. Judge Eyelash is ready for her close-up.

  3. Avatar for rptwiz rptwiz says:

    On the FL legislation part of the article, I’m so sick of hearing about half-measures in a vain attempt to slam the barn door after the cows are already out. “What could we have done to stop this last shooting from happening again?” Let’s raise the age limit or some other such nonsense.

    The only way to stop mass gun murders is to make guns so much harder to get and to hold. Regulate the living crap out of them and let the public bask in the freedom from fear of a gun massacre. Problem solved. Instead, stupid extreme ideas in the other direction always get a full airing, like arming teachers or more security or more mental health commitments which just discard the person to get them out of sight.

    I’d say that anyone who WANTS an assault rifle (except to keep at a registered and regulated gun range) is mentally ill and should be allowed to have one. I’d say anyone who wants a handgun ‘for protection’ is stupid and their judgment can’t be trusted to have one. Somehow, the most of the rest of the civilized world has realized this and gotten control of guns.

  4. If only Donnie had opened his Trump Brand Mental Institutions in time…

    Who better to run them than a stable genius?

  5. The legal rationale is that when you are so totally fucked, it doesn’t matter who the judge is.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

12 more replies


Avatar for system1 Avatar for paulw Avatar for xpurg8d Avatar for epicurus Avatar for daveyjones64 Avatar for sparrowhawk Avatar for midnight_rambler Avatar for gr Avatar for ottnott Avatar for tsp Avatar for matthew_tanner Avatar for firewing2 Avatar for marcc1213 Avatar for rptwiz Avatar for maximus Avatar for the_loan_arranger Avatar for x_salem_x

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: