CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) — The West Virginia Senate on Monday postponed the impeachment trial of a state Supreme Court justice after a judge who was to preside over the trial did not show up.
The trial of Justice Margaret Workman was to begin Monday, but Acting Chief Justice Paul Farrell was absent. Farrell said previously that Thursday’s ruling by a group of judicial stand-ins blocking the Senate trial prevented him from participating. The state constitution requires a presiding officer’s presence for the trial.
Given that and some lingering questions, the Senate voted 29-1 to adjourn.
Workman won a reprieve last week when the acting Supreme Court justices ruled her trial would violate the state constitution’s separation of powers clause. The acting justices also noted the justices’ due process was violated when the state House of Delegates did not follow through on its earlier mandate to approve an overall impeachment resolution.
Senate Judiciary Chairman Charles Trump, a Republican from Morgan County, suggested Monday the court should reconsider the House portion of its opinion and that House leaders should answer to the court, not the Senate.
The five acting justices are circuit judges who were appointed after Workman, Justice Beth Walker and Farrell stepped aside from hearing Workman’s case. Farrell had been appointed to hear cases in place of suspended Justice Allen Loughry. Justice Menis Ketchum resigned before the House impeachment vote took place and Justice Robin Davis retired immediately after the vote.
Workman, Davis, Loughry and Walker were impeached by the House in August over questions involving lavish office renovations that evolved into accusations of corruption, incompetence and neglect of duty.
Walker was cleared of an impeachment charge at her Senate trial earlier this month. Davis has asked a federal court to halt her impeachment trial later this month. Loughry’s impeachment trial is set for November.
Loughry was convicted of 11 criminal counts in federal court last week, including using state cars and gas cards for his personal benefit, making false statements, mail fraud and witness tampering. Ketchum pleaded guilty in August to a fraud charge related to his use of a state vehicle and gas card related to a 2014 golf trip to Virginia.
Wait - I understood the WV impeachments to be a political power grab. But actual crimes were committed in the form of misusing and misreporting funds?
It is a pure power grab. The claims that the funds were mis-used are merely opinion. Upkeep of public buildings is expensive. The sums spent by the judges are not excessive by the standards set by the legislature.
This is all about being able to replace democrats with republicans who will support the GOP’s planned gerrymander etc.
Webster’s Dictionary
“Clusterfuck” - see WV Supreme Court Justice Purge.
Republicans should be wary of lowering the bar on judicial impeachment.
It tells us something about the quality of people the Republicans push for judgeships. McConnell has packed the courts with low quality lawyers. In one case the chap was so unqualified that he could not deal with the questions asked of him. At least he had the good sense to withdraw. Meanwhile McConnell is enjoying an addition to his paycheck and a not very comfortable spot in Trump’s back pocket… His wife is in the Trump cabinet and on the government payroll !!!