Opinions, Context & Ideas from the TPM Editors TPM Editor's Blog

Zero Dark Thirty & Torture

Chuqgxhxlywr6v5p3cxj
AP Photo

Given the intense controversy that emerged from the film and the fact that even US Senators got up in arms about it, I expected the film to be a strong endorsement of torture or at least to make a pretty clear argument that it was torture that led us to bin Laden. But when I saw the actual film it didn't really seem that way at all. It seemed at least more ambiguous than I'd been led to believe.

A number of articles I'd read referred to the scene where the lead character played by Jessica Chastain watches President Obama definitively say the US was out of the torture business. The descriptions I'd heard had Chastain's character either literally or metaphorically shaking her head at the President's naiveté and wrongheadedness. But the scene seemed more flat and noncommittal in the actual viewing.

Now, I'm not saying that some key parts of the movie couldn't be construed that way. And I think it's quite possible that I was so prepped by the media and commentary to see these pro-torture themes that in the event it was just underwhelming. I might well have reacted differently if I hadn't come into it with such a strong set of expectations.

But I'm curious: did anyone else have this same reaction?