Twitter: Way More Accounts Than We Thought Spread Russian Propaganda

The social media app Twitter is seen on a smartphone in front of a binary background, in Bydgoszcz, on August 7, 2016. (Photo by Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto) *** Please Use Credit from Credit Field ***
Start your day with TPM.
Sign up for the Morning Memo newsletter

Twitter underestimated the number of accounts spreading Russian propaganda by more than ten thousand, the company quietly disclosed late Friday.

A company spokesperson wrote on the Twitter blog that 50,258 automated accounts “identified as Russian-linked” had tweeted “election-related content during the election period.”

Twitter will individually email each of the 677,775 people who followed or retweeted a compromised account operated by or set to retweet posts from the Russian “troll farm” known at the time as the Internet Research Agency (IRA), the company said. The IRA was reportedly operating on orders from the Russian government.

Twitter’s initial report issued in September relied on a separate assessment by Facebook. It examined Facebook’s 450 compromised users and identified only 179 accounts in its initial assessment. Lawyers for both companies and Google endured public tongue-lashings by committees of both the House and the Senate last fall, who accused them f not doing enough to protect Americans from foreign propaganda.

An intelligence community assessment issued shortly before President Donald Trump’s inauguration said that Russian efforts to influence the election demonstrated a clear preference for Trump over Clinton, and included a multi-pronged disinformation effort across Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and Russia’s own state news service Russia Today, which made overtures to American political figures during the period. What effect the Russian-backed digital propaganda campaign had on the election has been hard to quantify.

Twitter also included a selection of imagery tweeted by the allegedly Kremlin-controlled Twitter feeds in its post. One image called for the arrest of George Soros, the founder of the progressive Open Society Foundation. Another showed a man in a t-shirt reading “Obama called me Clinger/ Hillary calls me Deplorable/ Terrorists call me Infidel/ Trump calls me AMERICAN”.

Twitter said it had identified “both more IRA and automated Russia-based accounts.” But the lion’s share of the new accounts in the current figures appear to be bots amplifying the posts of a relatively small handful of trolls, some 3,814 accounts run directly by the IRA. The 175,993 tweets from those accounts were spread far and wide by the network of automated tweeters supporting them.

The numbers are relatively small compared to overall Twitter usage, about which the company is cagey. Twitter has 157 million users, according to an estimate based on the company’s own metrics by tech reporters at Recode.

Latest Muckraker

Notable Replies

  1. Apparently the new hotness for the Russian bots and dumbfuck true believers is #releasethememo… whatever the fuck that means, I don’t speak “Fox and Fuckheads”

  2. Avatar for fuzz fuzz says:

    I personally notified Twitter this was happening during the election and offered to investigate at no cost to them, all I needed was firehose access (ability to access all Twitter public data in realtime). They weren’t interested.

  3. It is a memo prepared by Devin Nunes The Recused and his fellow GOP toadies on the House Intelligence Committee. The Dems weren’t involved. From Politico (see second link below):

    The memo, compiled by House Intelligence Committee chairman Devin Nunes and fellow Republicans on the panel, claims that senior federal officials abused a secret surveillance program, commonly known as FISA, to target the Trump campaign. It also alleges other federal law enforcement wrongdoing that some Republicans insist should lead to the firings of senior officials.

    We’ve heard the FISA stuff before. The surveillance targets foreigners, and the names of Americans that come up as part of the surveillance are redacted. Some US officials have the authority to request redacted names. It is not illegal to do so, but there are restrictions on how that information may be spread or used. The GOP is trying to cast routine operations as an anti-Trump conspiracy.

    In fight over Russia memo, Republicans have unusual ally – I think that should read “their usual ally”

    House Republicans clash over secret memo
    In this Politico item, they link to a wikileaks tweet that is soliciting and offering to match donations to a fund to reward anyone who provides the classified memo to wikileaks – just in case anyone still thinks that wikileaks is about freedom of information and isn’t taking sides in US politics.

  4. Okay so in other words…

    It’s nothing.

  5. Twitter will individually email each of the 677,775 people who followed or retweeted a compromised account operated by or set to retweet posts from the Russian “troll farm” known at the time as the Internet Research Agency (IRA), the company said.

    Approximately 666,666 of those people will be absolutely positive that Russians weren’t involved in any of the accounts.

Continue the discussion at forums.talkingpointsmemo.com

21 more replies

Participants

Avatar for system1 Avatar for ncsteve Avatar for blandsten Avatar for bluestatedon Avatar for cervantes Avatar for sonsofares Avatar for gr Avatar for ottnott Avatar for fuzz Avatar for nemo Avatar for theotherjim Avatar for bboerner Avatar for tena Avatar for junebug Avatar for pandastirfry Avatar for jacksonhts Avatar for greysea Avatar for coprophagoussmile Avatar for enhancedthespian Avatar for ohcomeonnow

Continue Discussion
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Deputy Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: