Opinions, Context & Ideas from the TPM Editors TPM Editor's Blog

Definitional Question

Now, Zack Roth thinks that it may not be right to call these guys 'birthers'. My sense though is that this is sort of a minor or perhaps even dissident sect within the birther movement. Sort of like Ismaili Islam -- a small but prominent branch of Shia Islam. Zack's angle seems to be that they're more like the Druze of Syria, Lebanon and Israel, who began as a dissident sect within Islam but are now, by consent of all parties, an entirely separate sect -- not part of Islam at all.

Who can help us settle this dispute?