TPM Reader CW (no, not that CW — a real person):
The swine flu saga is still in its infancy, but it’s reasonable based on past events to assume two things: 1) the eventual impact will be far less severe than you would think watching the news, and 2) there will be a wave of amateur and professional criticism of the media’s (and possibly governments’) supposed overreaction. Last time this happened, I was one of those people.
But, again assuming that those things prove true, that’s not what I’m going to take away from all this. I’m going to be pretty damn impressed. The first news reports of abnormal influenza patterns came on April 5, from remote towns in central Mexico. “Swine flu” entered our lexicon on April 21, when a CDC alert reported two cases in California. On April 23 it was confirmed that this new strain was responsible for the outbreak in Mexico.
Four days later, a massive global awareness and preparedness effort, developed largely as a result of previous threats like SARS and bird flu, has kicked into high gear. Less than a week after the first reports of a possible pandemic, the entire developed world is aware of the situation. So, can we turn on cable news without listening to Norah O’Donnell remind us to wash our hands every ten minutes? No. But that’s exactly what should be happening.
There was a bit of a scare this morning in lower Manhattan, when a 747 was seen flying low over the tip of the island with a fighter jet following nearby. It turns out it was a DOD photo op, taking one of the jets used for Air Force One and having some low-flying shots near like the Statue of Liberty. Apparently, all the key agencies like FAA were notified. Local authorities were apparently notified but with instructions not to pass the information on the general public.
In response to my earlier post on torture, a number of readers have written in to say that it’s not a matter of Cheney et al. being squeamish about using the word ‘torture’. It’s that there are specific statutes on the books in the US and internationally that make ‘torture’ a crime, with serious penalties. Everyone recognizes that; and they don’t want to be prosecuted. But I think my earlier point includes this reasoning behind the reluctance to identify torture as ‘torture’.
Being bold means taking responsibility for being bold. As I’ve argued before, I think the answer to the ticking time bomb rationale for torture is this: that in the extremely unlikely circumstance that government officials ever found themselves in that position of having a ticking time bomb ticking away, they might have to make the decision to break the law. Not fudge it or keep their actions hidden, but take the decision on their own responsibility that it was the best thing to do in the situation — despite it being wrong as a general matter — and then bring their decision to attention of the people and law enforcement authorities and throw themselves on the mercy of the public. Thomas Jefferson explored a similar question and argument for the position a president could find himself in when faced with extra-constitutional or even unconstitutional actions.
In any case, if your patriotism is such that in an extreme situation you’d risk your own liberty to defend the lives of Americans, that’s courage. But nothing else really cuts it.
More realistically, if these folks are really that tough, why not simply come and call for the repeal of American laws banning torture and the US withdrawal from international agreements doing the same?