In it, but not of it. TPM DC

The Three Hillary Book Stories Everyone Has Insisted On Writing This Week

Fqyuige8j7nrvulj6o5m
AP Photo / J. Scott Applewhite

So even the best reporters find themselves struggling to deliver a fresh take. Instead, coverage of Hillary's big week is falling into three identifiable tracts.

This Looks Like A Campaign!

This was the headline (before it was changed) from America's paper of record:

The New York Times was not alone.



"Clinton's book tour is widely seen as a rollout for her potential 2016 presidential campaign," noted Business Insider.

Alex Seitz-Wald at National Journal succinctly summarized the various angles of the book release and its 2016 implications:

Hillary Clinton's much anticipated book tour is here, and it's going to look a lot like a presidential campaign.

For a 2016-hungry media, the campaign simulacrum will be a chance to look for clues to a potential bid. For her legions of fans, it's a chance to see the former secretary of State up close and in the flesh. But for Clinton herself, the tour promoting Hard Choices will offer something more personal: a gut check.

"What she's going to be asking herself is, am I having fun? Am I enjoying this? Do I really want to do this again and potentially risk losing again?" said one former aide.

Book Signing Anecdotes!

National Journal reported that at least five reporters interviewed the man at the front of the line at a New York City Barnes and Noble to get his book signed by Hillary.

Politico reporter Maggie Haberman tweeted the rules for those getting a book signed:

A report on which earned a Drudge Report link:

The Times reported on an 11-year-old whose mother pulled her out of school to attend the signing. “I’m not going to remember the last Tuesday toward the end of my school year, but I’ll remember this,” the young political junkie told the newspaper.

And MSNBC produced this video on the Hillary Clinton "super fans" who showed up hours early to get a prime spot in line.

But The Book Itself Kinda Sucks!

The irony is that the actual product driving all this coverage has received tepid reviews at best. Politico's Mike Allen set the tone Monday, as he so often does:

"Hard Choices" is a newsless snore, written so carefully not to offend that it will fuel the notion that politics infuses every part of her life. In this book, like in "The Lego Movie" theme song, everyone is awesome!

"Hillary Clinton's Book Is Being Destroyed By Critics," Business Insider concluded, linking to Allen's panning as well as critical reviews from the New York Times and the New Republic.

Mark Halperin, champion of horse-race journalism and co-author of the now infamous "Game Change" about the 2008 presidential campaign, laid hard into the book Tuesday on MSNBC's "Morning Joe." He dismissed it as "tone deaf" and "cautious mush."

He also ripped its rollout -- and accompanying gaffes -- on Twitter.

About The Author

K4zw8el802c2lczjp9fi

Dylan Scott is a reporter for Talking Points Memo. He previously reported for Governing magazine in Washington, D.C., and the Las Vegas Sun. His work has been recognized with a 2013 American Society of Business Publication Editors award for Best Feature Series and a 2010 Associated Press Society of Ohio award for Best Investigative Reporting. He can be reached at dylan@talkingpointsmemo.com.