Neu said he doesn't know why he circled the verse, according to the report. He was reportedly trying to be funny.
"In hindsight, maybe it wasn't the smart thing to do, you know," he said. "I should have been more careful where I left it, or whatever."
Dave Bristow, of the Manatee County Sheriff's Office's Public Information Unit, told TPM Neu was suspended for what he did at work, adding that he feels the incident is being misreported by other media.
"It's not the sort of thing that we allow (people) to do at work," Bristow said, declining to comment further.
Neu was originally going to show the verse to others in the office, but he said he got too busy and forgot.
"Until today, I completely forgot about it other than I know what the prayer was," Neu said in an interview contained in the police report. "It was not intended for anybody. It was not meant to be anybody. It's not a threat on the president."
According to the report, Neu had said around the 2008 presidential election he hoped Obama wouldn't be elected.
Neu was suspended for 26 hours over the "Obama Prayer."
Read the police report: