Analysis: Even MS Voting ‘Irregularities’ Are Too Few To Contest Runoff Results

Austin Barbour, a senior advisor with U.S. Sen. Thad Cochran's reelection campaign responds to the voting irregularities allegations made by state Sen. Chris McDaniel, R-Ellisville, and a number of his supporters, at... Austin Barbour, a senior advisor with U.S. Sen. Thad Cochran's reelection campaign responds to the voting irregularities allegations made by state Sen. Chris McDaniel, R-Ellisville, and a number of his supporters, at a news conference in Jackson, Miss., Wednesday, July 2, 2014. Barbour challenged McDaniel and his supporters to go "put up or shut up," with evidence to prove the allegations of illegal voting. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis) MORE LESS

An analysis by Mississippi’s Clarion Ledger suggests that state Sen. Chris McDaniel (R-MS) may not have found enough evidence to overturn the results of the runoff election in which he lost the runoff primary to incumbent Sen. Thad Cochran (R-MS).

The analysis on Tuesday followed Cochran’s campaign releasing its own tally of votes that seem to be invalid in the runoff. A day earlier McDaniel’s lawyer, Mitch Tyner, said that the McDaniel campaign and McDaniel supporters had found thousands of irregular ballots and projected that they would find enough invalid ballots to close the margin by which Cochran beat McDaniel in the runoff.

Austin Barbour, a top adviser for Cochran’s re-election campaign, released its own tallies of questionable ballots, through the campaign’s own county-by-county search.

“As you will see, the numbers contained in this review are drastically lower than the wild claims made by the McDaniel campaign,” Barbour (pictured) said.

McDaniel’s campaign has not provided specifics on what they’ve found, the Clarion Ledger’s Sam Hall wrote.

“McDaniel’s campaign needs to start making an actual fact-based campaign of accusations if he is going to move forward with his challenge,” Hall wrote.

That doesn’t mean that there weren’t voting irregularities in the runoff, Hall added. Hall continued:

There’s clearly some irregularities out there. There may even be some instances where the Cochran campaign violated federal campaign finance laws. However, none of that would lead to an overturned election. It just wouldn’t, as hard as that may be to accept.

The only thing that will lead to an overturned election is either proof of voter fraud or convincing a judge that the election was so poorly managed the results cannot be trusted. So far, even the circumstantial evidence presented has fallen apart under scrutiny. Now it’s time for hard numbers.

The McDaniel campaign hopes that it can find enough evidence to initiate a new election. But legal experts have cast doubt about whether McDaniel could actually get another election to happen.

27
Show Comments

Notable Replies

  1. “McDaniel’s campaign needs to start making an actual fact-based campaign.” Why on earth would any GOP’er ever want to do that?

  2. Evidence! Since when did a republican need evidence to support charges of a scandal. All they have to do is yell scandal, and let the news media run with it, no evidence required.

  3. Why let the facts get in the way of a good faux-crisis?

  4. "“McDaniel’s campaign needs to start making an actual fact-based campaign of accusations if he is going to move forward with his challenge,” Hall wrote. "

    The only fact that actually matters at the end of the day. You lost the election McD… This is all just theater to strip the rubes of a few more $'s before you sail off into fox-commentator land, or failing that back to talk radio.

  5. Avatar for jw1 jw1 says:

    McDaniel campaign:
    Gawdammit! Shush now ya’ heah!
    We needs a week-- at least-- to Grift the ®ubes!
    Whoyathinks gonna’ pay these campaign debts? Us?

    jw1
    .

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

21 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for ajm Avatar for dr_coyote Avatar for fgs Avatar for druid800 Avatar for jw1 Avatar for mymy Avatar for Patriott Avatar for sergeant2 Avatar for edwardf56 Avatar for mcbain Avatar for sonsofares Avatar for progressiveoldman Avatar for alyoshakaramazov Avatar for sangsue Avatar for fitley Avatar for neal_anderthal Avatar for captaincommonsense Avatar for kitty Avatar for suicide_arsonist Avatar for nelsonrobison Avatar for occamsrazor2 Avatar for wrightwingnut Avatar for 62fender

Continue Discussion