In Striking Down Utah’s Gay Marriage Ban, Judge Gives Scalia Big Bear Hug

In a bit of irony — and perhaps trolling — the federal judge who struck down Utah’s ban on gay marriage Friday repeatedly cited U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia’s dissent from this summer’s ruling on the federal Defense of Marriage Act.

In doing so, U.S. District Judge Robert Shelby wasn’t exactly turning Scalia’s words against him but rather fulsomely embracing the dire warnings Scalia had given about what the Supreme Court majority’s decision meant for the future legal challenges to state laws that attempt to preserve traditional marriage.

From beginning to end of Shelby’s opinion Friday, in four different citations scattered throughout, he favorably cited Scalia’s dissent, buttressing his legal analysis with Scalia’s warnings.

In its 5-4 decision in June, the Supreme Court held that the federal Defense of Marriage Act was unconstitutional because it violated individual liberty, but did not rule that all state bans on gay marriage were unconstitutional. In his dissent in the case, United States v. Windsor, Scalia wrote that the majority opinion’s logic would inevitably lead to the state bans being declared unconstitutional as well:

In my opinion, however, the view that this Court will take of state prohibition of same-sex marriage is indicated beyond mistaking by today’s opinion. As I have said, the real rationale of today’s opinion … is that DOMA is motivated by “bare… desire to harm” couples in same-sex marriages. How easy it is, indeed how inevitable, to reach the same conclusion with regard to state laws denying same-sex couples marital status.

Shelby nodded in rhetorical agreement with Scalia’s reasoning after citing that quote in his decision.

“The court agrees with Justice Scalia’s interpretation of Windsor,” Shelby wrote, “and finds that the important federalism concerns at issue here are nevertheless insufficient to save a state-law prohibition that denies the Plaintiffs their rights to due process and equal protection under the law.”

Utah Gay Marriage Ruling

Dear Reader,

When we asked recently what makes TPM different from other outlets, readers cited factors like honesty, curiosity, transparency, and our vibrant community. They also pointed to our ability to report on important stories and trends long before they are picked up by mainstream outlets; our ability to contextualize information within the arc of history; and our focus on the real-world consequences of the news.

Our unique approach to reporting and presenting the news, however, wouldn’t be possible without our readers’ support. That’s not just marketing speak, it’s true: our work would literally not be possible without readers deciding to become members. Not only does member support account for more than 80% of TPM’s revenue, our members have helped us build an engaged and informed community. Many of our best stories were born from reader tips and valuable member feedback.

We do what other news outlets can’t or won’t do because our members’ support gives us real independence.

If you enjoy reading TPM and value what we do, become a member today.

Latest Dc
Comments
Masthead Masthead
Founder & Editor-in-Chief:
Executive Editor:
Managing Editor:
Associate Editor:
Investigations Desk:
Reporters:
Newswriter:
Editor at Large:
General Counsel:
Publisher:
Head of Product:
Director of Technology:
Associate Publisher:
Front End Developer:
Senior Designer: