Boeing Pulls 2019 Forecast Over 737 Max 8 Uncertainty, Suspends Stock Buybacks

A Boeing 737 MAX 8 airplane being built for India-based Jet Airways lands following a test flight, Wednesday, April 10, 2019, at Boeing Field in Seattle. Flight test and other non-passenger-bearing flights of the plane continue in the Seattle area where the plane is manufactured, as a world-wide grounding the the 737 MAX 8 continues, following fatal crashes of MAX 8's operated by Ethiopian Airlines and Lion Air. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
FILE - In this April 10, 2019, file photo a Boeing 737 MAX 8 airplane being built for India-based Jet Airways lands following a test flight at Boeing Field in Seattle. Boeing Co. reports earnings Wednesday, April 24.... FILE - In this April 10, 2019, file photo a Boeing 737 MAX 8 airplane being built for India-based Jet Airways lands following a test flight at Boeing Field in Seattle. Boeing Co. reports earnings Wednesday, April 24. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File) MORE LESS
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Boeing is pulling its 2019 forecast over 737 Max uncertainty and says it’s suspending its stock buybacks.

The aerospace giant also provided first quarter results on Wednesday that beat Wall Street’s estimates.

Boeing Co. said its previously issued full-year guidance didn’t account for 737 Max impacts. It plans to issue a new guidance at a future date. Investors and consumers have been keeping a close eye on Boeing due to two deadly crashes involving the 737 Max. The two crashes have damaged the company’s reputation for safety, caused the worldwide grounding of about 370 Boeing 737 Max airliners, and raised questions about the U.S. government’s approval of the plane in 2017.

Boeing posted an adjusted profit of $3.16 per share on revenue of $22.92 billion. Analysts surveyed by FactSet expected Boeing to report adjusted earnings of $3.19 per share on revenue of $22.94 billion. Both of those figures have come down considerably in the past month.

The company provided few clues about the fate of its best-selling plane and when it might fly again.

It said Wednesday it is making steady progress on the path to final certification for a software update for the 737 MAX, with over 135 test and production flights of the software update complete. The company said it continues to work closely with global regulators and our airline partners to comprehensively test the software and finalize a robust package of training and educational resources.

Boeing hit its numbers, but that is secondary to two crashes. Investigations into crashes in Indonesia and Ethiopia have implicated an automated flight-control system that erroneously pushed the noses of the planes down in response to bad readings from sensors. Boeing began working on a software update to the system more than five months ago.

When the market closed Tuesday, Boeing Co. shares stood 4% higher than before the October crash of a 737 Max operated by Indonesia’s Lion Air. After a slump, they skyrocketed from late December until early March when another 737 Max crashed, this one operated by Ethiopian Airlines.

Analysts treated the Lion Air crash off the coast of Indonesia as a one-time event and noted confidently that Boeing was working on a software fix.

Even with a mild sell-off since the March crash, the shares are still up 16% in 2019, barely trailing the 17% gain in the Standard and Poor’s 500.

In premarket trading, the stock edged up less than 1%.

Investors believe the market for jetliners will remain strong for many years and airlines don’t have much choice for big planes — Boeing and Airbus form a duopoly, and both have huge order backlogs.

CEO Dennis Muilenburg said the company has conducted 120 test flights of the upgraded software, and only needs a final certification flight with FAA personnel on board. That flight is expected any day.

Last week, an expert panel of the Federal Aviation Administration judged that a software fix to the Max would be “operationally suitable,” and that airline pilots familiar with previous versions of the 737 won’t need additional time in flight simulators to learn about the new software that is unique to the Max.

Jim Corridore, an airline analyst for CFRA Research, said that while Boeing still has much work to do, the FAA panel’s determination “shows that the return of the plane to flying is now a ‘when’ question rather than ‘if’ … we remain firm in our view that Boeing will survive this with its order book largely intact.”

Some analysts do see long-term risks to Boeing, however. The company has temporarily cut production of 737s, which means cash will be delayed until deliveries of new planes resume. It also faces a growing list of lawsuits by families and shareholders.

Goldman Sachs analyst Noah Poponak is surprised that investors seem to expect a “relatively benign” outcome of the Max saga.

Airbus could raise production, Poponak wrote in a recent note to clients, and the flying public, airlines and several countries are viewing the Max with more caution.

“We see a risk that lasts in the order book moving forward over the next few years,” he said.

Latest News

Notable Replies

  1. Avatar for sanni sanni says:

    See: dramatic results of deregulation and how it is ALWAYS good for business, and thus always good for the public.

    ~cough, cough~

  2. The high cost of …not buying the upgrade package?

    The Invisible Hand of The Marketplace does NOT mess around! Isn’t Capitalism a gas?

    Neither Lion Air Flight 610, which crashed in 2018, nor Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302, which crashed on March 10 of this year, had either the so-called angle of attack indicator or the disagree light, which Boeing sells as upgrades to airlines.

  3. Avatar for noonm noonm says:

    Boeing is pulling its 2019 forecast over 737 Max uncertainty and says it’s suspending its stock buybacks.

    They are going to need that money for the lawsuits. All the lawsuits.

  4. What works in BA’s favor is that both BA and Airbus are maxed out in narrow body jetliner production capacity, so any B737 Max cancellations will require a 6-7 year wait for A320 family deliveries to occur.

    Second, the A320 is the first FBW commercial transport and has had a number of flight control related crashes and anomalies which could have been fatal, including an uncommanded 45 degree roll on takeoff in NY that clipped a light pole and almost resulted in a crash in just the past month.

    Flying is safer than any other form of travel, but it is not entirely risk free. BA will get the B737 Max back in the air soon enough, but will suffer both financial and reputational consequences. How long these issues will last is just speculation at this point.

  5. Fundamentally flawed design, not sure they can software their way out of this. Maybe next time, instead of a rush job to match the competitor, focus on building an airframe which actually has a proper balance between the engine size/positioning and the rest of the airframe.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

9 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system Avatar for sedonaz Avatar for UnfadingGreen Avatar for sanni Avatar for greylady Avatar for rapier Avatar for bboerner Avatar for jasan Avatar for noonm Avatar for castor_troy Avatar for justruss Avatar for devonessex Avatar for thomaspaine

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: