Federal Judge Cites Frank Underwood In An Actual Ruling

|
September 11, 2014 5:57 p.m.

A federal judge quoted fictional “House of Cards” character Frank Underwood in an opinion released Thursday for aptly articulating a “longstanding and fundamental principle of American law.”

U.S. District Court Judge Timothy S. Black struck down an Ohio law banning false statements about political candidates, decreeing it unconstitutional. The judge argued that although “[l]ies have no place in the political arena,” it’s not the role of the government to police the accuracy of statements.

The judge went on to quote Underwood β€” the calculating, murderous politician portrayed by Kevin Spacey in the popular Netflix drama β€” in his 25-page opinion:

What then is the alternative? The United States Supreme Court has clearly signaled the answer. For starters, the Supreme Court held flatly in 2012 that: “The remedy for speech that is false is speech that is true. This is the ordinary course in a free society. The response to the unreasoned is the rational; to the uninformed, the enlightened; to the straight-out lie, the simple truth.” United States v. Alvarez … The more modern recitation of this longstanding and fundamental principle of American law was recently articulated by Frank Underwood in House of Cards: “There’s no better way to overpower a trickle of doubt than with a flood of naked truth.”

The case dates back to a 2010 billboard pushed by the anti-abortion group Susan B. Anthony List claiming that (now defeated) Rep. Steve Driehaus (D-OH) supported taxpayer-funded abortions by voting for Obamacare. After a long battle in the courts about whether the Ohio law threatened the right to free speech, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously this year that SBA List had standing to move forward and have its case heard on the merits.

The judge’s citation of Underwood was noticed by Adam Liptak of the New York Times and Byron Tau of Politico.

Newsletters
Get TPM in your inbox, twice weekly.
Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.
Latest Livewire
Comments are now Members-Only

Non-members are still able to read comments, but will no longer be able to participate. To join the conversation, sign up now and get:

30% Off Annual Prime Membership

TPM strives to build as inclusive a community as financially possible. We offer FREE memberships to those experiencing financial hardship and FREE memberships for students.

View all options
Comments
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: