Appeals Court Reverses Ruling on Florida Vote Suppression Measure

Hans von Spakovsky’s legacy is still being felt down in Florida. From the AP:

Florida can temporarily enforce a law that disqualifies any voter registration where the Social Security or driver license numbers on the application can’t be matched with government databases, an appeals court ruled Thursday.

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta said a lower court shouldn’t have ordered a temporary injunction in December that prevented Florida from enforcing an anti-fraud law that dismissed applications when matches couldn’t be made.

As we reported last year, one of Spakovsky’s achievements while at the Justice Department was promoting this interpretation of the law: that states ought to reject voter applications if the data did not match driver’s license or Social Security records. Civil rights groups, calling the measure “disenfranchisement-by-bureaucracy,” sued to halt the law in an attempt to minimize the effect on the 2008 election. A newspaper investigation found that the measure resulted in tens of thousands of voters being rejected, the overwhelming majority of them minorities.

Back in December, a district court agreed with the argument by the groups — the NAACP, the Haitian-American Grassroots Coalition, and Southwest Voter Registration Education Project — that the law ought to be halted from going into effect while the lawsuit was decided. That decision was overturned yesterday.

“Yesterday’s ruling by the appellate court represents a setback for all eligible Floridians, particularly voters of color, who wish to register to vote and participate in the upcoming presidential elections,” said Elizabeth Westfall of Advancement Project, one of the attorneys for the groups. But Justin Levitt, counsel at the Brennan Center for Justice, said that the suit would go on and that “the trial court must now consider whether disenfranchising thousands of eligible citizens because of typos, is consistent with the U.S. Constitution.”