In it, but not of it. TPM DC

Why Extending The Obamacare Deadline Could Hurt Democrats In 2014

AP Photo

Here's why an enrollment extension could be bad for Democrats in the midterm elections. Insurers insist that an extension would skew their risk pools toward older, sicker people and force them to hike premiums for 2015 to make up for it -- and outside experts back them up on the actuarial risks. If that happened, the increased premium rates would likely be released some time in September -- October at the latest -- according to the guidance that the Obama administration has given to insurers.

So with less than two months until the election, "rate shock" associated with Obamacare could be dominating the news cycle. There's no way that would be good for the Democratic candidates, these industry sources argue.

"I guarantee that we're going to make that point to them," one source said.

Seven of the 10 Democratic senators who signed a letter advocating for an enrollment extension are up for reelection in 2014: Jeanne Shaheen (NH), Mark Begich (AK), Mark Pryor (AR), Mary Landrieu (LA), Kay Hagan (NC), Mark Udall (CO), and Tom Udall (NM).

The political variables at play are admittedly complex. Right now, it might make sense for those senators to endorse an enrollment extension. No one is happy with the marketplace rollout, and asking the White House to give people some relief would appear to have little downside at the moment.

But it's unclear if those senators have gamed this out to next fall, to the point outlined by the industry where that endorsement could potentially backfire. TPM asked several of the senators' offices for comment, but they declined to discuss the issue in detail.

"Senator Shaheen understands that to make healthcare affordable, we need as many people in the insurance markets as possible," Shaheen spokeswoman Elizabeth Kenigsberg said in an emailed statement to TPM. "She believes that extending the enrollment period in light of the problems with the marketplace website is the practical fix to give consumers more time to enroll in coverage."

Matt Canter, deputy executive director for the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, acknowledged to TPM that this could be "a legitimate concern" for Democratic candidates. But he asserted that the party's position of fixing Obamacare would be more appealing to voters than the Republican push to dismantle the law.

"Voters don't make any decision in a vacuum. It's a vote between the two people on the ballot and the contrast between those two people," Canter said. "All the polls show that the Republican alternative is polling at an all-time low. A majority wants to make this law work."